Staff was friendly. They made an error and served us a wrong item but did remake the food quickly unfortunatelydid leave the wrong item on the bill i paid. But we were in a hurry at the end and i didnt notice or say anything. The staff was very gracious im very sure it was an oversight and it would have just came right off. There were plenty of folks inside who clearly were regulars so im not trying to relay a bad review just oir experience. Another dinner item ordered was a vegetable chimichanga. It could be me but it just wasn't anything I'd get again. I really wanted to like it. Maybe because it was the end of the night. Anyway unfortunately unless someone else wants to go here this probably won't be one of my 1st suggestions. For now anyway.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Jersey Joe
Great place located in a busy strip mall in the middle of wyckoff. It's in the same shopping center that has Marshalls on one end and sbux on the other. Kids always love this place and staff is always super friendly and smiling. Never had a bad meal .Food is always pretty quick and the drinks have a decent pour. Happy to have this establishment in the middle of town!
Joseph Gonzalez
Kid-friendliness: My daughter loves this place ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Michelle C.
it tastes good but it's not a quesadilla. it's soggy ans not crunchy i had to se a fork and knife because i can't pick it up without the stuffing fall off
Alena P.
My husband took me and my sons here for a birthday lunch. I absolutely loved the place. The food was great. The best part of the experience was the service. The server (I'm awful with names unfortunately so didn't catch her name) was super bubbly and did an amazing job. The manager came out to make sure the customers were happy with their experience. The hosts were very friendly. Just overall a very welcoming place. We'll definitely be back!
Carol Wilmot
Not great beans stuck together with no spice or flavor
Mike Vanni
Excellent service and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dana K.
Service was great! Pat, the manager, personally came to our table to check if everything was good and had a friendly chat with us. We had a fun experience especially with the live music. Also, the food was delicious!
Daniel L.
Pat Fitapelli is the manager there, and he is quite simply exceptional. The food is quite good at a reasonable price, but Pat walks around the place ensuring that everyone has a wonderful experience. I am so extraordinarily grateful to have this restaurant within a reasonable distance. I got the triple combo, and the pulled chicken just MELTS in your mouth. Thank you to Pat for being simply AMAZING!
Came here for carry out. Had drinks while we waited for our order. Nice folks although the margarita was a sweet mess. Got home with our order and half of mine was missing. Sides that they specifically asked us about were all wrong. My husbands fajitas did not appear to be grilled and were drowned in a sweet sauce. We’ve been coming to this place for years but cannot recommend based on this visit :(
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Morris Goldberg
Great food and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chips and Salsa
Jerry G.
Our go to for Mexican food. It's one of the first restaurants we found when we moved to the area 27 years ago and it still never disappoints. It's a friendly place that always makes you feel welcomed. .
Yajaira Goncalves
Love this
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Kerry B.
I have been coming to blue moon for my whole life as a local Wyckoff resident and I am never disappointed! The staff is always quick, friendly, and there are tons of staffers working. The refried beans are the best I've ever had and same with the quesadilla! I'd recommend anything with chicken - tacos, quesadilla, etc. My lifelong favorite is the baja chicken tacos. Only caution is that it can get a bit loud inside if you're eating during a popular window, but it's part of the blue moon experience :)
One of NJ's best Mexican
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Staff was friendly. They made an error and served us a wrong item but did remake the food quickly unfortunatelydid leave the wrong item on the bill i paid. But we were in a hurry at the end and i didnt notice or say anything. The staff was very gracious im very sure it was an oversight and it would have just came right off. There were plenty of folks inside who clearly were regulars so im not trying to relay a bad review just oir experience. Another dinner item ordered was a vegetable chimichanga. It could be me but it just wasn't anything I'd get again. I really wanted to like it. Maybe because it was the end of the night. Anyway unfortunately unless someone else wants to go here this probably won't be one of my 1st suggestions. For now anyway.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Great place located in a busy strip mall in the middle of wyckoff. It's in the same shopping center that has Marshalls on one end and sbux on the other. Kids always love this place and staff is always super friendly and smiling. Never had a bad meal .Food is always pretty quick and the drinks have a decent pour. Happy to have this establishment in the middle of town!
Kid-friendliness: My daughter loves this place ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
it tastes good but it's not a quesadilla. it's soggy ans not crunchy i had to se a fork and knife because i can't pick it up without the stuffing fall off
My husband took me and my sons here for a birthday lunch. I absolutely loved the place. The food was great. The best part of the experience was the service. The server (I'm awful with names unfortunately so didn't catch her name) was super bubbly and did an amazing job. The manager came out to make sure the customers were happy with their experience. The hosts were very friendly. Just overall a very welcoming place. We'll definitely be back!
Not great beans stuck together with no spice or flavor
Excellent service and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Service was great! Pat, the manager, personally came to our table to check if everything was good and had a friendly chat with us. We had a fun experience especially with the live music. Also, the food was delicious!
Pat Fitapelli is the manager there, and he is quite simply exceptional. The food is quite good at a reasonable price, but Pat walks around the place ensuring that everyone has a wonderful experience. I am so extraordinarily grateful to have this restaurant within a reasonable distance. I got the triple combo, and the pulled chicken just MELTS in your mouth. Thank you to Pat for being simply AMAZING!
Restaurantji Recommends
Came here for carry out. Had drinks while we waited for our order. Nice folks although the margarita was a sweet mess. Got home with our order and half of mine was missing. Sides that they specifically asked us about were all wrong. My husbands fajitas did not appear to be grilled and were drowned in a sweet sauce. We’ve been coming to this place for years but cannot recommend based on this visit :(
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Great food and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chips and Salsa
Our go to for Mexican food. It's one of the first restaurants we found when we moved to the area 27 years ago and it still never disappoints. It's a friendly place that always makes you feel welcomed. .
Love this
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
I have been coming to blue moon for my whole life as a local Wyckoff resident and I am never disappointed! The staff is always quick, friendly, and there are tons of staffers working. The refried beans are the best I've ever had and same with the quesadilla! I'd recommend anything with chicken - tacos, quesadilla, etc. My lifelong favorite is the baja chicken tacos. Only caution is that it can get a bit loud inside if you're eating during a popular window, but it's part of the blue moon experience :)