Good business for an American company. I live out of the country because of political reasons, and the quality is impeccable. God help the USA. I know most people never leave the USA, but there is an amazing world out there....it would open your eyes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gluten Free Chocolate Cake Peanut Butter Buttercream Filling with White Buttercream on the Exterior
Jorrell Haas (J)
We have a wedding coming up in march and we were looking for a caterer to supply us with confections. We sampled their food at Tincan Alley as the storefront caught my Fiancée's eye. At the time she likes it very much and we had our wedding coordinator arrange a sampling for us to bring home. At the house we tried multiple dishes, brownies, mouse and a couple others. At that point we had a good idea of what we wanted and generally liked the food and their various gluten free options as my Fiancée and my Father both have celiac disease. The issue that cropped up was we found the dishes to be overly sweet to our palate and decided we needed to see about lowering the sugar content. So we had our coordinator contact them and see about making the dishes less sweet. We unfortunately were met with a less than positive response. They flat out refused to make any alterations to their recipes. This was surprising to us because they're a custom bakery, made to order supposedly but only if they agreed with you. Bit confused by this due to them being a locally owned business, non corporate so I guess it's really not made to order as we thought. We could understand this if they were a corporate due to them having specific guidelines set by the home office. So at the end of the day we decided to take our business somewhere else, the food was pretty good besides the overall sweetness but their refusal to make the desserts to the buyers requests totally soured us on ever trying them again. We never went into the main store at uptown, just Tincan Alley so I can't speak for the overall atmosphere of the bakery itself. That location was fine however, just like any other store in the alley. I'm not pushing people away from them as everyone's tastes are different. I do want to highlight the lack of cooperation on their part to make any alterations to their recipes. You pretty much have to take what they give you and like it, can't adjust the flavor profile to the customers preferences.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
PunkH
Work brought them in. Best lemon dessert I've probably ever had. Get the lemon cupcake, mentally thank me later.
Mailani Neal
Cake Fetish catered our cakes for our wedding and the cakes were perfect! We ordered two quarter sheet cakes + a personal cake for ourselves. All three cakes were DELICIOUS. They were able to provide us with a vegan option and a gluten free option for our guests' dietary restrictions.
Cake Fetish and Ashley absolutely saved us when our original dessert caterer fell through. Ashley was a great communicator and helped us have the perfect cakes for our special day. We cannot thank them enough.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Elite Michael
Cake fetish did an amazing job on our wedding cake. Its exactly what we had asked for and they delivered it right on time. Thank you so much for being prompt and delivering us the cake of our dreams.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nancy Duran
I ordered the coffee cake for my daughters birthday and it was awful. I was so excited to try it but it was sooo dry! All buttercream with barely any cake. No one could eat it. Gave me a bad stomach ache. It looked like they filled a collapsed three layer cake with even more buttercream. I will never buy a cake there. What a waste.
Rosie Jamael
Cake Fetish did an amazing job on our wedding cake! it was perfectly decorated, delicious abc the delivery made it that much easier for us on our wedding day!
We went with the lemon raspberry, vanilla raspberry and the buttercream cream cheese frosting!
The cake tasting was also a fun little date for me and my fiancée!
Dylan Friis
Yum they are great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dozen Mini Cupcake
T “Bella T” S
Before, in the past, the customer service and the variety of things other than Cupcakes was good. This time around, the customer service was lacking and variety
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 2
Irene Acosta
Not sure if bakery knows but it's listed under gluten free, it is not and not celiac safe.
Not sure if bakery knows but it's listed under gluten free, it is not and not celiac safe.
Dal Haw
Frosting was awful it was sickening blob of tasteless fat and sugar. I ordered a matcha strawberry the cake was the only thing palatable The strawberry frosting tasted sickening sweet lard it was horrible. If I was blind, I would not know the what the flavor wasb, it all tasted sickening sweet and nasty With no flavor whatsoever. literally almost puked. It was pretty and the matcha cake was good frosting so terrible. I live very close so I always wanted to try cake festish it's sad that it was so bad I had high hopes. The cake place on Paseo way better
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Danielle Castillo
I’m mad I spent my money there. The keto cupcakes were so small, they look like cup cake minis. The brownie left an awful taste in my mouth. It was just disappointing. Also there should be more than 3 keto options, that’s crazy. Also what is on the website is not in the store. I will never go there again, I would rather bake my own keto snacks!
Elizabeth Ross
We had family come to visit and they decided they wanted to do their gender reveal at our house. We called several bakeries to ask about the ability to do 6 cupcakes the same day and they were the only one that even tried to accommodate. They did it quickly and were so sweet! Their stock was low for the day (it was in the afternoon) but they worked to wow us! The cupcakes were fantastic and they even did special decorations on top of the cupcake with blue and pink sprinkles and a cute animal cookie! My family was so impressed with their customer service and their food! We will be back!
Catherine Dane
They were so accommodating of my requests and always have the best cakes and cupcakes!
Good business for an American company. I live out of the country because of political reasons, and the quality is impeccable. God help the USA. I know most people never leave the USA, but there is an amazing world out there....it would open your eyes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gluten Free Chocolate Cake Peanut Butter Buttercream Filling with White Buttercream on the Exterior
We have a wedding coming up in march and we were looking for a caterer to supply us with confections. We sampled their food at Tincan Alley as the storefront caught my Fiancée's eye. At the time she likes it very much and we had our wedding coordinator arrange a sampling for us to bring home. At the house we tried multiple dishes, brownies, mouse and a couple others.
At that point we had a good idea of what we wanted and generally liked the food and their various gluten free options as my Fiancée and my Father both have celiac disease. The issue that cropped up was we found the dishes to be overly sweet to our palate and decided we needed to see about lowering the sugar content.
So we had our coordinator contact them and see about making the dishes less sweet. We unfortunately were met with a less than positive response. They flat out refused to make any alterations to their recipes. This was surprising to us because they're a custom bakery, made to order supposedly but only if they agreed with you.
Bit confused by this due to them being a locally owned business, non corporate so I guess it's really not made to order as we thought. We could understand this if they were a corporate due to them having specific guidelines set by the home office. So at the end of the day we decided to take our business somewhere else, the food was pretty good besides the overall sweetness but their refusal to make the desserts to the buyers requests totally soured us on ever trying them again.
We never went into the main store at uptown, just Tincan Alley so I can't speak for the overall atmosphere of the bakery itself. That location was fine however, just like any other store in the alley. I'm not pushing people away from them as everyone's tastes are different. I do want to highlight the lack of cooperation on their part to make any alterations to their recipes. You pretty much have to take what they give you and like it, can't adjust the flavor profile to the customers preferences.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Work brought them in. Best lemon dessert I've probably ever had. Get the lemon cupcake, mentally thank me later.
Cake Fetish catered our cakes for our wedding and the cakes were perfect! We ordered two quarter sheet cakes + a personal cake for ourselves. All three cakes were DELICIOUS. They were able to provide us with a vegan option and a gluten free option for our guests' dietary restrictions.
Cake Fetish and Ashley absolutely saved us when our original dessert caterer fell through. Ashley was a great communicator and helped us have the perfect cakes for our special day. We cannot thank them enough.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Cake fetish did an amazing job on our wedding cake. Its exactly what we had asked for and they delivered it right on time.
Thank you so much for being prompt and delivering us the cake of our dreams.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered the coffee cake for my daughters birthday and it was awful. I was so excited to try it but it was sooo dry! All buttercream with barely any cake. No one could eat it. Gave me a bad stomach ache. It looked like they filled a collapsed three layer cake with even more buttercream. I will never buy a cake there. What a waste.
Cake Fetish did an amazing job on our wedding cake! it was perfectly decorated, delicious abc the delivery made it that much easier for us on our wedding day!
We went with the lemon raspberry, vanilla raspberry and the buttercream cream cheese frosting!
The cake tasting was also a fun little date for me and my fiancée!
Yum they are great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dozen Mini Cupcake
Before, in the past, the customer service and the variety of things other than Cupcakes was good. This time around, the customer service was lacking and variety
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 2
Not sure if bakery knows but it's listed under gluten free, it is not and not celiac safe.
Restaurantji Recommends
Not sure if bakery knows but it's listed under gluten free, it is not and not celiac safe.
Frosting was awful it was sickening blob of tasteless fat and sugar. I ordered a matcha strawberry the cake was the only thing palatable The strawberry frosting tasted sickening sweet lard it was horrible. If I was blind, I would not know the what the flavor wasb, it all tasted sickening sweet and nasty With no flavor whatsoever. literally almost puked. It was pretty and the matcha cake was good frosting so terrible. I live very close so I always wanted to try cake festish it's sad that it was so bad I had high hopes. The cake place on Paseo way better
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
I’m mad I spent my money there. The keto cupcakes were so small, they look like cup cake minis. The brownie left an awful taste in my mouth. It was just disappointing. Also there should be more than 3 keto options, that’s crazy. Also what is on the website is not in the store. I will never go there again, I would rather bake my own keto snacks!
We had family come to visit and they decided they wanted to do their gender reveal at our house. We called several bakeries to ask about the ability to do 6 cupcakes the same day and they were the only one that even tried to accommodate. They did it quickly and were so sweet! Their stock was low for the day (it was in the afternoon) but they worked to wow us! The cupcakes were fantastic and they even did special decorations on top of the cupcake with blue and pink sprinkles and a cute animal cookie! My family was so impressed with their customer service and their food! We will be back!
They were so accommodating of my requests and always have the best cakes and cupcakes!
Loading...