M'tucci's Twenty-Five

Usually I love this place but tonight I was very disappointed. They told me they were out of the special (encrusted cod) got a very soggy appetizer, one of the drinks seemed watered down, while the other lacked amaretto so we had to order a shot. The dish I was served was only supposed to be substituted with mahi mahi, but the dish was not just substituted that way. A friend of mine later went and ordered the same meal and they suddenly did have cod and the dish looked nothing like I ordered. The cost was much more also. Highly disappointed so much that I won’t return to
this location

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 2

Continue M'tucci's deserved reputation for high quality Italian food with some original twists on Old recipes. Busy Place, active bar, service is efficient but not talkative. Amazing value for high quality food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Poor service, just doing countless dishes 3 feet away while never refilling a drink nor taking an order. Snotty little cherub. Jalepeno app was slimy falling apart with undercooked chewy bacon. Pizza was floppy raw dough yet burnt edges ?! NOT worth the price

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

I placed a catering order with a pickup time scheduled for 5pm. When we arrived to pick it up at 4:55pm, we were told it would be ready in “just a few minutes”. After a 25 minute wait and reassurance that it was “almost done” multiple times, our food was finally brought out. I checked the bags before walking to my car, and good thing I did because two of the pans of food were missing. It wasn’t until 5:25pm that they brought out the last two pans to complete our order.

When we got home, there were many mistakes with the order. The sausages we ordered were not there, and we incorrectly received a bolognese pasta dish instead. The chicken scallopini was plain, and did not have the lemon caper butter sauce, feta, or tomatoes as said in the description. Each tray of chicken and steak was supposed to serve 10, but I’d say there was enough meat for closer to 8 people.

As for the food itself: we enjoyed the bistecca Italiano, polenta, Caesar salad, and pork bolognese pasta (though it was given in error). The alfredo pasta had good flavor but could have used more sauce. The asparagus was ok, but not very flavorful and the ends were woody. As mentioned above, the chicken was bland and missing the sauce.

All in all, this experience was far below the standards that I expected from M’tuccis. I would say that this was a misuse of my time and money

Food: 3

Service: 2

Great food, our server Maria was outstanding! Kinda noisy but otherwise everything was great!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loud dining room, food grossly over seasoned and I received one and one half shrimp in my entree...very disappointed.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 5

Great for get togethers

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Im giving 3 stars based on the first few minutes of our visit. Cole was rude and seemed annoyed when we asked for drinks. She then asked Kendall- who was excellent- to takeover. Food was great, but the service at the start of our visit affected the overall experience.

The menu is diverse, and the food was delicious! It took a little longer than expected, but overall, a great experience dining here.

Very good food. Decent prices!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

M'tuccis catered our company Christmas party and their service was excellent! Extremely budget friendly for the quality of food as well. :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food was amazing and staff was wonderful. Charles was our server and he had great suggestions and was so attentive and fun! Everything is craft so you can customize, and it’s ALL full of flavor. Loved this location, will be trying the others around town!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I work at a near by hotel and I stopped by this M’tuccis for the first time, the staff were excellent, very kind, and prompt. Food was amazing, our favorites were the sourdough board, the carrot ravioli special, and tiramisu. A little pricey, but for a scratch kitchen that is understandable. Worth the money and will definitely be coming back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

M’Tucci’s Twenty-Five is a fantastic spot whether you’re meeting for a business lunch, enjoying brunch, or just spending time with friends. The atmosphere strikes the perfect balance between professional and comfortable — stylish enough for client meetings, yet relaxed enough for a casual catch-up.

The staff is consistently attentive, and the service is paced well, which makes it easy to stay on schedule during the workday or linger a bit longer on weekends. Their menu offers a great mix of Tuscan-inspired dishes, lighter options, and brunch favorites, all crafted with the quality and attention to detail M’Tucci’s is known for.

Conveniently located off I-25, it’s an easy choice for both locals and visitors. Overall, M’Tucci’s Twenty-Five delivers reliable food, excellent service, and a versatile dining experience — highly recommended for business or leisure.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Maybe it's a different style of Italian food than I've had everywhere else but I just can't get into the style of pasta in the last 2 visits. The salad is great and the wine was good. Our server was friendly, efficient and helpful.