Food was good but way overpriced. Service was literally nonexistent and the lady at the register seemed like she was pissed we walked in. Definitely look at the prices before you order because they don’t seem comparable to any other pizzeria in the enchanted circle are. However the pizza was good.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Tony Cordray
Best Pizza in Anglefire.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Mountain Pizza
Duane Pogue
Great pizza! friendly people. Get the garlic butter on the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Barbara Thurston
Love the food and the smell when you walk in is awe inspiring! Makes you think of great pizza!!
E S
This place is really good. It’s in a small strip mall and I’ll get you out of a pinch if you need food in angel fire.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 3
Noah T.
Called 5 times never answered finally answered after 6th time finally answers I give my order, old lady at the front says it'll be done in 30 minutes. I show up 30 minutes later she says she forgot to put in the order and it'll be 20 more minutes. I wait the. crazy guys yells very obnoxiously loud that my order is ready. If you're thinking of coming here re-evaluate your life choices terrible place to go. Food was good.
The K.
This place is fantastic. Way better than Zeb's. Zeb's is so, so bad. The worst. I would rather go to prison for 6 months than eat there again. But Pizza Stop is great.
Grant R.
Really good pizza. If you're thinking about going to Zebs, re-evaluate your life, get a grip, and come here. Only place around with semi normal prices and good food.
Brittany Williams
Visiting from Texas to ski and this is the best pizza I have ever had. This was the best meal we had the whole time we were in angel fire. Would definitely eat again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark
Pepperoni pizza was fantastic, especially for being in such a small town. Best in Angel Fire and been eating it for 20-25 years!
A local staple, been eating this food since I was a teenager. They really make you feel appreciated and have the most amazing pizza ever! The staff is warm and friendly, and the restaurant has a style you have to see to really appreciateVegetarian options: Like any pizza, veggie it up!Parking: If you can't find a spot out front, the lot nextdoor always has room after the resort is closed
My go to pizza place for years, they treat me like family and the pizza is absolutely
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda M.
These are garlic "rolls".... Do not confuse them with garlic knots, per the delightful lady who makes them. They're quite good so don't overlook ordering them. Also be sure to get the ranch dressing. It's yummy! The pizza was pretty good. The sauce was good, and given the rolls, we probably should have just ordered the ultra thin crust. The regular crust is very doughy! Also, don't expect to eat there. This is primarily a take out, although you can get a beer while you wait.
Luke B
Pizza was delicious and very friendly people, I recommend it if you don't mind spending a little extra. be warned though that the menu pictures posted are outdated and the prices have gone up. "The Works" XL ran us about $45. Currently they also only offer take out.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ronald Green
The lady who answers the phone is incredibly sweet. However, I paid somewhere around $25 for some warmed up frozen jalapeño poppers and mozz sticks. The XL pizza isn’t even close to worth the money. $33 3-topping that looks like it’s the size of a medium. I realize the inches are on the menu but “XLG” is incredibly deceiving. It’s Angel Fire so the prices are jacked up, of course, but I wouldn’t come back.
Food was good but way overpriced. Service was literally nonexistent and the lady at the register seemed like she was pissed we walked in. Definitely look at the prices before you order because they don’t seem comparable to any other pizzeria in the enchanted circle are. However the pizza was good.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Best Pizza in Anglefire.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Mountain Pizza
Great pizza! friendly people. Get the garlic butter on the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love the food and the smell when you walk in is awe inspiring! Makes you think of great pizza!!
This place is really good. It’s in a small strip mall and I’ll get you out of a pinch if you need food in angel fire.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 3
Called 5 times never answered finally answered after 6th time finally answers I give my order, old lady at the front says it'll be done in 30 minutes. I show up 30 minutes later she says she forgot to put in the order and it'll be 20 more minutes. I wait the. crazy guys yells very obnoxiously loud that my order is ready. If you're thinking of coming here re-evaluate your life choices terrible place to go. Food was good.
This place is fantastic. Way better than Zeb's. Zeb's is so, so bad. The worst. I would rather go to prison for 6 months than eat there again. But Pizza Stop is great.
Really good pizza. If you're thinking about going to Zebs, re-evaluate your life, get a grip, and come here. Only place around with semi normal prices and good food.
Visiting from Texas to ski and this is the best pizza I have ever had. This was the best meal we had the whole time we were in angel fire. Would definitely eat again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pepperoni pizza was fantastic, especially for being in such a small town. Best in Angel Fire and been eating it for 20-25 years!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Rolls
Restaurantji Recommends
A local staple, been eating this food since I was a teenager. They really make you feel appreciated and have the most amazing pizza ever! The staff is warm and friendly, and the restaurant has a style you have to see to really appreciateVegetarian options: Like any pizza, veggie it up!Parking: If you can't find a spot out front, the lot nextdoor always has room after the resort is closed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Veggie Pizza, Cheese Sticks, Meat Mountain Pizza
My go to pizza place for years, they treat me like family and the pizza is absolutely
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
These are garlic "rolls".... Do not confuse them with garlic knots, per the delightful lady who makes them. They're quite good so don't overlook ordering them. Also be sure to get the ranch dressing. It's yummy! The pizza was pretty good. The sauce was good, and given the rolls, we probably should have just ordered the ultra thin crust. The regular crust is very doughy! Also, don't expect to eat there. This is primarily a take out, although you can get a beer while you wait.
Pizza was delicious and very friendly people, I recommend it if you don't mind spending a little extra. be warned though that the menu pictures posted are outdated and the prices have gone up. "The Works" XL ran us about $45. Currently they also only offer take out.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
The lady who answers the phone is incredibly sweet. However, I paid somewhere around $25 for some warmed up frozen jalapeño poppers and mozz sticks. The XL pizza isn’t even close to worth the money. $33 3-topping that looks like it’s the size of a medium. I realize the inches are on the menu but “XLG” is incredibly deceiving. It’s Angel Fire so the prices are jacked up, of course, but I wouldn’t come back.
Food: 1
Service: 4