Pizza was really great! Probably one of the best pizzas we’ve had in a while. I would recommend this to anyone looking for something more gourmet.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Max Payne
This pizza had some flop in the center but it was even better reheated! Solid spot 🍕
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brooklynn Brown
I’m leaving this review because the experience was unacceptable from both the staff and the owner.
Not only did a worker—but the actual owner—refuse to accept simple feedback, they responded with: “Are you sure nothing is wrong with your tastebuds?”
On 12/3/2025, your own employee admitted that you were short on ingredients to make the spinach artichoke pizza. Since there was no sauce available, they mixed something together last-minute that was completely watered down. (I can provide the transaction.)
Then today, we ordered a margherita pizza and had the exact same issue: no flavor, no seasoning, nothing. The owner claimed they personally made the pizza, but if that’s true, that makes it even worse — because it still tasted like nothing.
When we politely asked who we could speak to, the worker said, “I don’t know what to tell you.” The owner then got on the phone and said, “I can give you a refund if you never come back.”
That tells me everything I need to know about your customer service.
Instead of simply accepting feedback about improving flavor, we were met with disrespect, sarcasm, and defensiveness. And for a $35 pizza, basic quality and professionalism should be the bare minimum.
I’ll gladly take my business somewhere that values customers and consistency.
And just a reminder: In 2025, one bad review or one TikTok video of how you treat people can undo 11 years of business. What you put into the world comes back to you just as strongly.Fix it.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Dean Sakells
The pizza is fantastic about as close to new york pizza as you're going to possibly get, I was very surprised.It was that good
Anthony Mueller
Excellent pizza, I really like the crust
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kim Medeiros
I love stopping by Forrest's pizza for a slice 🍕. I think it's the best pizza in town 😜
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delilah Villegas
The service here was great!
Larry Hillesland
20+ years ago this was a coffe shop. Today it makes great pizza.
Leslie Rutkowski
We ordered a cheese pie and a salad. Both were excellent! The crust was good quality and not too thin, not too thick. Good sauce, good cheese. The salad was big and had romaine plus a bunch of veggies. Service was fast and very friendly. I would definitely recommend Forrest's, especially if you are craving an East coast style pizza.
This is the perfect take out spot! We grabbed 4 slices for a late lunch and we were SO impressed- literally my perfect slices! The spinach and artichoke pizza is surprisingly good and was my favorite of the bunch!! Can’t wait to be back!!
There is no indoor seating, but some tables and chairs outside patio style.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jerome Aroni
After the drive from Gila National Monument, I was hungry so I stopped at Silver City before heading back to El Paso. Came across this pizza place and ordered the Hawaiian pizza since I’m from Hawaii and want to try the pizza that matches where I came from ?. No disappoint it taste very good. Didn’t mind the wait because a lot of people were ordering and waiting so I know this place is gonna be good. Shoutout to my hiking friend who recommend me this spot to eat at. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emily Burton
Pizza was delicious and staff were really friendly. Small 2-topping pizza was about $25 but it was my dinner last night and my breakfast and lunch today. So, quite a bargain really!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kyle Knowshisgun
Great pizza! Well worth the wait during the busy hours
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni and Green Chile Slices, Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza was really great! Probably one of the best pizzas we’ve had in a while. I would recommend this to anyone looking for something more gourmet.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This pizza had some flop in the center but it was even better reheated! Solid spot 🍕
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’m leaving this review because the experience was unacceptable from both the staff and the owner.
Not only did a worker—but the actual owner—refuse to accept simple feedback, they responded with:
“Are you sure nothing is wrong with your tastebuds?”
On 12/3/2025, your own employee admitted that you were short on ingredients to make the spinach artichoke pizza. Since there was no sauce available, they mixed something together last-minute that was completely watered down. (I can provide the transaction.)
Then today, we ordered a margherita pizza and had the exact same issue: no flavor, no seasoning, nothing. The owner claimed they personally made the pizza, but if that’s true, that makes it even worse — because it still tasted like nothing.
When we politely asked who we could speak to, the worker said,
“I don’t know what to tell you.”
The owner then got on the phone and said,
“I can give you a refund if you never come back.”
That tells me everything I need to know about your customer service.
Instead of simply accepting feedback about improving flavor, we were met with disrespect, sarcasm, and defensiveness. And for a $35 pizza, basic quality and professionalism should be the bare minimum.
I’ll gladly take my business somewhere that values customers and consistency.
And just a reminder:
In 2025, one bad review or one TikTok video of how you treat people can undo 11 years of business. What you put into the world comes back to you just as strongly.Fix it.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
The pizza is fantastic about as close to new york pizza as you're going to possibly get, I was very surprised.It was that good
Excellent pizza, I really like the crust
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love stopping by Forrest's pizza for a slice 🍕. I think it's the best pizza in town 😜
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The service here was great!
20+ years ago this was a coffe shop. Today it makes great pizza.
We ordered a cheese pie and a salad. Both were excellent! The crust was good quality and not too thin, not too thick. Good sauce, good cheese. The salad was big and had romaine plus a bunch of veggies. Service was fast and very friendly. I would definitely recommend Forrest's, especially if you are craving an East coast style pizza.
Excellent pizza and salads
Restaurantji Recommends
Best Pizza in Silver City !
This is the perfect take out spot! We grabbed 4 slices for a late lunch and we were SO impressed- literally my perfect slices! The spinach and artichoke pizza is surprisingly good and was my favorite of the bunch!! Can’t wait to be back!!
There is no indoor seating, but some tables and chairs outside patio style.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
After the drive from Gila National Monument, I was hungry so I stopped at Silver City before heading back to El Paso. Came across this pizza place and ordered the Hawaiian pizza since I’m from Hawaii and want to try the pizza that matches where I came from ?. No disappoint it taste very good. Didn’t mind the wait because a lot of people were ordering and waiting so I know this place is gonna be good. Shoutout to my hiking friend who recommend me this spot to eat at. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was delicious and staff were really friendly. Small 2-topping pizza was about $25 but it was my dinner last night and my breakfast and lunch today. So, quite a bargain really!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza! Well worth the wait during the busy hours
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni and Green Chile Slices, Pepperoni Pizza
Loading...