I used to really love ordering from here, the pizza dough was amazing, the toppings were fresh, tasty, and plenty.But in my last few orders, I have been quite disappointed with the food. It's almost like I'm ordering from a completely different place. I know they have been having some phone issues and management was changing. I was told changing for the better. They were already great so I didn't see the need for the change but I also don't know what goes on in the background...but the pizza I received tonight was terrible.It really hurts for me to have to say this, but I'm nervous to order from here again because I want to get what I expect from such a great place.The pictures I have posted is a comparison between the exact same type of pizza, one picture being from July 2023, the other picture is the one I received tonight (March 21, 2024). You can tell the difference of quality from just the pictures...I am very disappointed... :(
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Bethany Isaksen
Honestly a shame because their garlic fingers are really good but the service is terrible. I ordered online and the shop was closed but the order/charge went through anyway. We called multiple days in a row until they were finally open (no mention of being closed online or their social media). When I finally got a hold of someone they gave me the number for their IT only to be told the store had to do the refund. When I called back they told me I had to come into the shop to get a refund. No apologies whatsoever.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
Robin Taylor
I used to love ordering from here, but in the past few weeks, it has been almost impossible to get someone on the phone to order. I call, and it just rings and rings, and when someone finally answers, she is pretty rude... she didn't even say it was Martino's Pizza, I thought I accidentally called someone's home phone by mistake. I had to ask if it was the pizza place. So they don't really answer the phone anymore, and they don't even tell you it is Martino's Pizza anymore.I still gave the food 5-stars because it is good... but if you are looking to call an order in, don't even bother.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
Dakoda Blackburn
Fish and chips are good. The donairs arent that great and the pizza is pretty mid. Overall it's an ok place to eat. I still miss Jake and Dino's nothing will ever substitute.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 5
jeff
Very quick service and best pizza there since Dino's was there.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Steve Steele
Tried to leave an online review with trip advisor but they put it on pizza hut?? Emailed back and forth with Charanpreet asking about an order for the guys/gals at work for Christmas lunch. They have a 39 dollar 2 large special. She helped me pick the ingredients to satisfy as many as possible. 1 all meat, 1 all veg, 1 works, 1 all pepperoni and a garlic fingers. All came with dipping sauce. She called as planned when it was ready and it was a great success. A bit of everything for everyone. Well done start to finish. Everyone loved it. Will do it again for work and myself.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
stoney 420
Im done from eating here last few times i been in to get a slice its been makeing me sick as a dog food is good but i dont know why its makeing me puke it all back
Food: 3
Joshua McDonald
I stopped by for a slice last night and the girl working told me she just took it over this month, so i went again today to give it a real try. The pizza is beautifully crisp and cooked, generous toppings, 3 sauces for no extra fee including what can only be described as a violent garlic sauce, a crisp crust with a bready interior, and the best part is the lady running the joint is a real nice woman who seems to be putting her heart into what she makes. Id love to see her succeed here so please give this place a try.Parking: Limited number of spots but its usually not full.Wheelchair accessibility: It might have a bit of a dip by tge door, but there are no stairs.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatlovers Slice, Medium Pizza Up to 3 Toppings and Medium Garlic Fingers
Craig Phillips
I tried this place earlier and enjoyed it. For some reason, I didn't have it again for a while. Mistake. Very good. Lesson learned.Try the paneer pizza.
Do you want a pizza that tastes a step up from your regular pizza joint? Martino's is great! And the garlic sauce is proper kebab shop garlic sauce! 10/10!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hawaiian 12
Martina Kluge
Amazing chicken wings,
and the burgers are to die for!
Lisa Dudka
I ordered a deluxe pizza with cups of garlic sauce on the side for pizza night with my son. I’m eating it right now —-it’s amazing. It was so good that I actually gave them a call. The crust has a nice crispness to it, nice balance of toppings and was delivered quickly with great customer service. Garlic sauce on the pizza is chef’s kiss.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Roman K
This place is an absolute underrated gem.Original pizzas and classics alike are all delicious. Their homemade garlic dip is unreal. The burgers and fries are SO GOOD! Chicken burger is also amazing. I’ve yet to have a less than awesome experience there. Garlic fingers are a banger as well.Their lunch deals are unbeatable, especially with todays insane food prices.
I used to really love ordering from here, the pizza dough was amazing, the toppings were fresh, tasty, and plenty.But in my last few orders, I have been quite disappointed with the food. It's almost like I'm ordering from a completely different place. I know they have been having some phone issues and management was changing. I was told changing for the better. They were already great so I didn't see the need for the change but I also don't know what goes on in the background...but the pizza I received tonight was terrible.It really hurts for me to have to say this, but I'm nervous to order from here again because I want to get what I expect from such a great place.The pictures I have posted is a comparison between the exact same type of pizza, one picture being from July 2023, the other picture is the one I received tonight (March 21, 2024). You can tell the difference of quality from just the pictures...I am very disappointed... :(
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Honestly a shame because their garlic fingers are really good but the service is terrible. I ordered online and the shop was closed but the order/charge went through anyway. We called multiple days in a row until they were finally open (no mention of being closed online or their social media). When I finally got a hold of someone they gave me the number for their IT only to be told the store had to do the refund. When I called back they told me I had to come into the shop to get a refund. No apologies whatsoever.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
I used to love ordering from here, but in the past few weeks, it has been almost impossible to get someone on the phone to order. I call, and it just rings and rings, and when someone finally answers, she is pretty rude... she didn't even say it was Martino's Pizza, I thought I accidentally called someone's home phone by mistake. I had to ask if it was the pizza place. So they don't really answer the phone anymore, and they don't even tell you it is Martino's Pizza anymore.I still gave the food 5-stars because it is good... but if you are looking to call an order in, don't even bother.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
Fish and chips are good. The donairs arent that great and the pizza is pretty mid. Overall it's an ok place to eat. I still miss Jake and Dino's nothing will ever substitute.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 5
Very quick service and best pizza there since Dino's was there.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Tried to leave an online review with trip advisor but they put it on pizza hut?? Emailed back and forth with Charanpreet asking about an order for the guys/gals at work for Christmas lunch. They have a 39 dollar 2 large special. She helped me pick the ingredients to satisfy as many as possible. 1 all meat, 1 all veg, 1 works, 1 all pepperoni and a garlic fingers. All came with dipping sauce. She called as planned when it was ready and it was a great success. A bit of everything for everyone. Well done start to finish. Everyone loved it. Will do it again for work and myself.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Im done from eating here last few times i been in to get a slice its been makeing me sick as a dog food is good but i dont know why its makeing me puke it all back
Food: 3
I stopped by for a slice last night and the girl working told me she just took it over this month, so i went again today to give it a real try. The pizza is beautifully crisp and cooked, generous toppings, 3 sauces for no extra fee including what can only be described as a violent garlic sauce, a crisp crust with a bready interior, and the best part is the lady running the joint is a real nice woman who seems to be putting her heart into what she makes. Id love to see her succeed here so please give this place a try.Parking: Limited number of spots but its usually not full.Wheelchair accessibility: It might have a bit of a dip by tge door, but there are no stairs.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatlovers Slice, Medium Pizza Up to 3 Toppings and Medium Garlic Fingers
I tried this place earlier and enjoyed it. For some reason, I didn't have it again for a while. Mistake. Very good. Lesson learned.Try the paneer pizza.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good its very good, great customer
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Awesome food, great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Do you want a pizza that tastes a step up from your regular pizza joint? Martino's is great! And the garlic sauce is proper kebab shop garlic sauce! 10/10!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hawaiian 12
Amazing chicken wings, and the burgers are to die for!
I ordered a deluxe pizza with cups of garlic sauce on the side for pizza night with my son. I’m eating it right now —-it’s amazing. It was so good that I actually gave them a call. The crust has a nice crispness to it, nice balance of toppings and was delivered quickly with great customer service. Garlic sauce on the pizza is chef’s kiss.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is an absolute underrated gem.Original pizzas and classics alike are all delicious. Their homemade garlic dip is unreal. The burgers and fries are SO GOOD! Chicken burger is also amazing. I’ve yet to have a less than awesome experience there. Garlic fingers are a banger as well.Their lunch deals are unbeatable, especially with todays insane food prices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5