Brooklyn's Best Pizza & Pasta

Lunch special deal was great. A little misled from the signs out front that said beer and wine however no liquor sales once went inside. Otherwise great pizza!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: White Pizza, Pizza by the Slice

Wish they had a kids meal. We asked for half buttered noodles. Was brought a full without notice, then when recieved bill informed the full was charged but asked for half, waitress said she would fix it, we gave her our card, she charged the full amount.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

The pizza was solid, as expected. The chicken, however, was disappointing—clearly processed and not real breast meat, so I’d steer clear of that. Pricing felt steep: processed chicken, fries, and a single pepperoni pizza came out to $42. I’d come back for the pizza alone, but only if I was in the mood to splurge.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pie

As a New Yorker who lived in Brooklyn, this pizza is nowhere near a good Brooklyn pizza. For starters, on both the round and Sicilian pies, there is little cheese. And they do something I've never seen in Brooklyn, or any other pizza joint - they splash tomato sauce across the slices. Perhaps to cover up that there is little cheese? And the dough for the round pie is not stretched thin like good Brooklyn pizza. It's too thick. The crust is alright, but where the little bit of cheese and way too much sauce sits, the dough/crust is just too thick. And as is typical for pizza joints in Vegas, if you want a true NY pizza crust, you have to ask for the pizza to be cooked well-done, otherwise you get a doughy crust. Might as well do to Domino's. $3.95 for a cheese slice and $4.95 for a Scillian (their spelling, not mine) slice. With tax, almost $10 for two slices that lack cheese and are smothered in the inexpensive ingredient, red sauce. I've had much better NY pizza in Vegas.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

First time here. The lasagne was good but the meatballs were ATROCIOUS. Somebody screwed up while preparing them, I'm not kidding. They were like mush that just dissolved in your mouth. They had no texture and hardly any MEAT in the actual meatball. It was 60-80% MILK and breadcrumbs, that is why they dissolved into mush. I've worked at 3 different local pizza joints and I've made meatballs countless times...these were made with a totally incorrect ratio of ingredients. The restaurant itself was extremely busy so I think somebody was either rushing into the process or ill-informed on how to cook meatballs and they made a serious mistake. The lasagne was good, the sauce was good, the meatballs were inedible. My dad (who will eat essentially ANYTHING) wouldn't even finish his meatball and ended up with diarrhea 10 minutes after eating. He is lactose intolerant, so that makes sense with my theory on the overused milk. I gave the rest of mine to my dog. Also, the guy who took my order over the phone seemed nice but he told me the meatballs come with garlic knots (so I decided not to order a side of garlic bread) and we did not receive any bread products whatsoever. Pretty disappointing experience overall. Kinda regret tipping $4.00. Had the food been outstanding, I would have come back here frequently in the future and tipped more generously, but I don't think I'll be coming back. Place feels like a gimmick.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

I got there. They didn't great nor did the give a menu. Gave the wrong drink. Stuck me shifty table. I had to walk out. I really wanted pizza. I will have to settle for El Pollo Loco. Very disappointed. Won't go back ever again.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

This place has the absolute worst service. I ordered a catering order for this past Saturday for a full try of Baked Ziti and a FULL tray of Sausage and Peppers, and instead I only received the tray of ziti and a HALF tray of sausage and peppers and the other half pasta. When I finally had a moment to call a few days later and address this they acknowledged what I ordered and what I didn’t receive but they wouldn’t over any future credit, refund, etc. and instead said I can leave whatever negative review I wish. Very disappointed in the service and the pizzas we ordered with it were terrible and certainly not NY style, being from NY myself.

Do yourself a favor and order your catering from Roma Deli, or Rocco’s Pizza.

Ok we have been coming here for years and they even catered our wedding.

Today (12/27 @ 5pm) was the most horrible experience in years. We ordered one slice of Grandmas pizza and 1/2 hr later it still hasn’t come out. The waitress said that they just got the ticket in the kitchen, well what happened to it? Was it stuck to another customers ticket? I suspect that the waitress didn’t even put it into the kitchen. She was clearly “lost” when we asked her, she said she didn’t know why the ticket was put in 1/2 hr after we ordered, and didn’t even seem to care that I was eating while my wife was still waiting for her slice, which was against my gentlemanly manners but my wife insisted.

Not only that but there were children present tonight in the restaurant and the tv was playing a movie showing topless waitresses! No one from the wait staff here even noticed. Embarrassing and disgusting. This place is starting to slide on my list of quality restaurants. Our regular waitress wasn’t here and she was always attentive. This waitress needs additional training in food service.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

We have been loyal customers of this place for years, ordering pizza almost weekly and always leaving generous tips. But the quality of service has deteriorated recently, and it's absolutely unacceptable. We live just a 5-minute drive from the restaurant, yet our orders now consistently arrive with delays. The most recent experience was the last straw—our pizza was nearly an hour late, arriving soggy, lukewarm and completely unappetizing. We didn't send it back because we had hungry guests.

Customer service here is an absolute nightmare. They are rude, dismissive and shockingly unprofessional. Calling to inquire about an order? Be prepared to be put on hold endlessly or even hung up on. When you finally manage to get someone on the line, they couldn't care less. Their response to complaints about late delivery? A condescending, "Just keep waiting, the driver is on the way." No apology, no accountability, just total indifference.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Wow!! Our last night in Vegas, this was one of the only places open after 10pm near our hotel….. and guess what?!!? Turned out to be the BEST dining experience we had our whole trip!! The ambiance, the customer service….. all so great! But then the food! Omg so freaking good! What we were looking for the whole week. We weren’t sure about eating in a strip mall but so glad we did! Love the 90’s Music mural too! We can’t wait to visit next time! FANTASTIC!!

I wanted too oder there stuffed meat pizza, I grew forgot what it's called I asked for the 2 pizza that are like together the meat lover's, they said it would be 30 minutes ,OK I would pick it up when I got it it was just a regular meat pizza for $29 dollars ? and I go I asked for the 2 pizza together I didn't no what it was called, and they said this what you asked for, Did Not help me at All, would I go back ? don't know, Definitely Not for a regular pizza for $29 dollars, Absolutely Not Worth It

Food: 3

Service: 3

My favorite pizza in Vegas! I tried a few places so was excited to finally find a Pizzeria that I love! The pizza is nice and thin, sauce taste good and sizes are not small! Also, everyone that work there is always nice and attentive. Highly recommend, you won’t regret it. :) Sn. This review is way over due, I found this place over 6 months ago.

We’ve loved Brooklyns for years. BUT….for the past six times we have ordered pizza from here, we never seem to get it in a timely manner. We’ve ordered it for pickup, and for delivery and I could literally (not figuratively) drive to the store, buy all of the ingredients, drive home, mix the dough, let us rise, fix the pizza, cook the pizza and eat the pizza all in the time it took for them to not deliver my pizza. After 1 1/2 hours of waiting for the pizza, I called and was told “this is a typical wait time but my pizza was on its delivery vans”, after 2 hours, I called and cancelled and asked for my money back. When you’re paying $65.00 for two pizzas (yes it’s good, but not that good) I would like to eat them before I go to bed. They have permanently lost a customer and easily $65 a week from us. Good luck for you brave enough to order here.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

I've tried this place a couple of times. The staff is always very nice and the service has been fast. The atmosphere is that of a typical pizza place. Unfortunately, the food has been extremely disappointing both times. The calamari breading was mushy and sliding off the meat. The meat itself was tuff and just not good. The pizza was okay, The sauce was too sweet for my tastes. It takes over the whole pie, but, I'm sure some people prefer that.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 5

?? An absolutely delicious experience - love their awesome pies and calzones! ??

Food: 5

Service: 5