Pizze Pie Guy is fairly new and is located inside Molly's Tavern and is such a great find! It's located in a huge shopping center area so parking is abundant. They have a nice sized room with tables and some booth seating as well as a couple good sized TVs to watch games on.The menu is great for a pizza style place with pizzas by the slice or whole, pasta dishes, wings, sandwiches, meatballs, a salad and some other dishes (mozzarella sticks, knots, garlic bread and more!).I've ordered a couple times now and love how everything is done fresh with minimal high quality ingredients. The owners seem very nice and were thankful. Prices are also very good for what you get.The pizza is phenomenal with a great sauce, cheesy, superior ingredients and a good crust. Some other items I've tried so far and liked include the cheesy garlic bread, the meatballs, mozzarella sticks and fries.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pie 18 Large, Ah Cheesy Garlic Bread 4, Margherita Infused Basil Oil Pizza, Cheesy Garlic Bread 8, Italian Knots or Fries
Aryo S.
Pizze Pie Guy is fairly new and is located inside Molly's Tavern and is such a great find! It's located in a huge shopping center area so parking is abundant. They have a nice sized room with tables and some booth seating as well as a couple good sized TVs to watch games on. The menu is great for a pizza style place with pizzas by the slice or whole, pasta dishes, wings, sandwiches, meatballs, a salad and some other dishes (mozzarella sticks, knots, garlic bread and more!). I've ordered a couple times now and love how everything is made fresh with high quality ingredients based on family recipes. The owners are very nice and were thankful. Prices are also very good for what you get! The pizza is phenomenal with a great sauce, cheesy, superior ingredients and a good crust. Some other items I've tried so far and liked include the cheesy garlic bread, the meatballs, mozzarella sticks and fries.
Kahieau K.
Drew provided a very clean, spacious and overall great venue for our first baby shower. Him and his wife gave us all that we needed to host an event including enough chairs and tables to dine and have our food and gifts to be on. The venue is big enough to sit 50-60 people with extra spare space for games etc. They were diligent with communication throughout the planning process and were always available through text, call and email. Their pricing for the venue is reasonable and in our budget. There was more than enough parking for our guests. I would highly recommend others to have family or social events at this location.
Steven Casper
The food is so good here, all we could talk about on the way home was how we couldn’t wait to go back.We got half margherita half cheese pizza, the crust was light and crispy, the balsamic was tangy and sweet. Just a great combination on a pizza. We couldn’t wait to eat a slice before remembering to take a picture.The manicotti was phenomenal, it just melted in your mouth. I may try and purchase an entire tray next time, not sure I’ve tasted better.The spaghetti and meatballs were also amazing. The meatball was cooked perfectly and super tender. My daughter refused to leave the restaurant until she ate every last noodle.Can’t wait to go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball Sub, Margherita Infused Basil Oil Pizza, Side Penne Pasta with Meatball, Italian Knots or Fries
Gage S.
Loved it! Father and Son business open about 4 month. Food was amazing! All fresh and homemade. We got the family meal with 2 Large pizzas, 4 meatballs, garlics bread. My son got the chicken parmigiana sandwich and he said it was good. We will totally come back again.
Steven C.
The food is so great here, all we could talk about on the way home was how we couldn't wait to go back. We got half margherita half cheese pizza, the crust was light and crispy, the balsamic was tangy and sweet. The manicotti was phenomenal, it just melted in your mouth. I may try and purchase an entire tray next time, not sure I've tasted better. The spaghetti and meatballs were also amazing. The meatball was cooked perfectly and super tender. My daughter refused to leave the restaurant until she ate every last noodle. Can't wait to go back.
Jennifer Carruthers
Amazing pie and Amazing Guy!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fingers or Wings & Fries, Pepperoni Pie - 18 Large
tori florence
Can’t recommend enough!. Soooo good! They just recently opened and I'm so excited to have them nearby.Their garlic cheese bread and the marinara sauce is to die for. Also got the side of penne with marinara and a meatball. Both were incredible- the sauce really is something I recommend.I also got a slice of their cheese pizza with their homemade ranch which were both really good too. I'll be coming back!Owner and workers were super welcoming and attentive. The restaurant itself is actually pretty large too, pictures look smaller. Lots of tables and tvs to sit and eat!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tori F.
Soooo good! They just recently opened and I'm so excited to have them nearby. Their garlic cheese bread and the marinara sauce is to die for. Also got the side of penne with marinara and a meatball. Both were incredible- the sauce really is something I recommend. I also got a slice of their cheese pizza with their homemade ranch which were both really good too. I'll be coming back! Owner and workers were super welcoming and attentive. The restaurant itself is actually pretty large too, pictures look smaller. Lots of tables and tvs to sit and eat!
Suz
Wow, amazing pizza!! Garlic bread is delicious too. Great menu, very nice dining area, fair prices. This was our first visit, for lunch, and we will be back. Friendly, caring A+ service, which is rare now days. Amanda was the absolute sweetest person, who made our pizza and served us. We could tell it was a family owned business & we were so impressed by their food quality and excellent service. Highly recommend!Parking: Inside Molly’s Tavern, free parking in a huge parking lot.
Absolutely amazing pie! Quite possibly the best meatballs I’ve ever had. They just melt in your mouth. We also had the garlic bread that was just perfect. They are so friendly and gracious. You will not be
There was a small hiccup with the original order, but they went above and beyond to fix the issue. Food is tasty AF!! Will definitely be going back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Karen Turnbull
Had the best experience at Pizza Pie Guy tonight! Ordered the family special …had more food than we could eat and took home leftovers! Everything is made fresh and was absolutely delicious! The meatballs and marinara sauce were insanely good! And if I’m gonna eat pizza this is the kind I want! Fresh made and so good! Sampled the desserts too! Yummy!!! The owners are so sweet and I love hearing about the family tradition of the recipes! Definitely worth a visit to this place. We had a great experience and will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Family Pie Guy Special
Charles Thurer
So lucky to have found this fantastic hidden gem! I had a cheese slice at the restaurant shortly after they opened. A few weeks ago, I was telling my father how amazing the place is. So he wanted the family to try it and we very much enjoyed everything! Owners Drew and Amanda are exceptional people. They treat you like family and go above and beyond to make sure you are happy. It is very rare to come across people who are as dedicated and devoted as they are. More importantly, their food is incredible. Absolutely out of this world!! Pizzas, salads, breadsticks, and pastas and the rest of their food is all made with love. I am from New York and amazing pizza has been very hard to come by. I have recommended their restaurant to family members and co-workers. If you work in the area, they offer a discount for employees that work in the area. They will even personally deliver your pizza. I will keep spreading the word. Definitely would recommend if you’re looking for a new pizza place! Thank you Drew and Amanda!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spring Salad, Family Pie Guy Special
Joshua Becerra
This place is amazing! I stopped in a couple weeks ago after work to try this place out after seeing some of their fliers in the break room and I haven't looked back since. Been in four times since! The pizza, pasta, and meatballs are all amazing! Everything is homemade and cooked to order. The couple that owns the place are soo sweet and are soo appreciative of the business. Dined in for the first time tonight and the dining area has a really cute and warming ambiance. Definitely will be back and have been recommending this place non stop!Thank you Drew and Amanda!
Pizze Pie Guy is fairly new and is located inside Molly's Tavern and is such a great find! It's located in a huge shopping center area so parking is abundant. They have a nice sized room with tables and some booth seating as well as a couple good sized TVs to watch games on.The menu is great for a pizza style place with pizzas by the slice or whole, pasta dishes, wings, sandwiches, meatballs, a salad and some other dishes (mozzarella sticks, knots, garlic bread and more!).I've ordered a couple times now and love how everything is done fresh with minimal high quality ingredients. The owners seem very nice and were thankful. Prices are also very good for what you get.The pizza is phenomenal with a great sauce, cheesy, superior ingredients and a good crust. Some other items I've tried so far and liked include the cheesy garlic bread, the meatballs, mozzarella sticks and fries.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pie 18 Large, Ah Cheesy Garlic Bread 4, Margherita Infused Basil Oil Pizza, Cheesy Garlic Bread 8, Italian Knots or Fries
Pizze Pie Guy is fairly new and is located inside Molly's Tavern and is such a great find! It's located in a huge shopping center area so parking is abundant. They have a nice sized room with tables and some booth seating as well as a couple good sized TVs to watch games on. The menu is great for a pizza style place with pizzas by the slice or whole, pasta dishes, wings, sandwiches, meatballs, a salad and some other dishes (mozzarella sticks, knots, garlic bread and more!). I've ordered a couple times now and love how everything is made fresh with high quality ingredients based on family recipes. The owners are very nice and were thankful. Prices are also very good for what you get! The pizza is phenomenal with a great sauce, cheesy, superior ingredients and a good crust. Some other items I've tried so far and liked include the cheesy garlic bread, the meatballs, mozzarella sticks and fries.
Drew provided a very clean, spacious and overall great venue for our first baby shower. Him and his wife gave us all that we needed to host an event including enough chairs and tables to dine and have our food and gifts to be on. The venue is big enough to sit 50-60 people with extra spare space for games etc. They were diligent with communication throughout the planning process and were always available through text, call and email. Their pricing for the venue is reasonable and in our budget. There was more than enough parking for our guests. I would highly recommend others to have family or social events at this location.
The food is so good here, all we could talk about on the way home was how we couldn’t wait to go back.We got half margherita half cheese pizza, the crust was light and crispy, the balsamic was tangy and sweet. Just a great combination on a pizza. We couldn’t wait to eat a slice before remembering to take a picture.The manicotti was phenomenal, it just melted in your mouth. I may try and purchase an entire tray next time, not sure I’ve tasted better.The spaghetti and meatballs were also amazing. The meatball was cooked perfectly and super tender. My daughter refused to leave the restaurant until she ate every last noodle.Can’t wait to go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball Sub, Margherita Infused Basil Oil Pizza, Side Penne Pasta with Meatball, Italian Knots or Fries
Loved it! Father and Son business open about 4 month. Food was amazing! All fresh and homemade. We got the family meal with 2 Large pizzas, 4 meatballs, garlics bread. My son got the chicken parmigiana sandwich and he said it was good. We will totally come back again.
The food is so great here, all we could talk about on the way home was how we couldn't wait to go back. We got half margherita half cheese pizza, the crust was light and crispy, the balsamic was tangy and sweet. The manicotti was phenomenal, it just melted in your mouth. I may try and purchase an entire tray next time, not sure I've tasted better. The spaghetti and meatballs were also amazing. The meatball was cooked perfectly and super tender. My daughter refused to leave the restaurant until she ate every last noodle. Can't wait to go back.
Amazing pie and Amazing Guy!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fingers or Wings & Fries, Pepperoni Pie - 18 Large
Can’t recommend enough!. Soooo good! They just recently opened and I'm so excited to have them nearby.Their garlic cheese bread and the marinara sauce is to die for. Also got the side of penne with marinara and a meatball. Both were incredible- the sauce really is something I recommend.I also got a slice of their cheese pizza with their homemade ranch which were both really good too. I'll be coming back!Owner and workers were super welcoming and attentive. The restaurant itself is actually pretty large too, pictures look smaller. Lots of tables and tvs to sit and eat!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Soooo good! They just recently opened and I'm so excited to have them nearby. Their garlic cheese bread and the marinara sauce is to die for. Also got the side of penne with marinara and a meatball. Both were incredible- the sauce really is something I recommend. I also got a slice of their cheese pizza with their homemade ranch which were both really good too. I'll be coming back! Owner and workers were super welcoming and attentive. The restaurant itself is actually pretty large too, pictures look smaller. Lots of tables and tvs to sit and eat!
Wow, amazing pizza!! Garlic bread is delicious too. Great menu, very nice dining area, fair prices. This was our first visit, for lunch, and we will be back. Friendly, caring A+ service, which is rare now days. Amanda was the absolute sweetest person, who made our pizza and served us. We could tell it was a family owned business & we were so impressed by their food quality and excellent service. Highly recommend!Parking: Inside Molly’s Tavern, free parking in a huge parking lot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Absolutely amazing pie! Quite possibly the best meatballs I’ve ever had. They just melt in your mouth. We also had the garlic bread that was just perfect. They are so friendly and gracious. You will not be
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball Sub, Pepperoni Pie 18 Large, Cheese Pizza Slice
There was a small hiccup with the original order, but they went above and beyond to fix the issue. Food is tasty AF!! Will definitely be going back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Had the best experience at Pizza Pie Guy tonight! Ordered the family special …had more food than we could eat and took home leftovers! Everything is made fresh and was absolutely delicious! The meatballs and marinara sauce were insanely good! And if I’m gonna eat pizza this is the kind I want! Fresh made and so good! Sampled the desserts too! Yummy!!! The owners are so sweet and I love hearing about the family tradition of the recipes! Definitely worth a visit to this place. We had a great experience and will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Family Pie Guy Special
So lucky to have found this fantastic hidden gem! I had a cheese slice at the restaurant shortly after they opened. A few weeks ago, I was telling my father how amazing the place is. So he wanted the family to try it and we very much enjoyed everything! Owners Drew and Amanda are exceptional people. They treat you like family and go above and beyond to make sure you are happy. It is very rare to come across people who are as dedicated and devoted as they are. More importantly, their food is incredible. Absolutely out of this world!! Pizzas, salads, breadsticks, and pastas and the rest of their food is all made with love. I am from New York and amazing pizza has been very hard to come by. I have recommended their restaurant to family members and co-workers. If you work in the area, they offer a discount for employees that work in the area. They will even personally deliver your pizza. I will keep spreading the word. Definitely would recommend if you’re looking for a new pizza place! Thank you Drew and Amanda!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spring Salad, Family Pie Guy Special
This place is amazing! I stopped in a couple weeks ago after work to try this place out after seeing some of their fliers in the break room and I haven't looked back since. Been in four times since! The pizza, pasta, and meatballs are all amazing! Everything is homemade and cooked to order. The couple that owns the place are soo sweet and are soo appreciative of the business. Dined in for the first time tonight and the dining area has a really cute and warming ambiance. Definitely will be back and have been recommending this place non stop!Thank you Drew and Amanda!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5