The quality of pizza was not the best I have had—BUT I will say if it’s late and you’ve been drinking—it’s delicious. 😋🍕 The line can be long, however moves fast. All counter service and serve by the slice or whole pizzas 🤤 Mushroom and pepperoni 🍕🍄🟫 was a good choice. They do offer other options like meatball sandwiches, pasta 🍝, and salads 🥗! We sat right outside the pizza place on the “streets of New York” 🗽 Overhead you can see the roller coaster 🎢 pass by! Definitely transports you.
MDB
This place used to be the spot.. now it's twice as expensive, the pizza is mediocre at best, and they don't throw it back in the oven to make it crispy. The people handing out the pizza are rude as well. Vegas as a whole has become so expensive, I don't know why anyone would come here.
Judy Noble
Wow. Best slice of pizza in Vegas , hands down!!!! I will absolutely be back!
Frank Biermann
Decent pizza - sure hits the spot after a few rounds of drinks, but you could do better. The old guy behind the counter has got some attitude issues, so it is what it is.
Trent River
Good for late night snack. Pricy for a slice in my opinion. Lines can be really long if it's a busy night.
Dee C
Great spot for a late night snack! Pizza was good and service was efficient with lots of varieties available. Had the sausage slice and very much enjoyed it. Nice spot for some late night convos with strangers for sure!
Brian Kane
I go to New York City a lot for work and my favorite snack is a slice of pizza. I’ve eaten at easily over 100 different pizza spots in New York. This is by far the worst pizza restaurant I’ve been to. New York Pizza should be able to be held in one hand while folded. The pizza I got was super floppy. Rather than sticking the slice in the oven to warm it up, which is common, they just slapped it on a plastic plate and handed it to me. It was barely warm and lacked flavor.
To use a Vegas benchmark, the secret pizza place at Cosmopolitan is easily 10 times better. This place would be considered bad by mall food court standards. I really can’t emphasize enough just how bad this place is. My pizza bar is extremely low… I love pizza…period. But I’ll never eat here again.
Barbara Thompson Roethle
We always loved this place and visited each time we stayed, sometimes more than once. During our recent visit to Vegas we went for a slice. They were not busy and we were served quickly and moved to the check out. I asked a question about the MGM Rewards to the man at the checkout, in a crabby tone he said take your receipt to the rewards booth in the casino. Then , no drinks? Based upon the fact we were paying $19 for 2 slices of pizza we opted out of drinks. When we didn't give a tip the man commented to a coworker that we didn't tip. Do we owe a tip when one person puts a slice on plate and the other rudely rings us up?
Matthew Cole
Great pizza. 8 bucks a slice which is great since it's in the hotel
Jackie Davis
Pizza was delicious. Spaghetti and meatballs are also delicious. One of the better spaghetti sauces and meatballs that I have had out to eat. Very reasonable.
The pizza was fine, the type/style you would find at any hole the wall. However , definitely not banged for the buck. Yes, it’s Vegas but $9 for a slice of cheese pizza? Also, there was a long line, and my pizza was cold by the time I paid for it.
There are much better food choices in the area.
Kyle Roberts
You’re getting exactly what you wanted at this place. A very nice slice of pizza. We decided to eat here instead of breaking the bank at another location. The pizza was very enjoyable. New York, New York is a really cool place so the atmosphere was perfect. You can obviously get better food on the strip, but if you go here, it will exceed your expectations. The bottle of Pepsi was the same price as the slice of pizza. Don’t get a drink.
Victoria
Every time I come to Vegas, this is my spot for pizza. Great quality!
Vincente “Nick” Celentano
Sirrico’s Pizza – NYNY Casino (2025 Update)
I used to consider Sirrico’s a solid option for a quick, reasonably priced slice of NY-style pizza in the NYNY Casino. A few years ago, my experience was mostly positive—$10 got you a slice and a beer, the pizza had a good balance of crisp and chew, and despite the usual line out the door, service was quick. If you were in the mood for a whole pie, they’d make one fresh in about 30 minutes.
Unfortunately, my latest visit left me disappointed. The price for a slice and a beer has jumped to $11.95, which I expected to some degree given how everything has gotten more expensive. What I didn’t expect was the drop in quality. The pizza itself has changed—it was always a thin-crust style, but now it feels like they’ve figured out the absolute minimum amount of dough they can use while still technically calling it a pizza slice. One slice was overly crispy, while the other was strangely doughy, making for an inconsistent experience.
Sirrico’s used to be a go-to for a solid slice at a fair price, but now it feels like they’re charging more while giving you less. If you’re in NYNY and craving pizza, it might still be a convenient option, but it’s no longer the easy recommendation it once was.
Kay Sheikh
Taste new york style pizza! Located in cute little village in New York New york hotel & Casino 🗽. Nice ambience to take a stroll, take a pause have a seat and enjoy a slice of pizza here.🍕
The quality of pizza was not the best I have had—BUT I will say if it’s late and you’ve been drinking—it’s delicious. 😋🍕
The line can be long, however moves fast. All counter service and serve by the slice or whole pizzas 🤤
Mushroom and pepperoni 🍕🍄🟫 was a good choice. They do offer other options like meatball sandwiches, pasta 🍝, and salads 🥗!
We sat right outside the pizza place on the “streets of New York” 🗽 Overhead you can see the roller coaster 🎢 pass by! Definitely transports you.
This place used to be the spot.. now it's twice as expensive, the pizza is mediocre at best, and they don't throw it back in the oven to make it crispy. The people handing out the pizza are rude as well. Vegas as a whole has become so expensive, I don't know why anyone would come here.
Wow. Best slice of pizza in Vegas , hands down!!!! I will absolutely be back!
Decent pizza - sure hits the spot after a few rounds of drinks, but you could do better. The old guy behind the counter has got some attitude issues, so it is what it is.
Good for late night snack. Pricy for a slice in my opinion. Lines can be really long if it's a busy night.
Great spot for a late night snack! Pizza was good and service was efficient with lots of varieties available. Had the sausage slice and very much enjoyed it. Nice spot for some late night convos with strangers for sure!
I go to New York City a lot for work and my favorite snack is a slice of pizza. I’ve eaten at easily over 100 different pizza spots in New York. This is by far the worst pizza restaurant I’ve been to. New York Pizza should be able to be held in one hand while folded. The pizza I got was super floppy. Rather than sticking the slice in the oven to warm it up, which is common, they just slapped it on a plastic plate and handed it to me. It was barely warm and lacked flavor.
To use a Vegas benchmark, the secret pizza place at Cosmopolitan is easily 10 times better. This place would be considered bad by mall food court standards. I really can’t emphasize enough just how bad this place is. My pizza bar is extremely low… I love pizza…period. But I’ll never eat here again.
We always loved this place and visited each time we stayed, sometimes more than once. During our recent visit to Vegas we went for a slice. They were not busy and we were served quickly and moved to the check out. I asked a question about the MGM Rewards to the man at the checkout, in a crabby tone he said take your receipt to the rewards booth in the casino. Then , no drinks? Based upon the fact we were paying $19 for 2 slices of pizza we opted out of drinks. When we didn't give a tip the man commented to a coworker that we didn't tip. Do we owe a tip when one person puts a slice on plate and the other rudely rings us up?
Great pizza. 8 bucks a slice which is great since it's in the hotel
Pizza was delicious. Spaghetti and meatballs are also delicious. One of the better spaghetti sauces and meatballs that I have had out to eat. Very reasonable.
Restaurantji Recommends
The pizza was fine, the type/style you would find at any hole the wall. However , definitely not banged for the buck. Yes, it’s Vegas but $9 for a slice of cheese pizza? Also, there was a long line, and my pizza was cold by the time I paid for it.
There are much better food choices in the area.
You’re getting exactly what you wanted at this place. A very nice slice of pizza. We decided to eat here instead of breaking the bank at another location. The pizza was very enjoyable. New York, New York is a really cool place so the atmosphere was perfect. You can obviously get better food on the strip, but if you go here, it will exceed your expectations. The bottle of Pepsi was the same price as the slice of pizza. Don’t get a drink.
Every time I come to Vegas, this is my spot for pizza. Great quality!
Sirrico’s Pizza – NYNY Casino (2025 Update)
I used to consider Sirrico’s a solid option for a quick, reasonably priced slice of NY-style pizza in the NYNY Casino. A few years ago, my experience was mostly positive—$10 got you a slice and a beer, the pizza had a good balance of crisp and chew, and despite the usual line out the door, service was quick. If you were in the mood for a whole pie, they’d make one fresh in about 30 minutes.
Unfortunately, my latest visit left me disappointed. The price for a slice and a beer has jumped to $11.95, which I expected to some degree given how everything has gotten more expensive. What I didn’t expect was the drop in quality. The pizza itself has changed—it was always a thin-crust style, but now it feels like they’ve figured out the absolute minimum amount of dough they can use while still technically calling it a pizza slice. One slice was overly crispy, while the other was strangely doughy, making for an inconsistent experience.
Sirrico’s used to be a go-to for a solid slice at a fair price, but now it feels like they’re charging more while giving you less. If you’re in NYNY and craving pizza, it might still be a convenient option, but it’s no longer the easy recommendation it once was.
Taste new york style pizza!
Located in cute little village in New York New york hotel & Casino 🗽.
Nice ambience to take a stroll, take a pause have a seat and enjoy a slice of pizza here.🍕
Loading...