Pizza has such thick cheese. Otherwise it was fine for the area. Probably not much better around. Atmosphere was nice and waitresses were kind and promptKid-friendliness: Roomy tables
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Krissa F.
BEWARE!!! Took my grandkids here today after the monster truck show for their birthdays. The two servers standing behind the bar immediately started whispering to each other immediately. No greeting whatsoever. Picked a table and waited several minutes for acknowledgement. Wouldn't have been a problem if there had been more than 2 people sitting at the bar who already had their food and drinks. Took about 10 minutes to get our drink order taken because the server was clearly in the kitchen with a boy with long hair (not tied up, I assume he was the chef on duty) smoking some sort of vape pen in clear view of the service window. We ordered the chicken ceaser salad, which had no croutons. Wouldn't have been a problem. Restaurants run out of stuff all the time. If it would have tasted halfway decent it would have been ok. Definitely gone downhill. Used to be our favorite thing on the menu. Took over 40 minutes for the kids to get their pasta because the server was again in the kitchen smoking with the other young man. I'll never return!!!
Josh McCarver
calmness. through town and chose to eat lunch here. It was a great choice! We both ordered calzones, and we agreed they were very good. Maybe we'll come back on our way home.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Tj unspeakable home
I was pleasantly surprised! Pepperoni pizza well done was fantastic !! Waitress was very
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Maryanne
We try to support our local eateries so celebrated a birthday last night. Our birthday guest’s pizza was “burned” so they had to re-make which can happen I understand. My pizza was the worse I’ve ever had, frozen pizza has been much better. Our Sons Calzone was good but they forgot my husband’s panini. The pesto squares were as usual very good. The poor waitress was very nice and doing her best as a main server and bar tender. I felt sorry for her. The place was packed and maybe the kitchen was overwhelmed? If they have new kitchen staff they need to learn a different pizza dough and do something about the taste of their cubed chicken, tasted like plant based. Lighting really needs updating! We will try it again in a few months and maybe things will improve.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 2
Amber S.
Food is good, but tried to do a team dinner while in town and reserve 5 tables together. I offered for each family to come up to the bar and order their own pizza since we wanted split checks. I figured each family ordering at the bar and paying for their pizza would make it easy but they refused and said we all had to be on one tab if we wanted tables close to one another. Nobody in winnemucca seems to want to do split checks. Crazy that restaurants will turn people away for split checks. I get it can be tough to do split checks, but a pizza place and families willing to come to the bar and order their food and pay seems crazy.
Frank S.
I went in to the pizzeria with my wife Dorothy we ordered a pizza and some beer. The pizza was excellent. The beer was cold. We chitchatted for a while and we left it was great. I recommended it to my family members so one day 15 of us were all together And I said let's go down to the winnemucca pizzeria. Rachel, the server was very very intentive. The food was excellent. We ordered six pies and probably about 20 beers, and some sodas.I thought I was in Italy. It smelt delicious I just want to say thank you very much for helping my family and I have some fun that day, I highly recommend winnemucca pizza. Thank you very much Frank Paul Segreto. I just wanted to say, my cousin Vinny. he really had a lot of fun that day. We will be back thank you.
Leah F.
Food was great! Second time ordering the star calzone. No bell peppers. First time ordering the minestrone soup with meatballs.. Delicious!! Service was friendly and prompt.
Andrew C.
Everything is great about this place! Food is excellent & service was prompt & friendly!
Analeah C.
I ordered pick up and all of it was very cold like it was outside. They gave me very thin crust like paper, i didn't even order thin crust and tasted like burnt bagel. The chicken also tasted like fish. They also didn't give us dipping sauce with the garlic knots. Im very disappointed with the quality of the food today
Driving home from Idaho and we were craving pizza. Found this place and decided to stop. Very friendly service. Highly recommend the Lots of Knots garlic bread knots and their pizza was excellent. Food came out pretty quick too.
Brendon Douglas
Some great pizza choices but they struggle with service when there is a few people in there; we had drinks not come, then extra one's that weren't ordered, and appetizers that apparently never made it to the kitchen.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Paul
Decent pizza, but the poor service and ordering process was not worth the hassle. I called the number to order ahead and was abruptly placed on hold for 15 mins before I finally hung up and tried again, but the call failed. Idk if the phone got unplugged or what, but I ended up driving there to place my order in person. Upon arrival, they didn’t even seem busy. The server casually took my order in no hurry, but I didn’t want to wait around so I left my cell number. They said they’d call when it’s ready, but after 30 minutes I once again gave up and returned to the restaurant on my own, only to find my order had been sitting out at the bar for who knows how long. Server said it hadn’t been long, but I was surprised to find it wasn’t under a heat lamp. No sauce provided with the garlic knots, I had to check the box and ask for some. Bottom of the box was super greasy and left a stain on my passenger seat after the drive home. Last couple things are nitpicks that only added to the annoyance, otherwise I would have overlooked. Price was steep and pizza turned out to be only okay.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Rebecca Herron
This restaurant is the bright spot in Winnemucca. We looked at several before happening upon this gem. Plenty of seating for a very busy restaurant, good service, and the pizza was EXCELLENT! Our waitress was nicely dressed, professional, and helpful. There were two young people helping to seat and pick up. They were my only negatives: they were dressed so sloppy! Totally unlike the rest of the staff who appeared proud to be employees.
Pizza has such thick cheese. Otherwise it was fine for the area. Probably not much better around. Atmosphere was nice and waitresses were kind and promptKid-friendliness: Roomy tables
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
BEWARE!!! Took my grandkids here today after the monster truck show for their birthdays. The two servers standing behind the bar immediately started whispering to each other immediately. No greeting whatsoever. Picked a table and waited several minutes for acknowledgement. Wouldn't have been a problem if there had been more than 2 people sitting at the bar who already had their food and drinks. Took about 10 minutes to get our drink order taken because the server was clearly in the kitchen with a boy with long hair (not tied up, I assume he was the chef on duty) smoking some sort of vape pen in clear view of the service window. We ordered the chicken ceaser salad, which had no croutons. Wouldn't have been a problem. Restaurants run out of stuff all the time. If it would have tasted halfway decent it would have been ok. Definitely gone downhill. Used to be our favorite thing on the menu. Took over 40 minutes for the kids to get their pasta because the server was again in the kitchen smoking with the other young man. I'll never return!!!
calmness. through town and chose to eat lunch here. It was a great choice! We both ordered calzones, and we agreed they were very good. Maybe we'll come back on our way home.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
I was pleasantly surprised! Pepperoni pizza well done was fantastic !! Waitress was very
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We try to support our local eateries so celebrated a birthday last night. Our birthday guest’s pizza was “burned” so they had to re-make which can happen I understand. My pizza was the worse I’ve ever had, frozen pizza has been much better. Our Sons Calzone was good but they forgot my husband’s panini. The pesto squares were as usual very good. The poor waitress was very nice and doing her best as a main server and bar tender. I felt sorry for her. The place was packed and maybe the kitchen was overwhelmed? If they have new kitchen staff they need to learn a different pizza dough and do something about the taste of their cubed chicken, tasted like plant based. Lighting really needs updating! We will try it again in a few months and maybe things will improve.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 2
Food is good, but tried to do a team dinner while in town and reserve 5 tables together. I offered for each family to come up to the bar and order their own pizza since we wanted split checks. I figured each family ordering at the bar and paying for their pizza would make it easy but they refused and said we all had to be on one tab if we wanted tables close to one another. Nobody in winnemucca seems to want to do split checks. Crazy that restaurants will turn people away for split checks. I get it can be tough to do split checks, but a pizza place and families willing to come to the bar and order their food and pay seems crazy.
I went in to the pizzeria with my wife Dorothy we ordered a pizza and some beer. The pizza was excellent. The beer was cold. We chitchatted for a while and we left it was great. I recommended it to my family members so one day 15 of us were all together And I said let's go down to the winnemucca pizzeria. Rachel, the server was very very intentive. The food was excellent. We ordered six pies and probably about 20 beers, and some sodas.I thought I was in Italy. It smelt delicious I just want to say thank you very much for helping my family and I have some fun that day, I highly recommend winnemucca pizza. Thank you very much Frank Paul Segreto. I just wanted to say, my cousin Vinny. he really had a lot of fun that day. We will be back thank you.
Food was great! Second time ordering the star calzone. No bell peppers. First time ordering the minestrone soup with meatballs.. Delicious!! Service was friendly and prompt.
Everything is great about this place! Food is excellent & service was prompt & friendly!
I ordered pick up and all of it was very cold like it was outside. They gave me very thin crust like paper, i didn't even order thin crust and tasted like burnt bagel. The chicken also tasted like fish. They also didn't give us dipping sauce with the garlic knots. Im very disappointed with the quality of the food today
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious calzone and linguine!
Food: 5
Driving home from Idaho and we were craving pizza. Found this place and decided to stop. Very friendly service. Highly recommend the Lots of Knots garlic bread knots and their pizza was excellent. Food came out pretty quick too.
Some great pizza choices but they struggle with service when there is a few people in there; we had drinks not come, then extra one's that weren't ordered, and appetizers that apparently never made it to the kitchen.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Decent pizza, but the poor service and ordering process was not worth the hassle. I called the number to order ahead and was abruptly placed on hold for 15 mins before I finally hung up and tried again, but the call failed. Idk if the phone got unplugged or what, but I ended up driving there to place my order in person. Upon arrival, they didn’t even seem busy. The server casually took my order in no hurry, but I didn’t want to wait around so I left my cell number. They said they’d call when it’s ready, but after 30 minutes I once again gave up and returned to the restaurant on my own, only to find my order had been sitting out at the bar for who knows how long. Server said it hadn’t been long, but I was surprised to find it wasn’t under a heat lamp. No sauce provided with the garlic knots, I had to check the box and ask for some. Bottom of the box was super greasy and left a stain on my passenger seat after the drive home. Last couple things are nitpicks that only added to the annoyance, otherwise I would have overlooked. Price was steep and pizza turned out to be only okay.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
This restaurant is the bright spot in Winnemucca. We looked at several before happening upon this gem. Plenty of seating for a very busy restaurant, good service, and the pizza was EXCELLENT! Our waitress was nicely dressed, professional, and helpful. There were two young people helping to seat and pick up. They were my only negatives: they were dressed so sloppy! Totally unlike the rest of the staff who appeared proud to be employees.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5