Bagel Boys Cafe
9 N Airmont Rd, Airmont
(845) 368-3456
Customers' Favorites
Bacon Egg and Cheese Bagel
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Everything Bagel
Macaroni Salad
Chicken Salad
Sesame Bagel
Chicken Parm
Baked Salmon
Lox Spread
Tuna Salad
Homemade Salads
Cobb Salad
Tossed Salad
Pan Asian Salad
Caesar Salad
Greek Salad
Lunch Cold Sandwiches
Chicken Cutlet Sandwich
Fresh.
Ham Sandwich
OvenGold Turkey Sandwich
Italian Combo Sandwich
Roast Beef Sandwich
Honey Maple Turkey Sandwich
Turkey Pastrami Sandwich
Mashki
Grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, baby arugula, fresh mozzarella balsamic vinaigrette dressing on multi-grain bread.
Godfather
Prosciutto, italian coppa, sopressata, mozzarella, roasted peppers, baby arugula, balsamic vinaigrette on a hero.
Montebello
Turkey pastrami, coleslaw, lacey swiss, and russian dressing on texas toast.
Godmother
Fresh mozzarella, tomato, roasted peppers, baby arugula, balsamic vinaigrette on a hero.
Crack Pepper Turkey Sandwich
Smoked Turkey Sandwich
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Salami Sandwich
Muffins
Double Chocolate Chip
Blueberry
Banana Nut
Chocolate Chip
Cinnamon Chip
Corn
Cheese Danish
Red Velvet
Red Velvet
Carrot Cheese
Chocolate Cheese
Carrot Raisin
Raisin Bran
Bran
Pancakes
French Toast
2 slices of Challah bread, comes with syrup.
Plain Stack Pancakes
3 pancakes per order, comes with syrup and butter.
BLT
Bacon, lettuce & tomato. Lots of bacon, crisp lettuce & tomato.
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
3 pancakes per order, comes with syrup and butter.
Grilled Cheese & Bacon
Lots of bacon, american cheese.
Blueberry Pancakes
3 pancakes per order, comes with syrup and butter.
Best Hand Rolled Water Bagels
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Bagel Boys Dozen
Always 15 bagels.
Bagel with Butter
Bagel Boys Bagel
Each.
Flagel with Cream Cheese
Mini Bagel with Cream Cheese
Mini Bagel with Butter
Bagel Boys Mini Bagel
Each.
Flagel with Butter
Flagels
Homemade Salad Sandwiches
Homemade Tuna Salad
Cranberry Chicken Salad
Low fat. chicken, toasted almonds, cranberries, mayo.
Egg Salad
1/2 lb.
Chicken Salad
1/2 lb.
Low Fat Tuna Salad
Carrots, celery, hellman's mayo.
Shrimp Salad
1/2 lb.
Smoked Fish Sandwiches
Nova Scotia Salmon
With cream cheese on bagel. Fresh sliced.
Whitefish Salad
Chunky whitefish & hellmann's mayo.
Baked Salmon Salad
Chunky baked salmon with hellmann's mayo on a bagel.
Tuna, Chicken, Egg Salads...
Tuna Salad
1/2 lb.
Chicken Salad
1/2 lb.
Cranberry Chicken Salad
1/2 lb.
Egg Salad
1/2 lb.
Grilled Chicken
1/2 lb.
Chicken Cutlets
1/2 lb.
Shrimp Salad
1/2 lb.
Low Fat Tuna Salad
1/2 lb.
Wraps
Caesar Wrap
Romaine lettuce, grilled chicken, grated parmesan cheese, croutons, caesar dressing.
Fried Eggplant
Fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers with balsamic vinaigrette.
Chicken Salad Wrap
Fill in your own wrap.
Honey Turkey
Havarti dill, honey mustard lettuce & tomato.
Pastrami Turkey
Lacy swiss, coleslaw, & russian dressing.
Smoked Turkey
Boars head bacon, lettuce, tomato & mayo.
Tuna Salad
Fill in your wrap.
Cranberry Chicken Salad
Fill in your own wrap.
Egg Salad
1/2 lb.
Roast Beef
Boars head bacon, lettuce, tomato & mayo.
Oriental Wrap
Boars head bacon, lettuce, tomato & mayo.
Assorted Grilled Veggies
With balsamic vinaigrette.
"Boars Head" Cold Cuts
Ovengold Turkey
Deluxe #1 Ham
Honey Maple Turkey
Pastrami Turkey
1/2 lb.
Fresh Turkey
Pepperoni
Cream Cheese
Plain Cream Cheese
1/2 lb.
Scallion Cream Cheese
1/2 lb.
Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese
1/2 lb.
Veggie Cream Cheese
1/2 lb.
Lox Spread
1/2 lb.
Smoked Fish
Whitefish Salad
1/2 lb.
Nova Scotia Salmon
1/4 lb.
Baked Salmon
Chunk. 1/4 lb.
Pickled Herring
1/2 lb.
Herring Salad
1/2 lb.
Baked Salmon Salad
1/2 lb.
Cheese
American
1/2 lb.
Lacey Swiss
1/2 lb.
Finlandia Swiss
1/2 lb.
Cheddar
1/2 lb.
Provolone
1/2 lb.
Havarti Dill
1/2 lb.
Fresh Mozzarella Sliced
1/2 lb.
Pepper Jack
1/2 lb.
Potato Chips
Kettle Chips
Wise Chips
Deep River
Famous Bakery
Rainbow Cookies
1/2 lb.
Rugelach
Like no other! 1/2lb.
Assorted Mix
1 piece.
Brownie
1 piece.
Black & White Cookie
1 piece.
Chinese Cookie
1 piece.
Mini Black & Whites
3 bag.
Butter Cookies
1/2 lb.
Side
Macaroni Salad
1/2 lb.
Coleslaw
1/2 lb.
Israeli Salad
1/2 lb.
Cucumber Salad
1/2 lb.
Square Knish
1/2 lb.
Potato Salad
1/2 lb.
Asian Noodle Salad
1/2 lb.
Half Sour Pickles
Quart.
Sour Pickles
Quart.
Coffee
Iced Coffee
Large, flavors or regular.
Hot Coffee
Large, flavors or regular, hot.
Tea
Hot Chocolate
Large, hot.
Coffee Decaf
Large, hot.
Box of Joe
Included: milk, 1/2 & 1/2, sweeteners, cups 12 cups.
Beverages
Fresh Squeeze Orange Juice
Tropicana
Snapple
20 oz. Soda
Gatorade
Poland Spring
Vitamin Water
Red Bull
Red Bull
Unsweet.
Nest Quick
Dr. Brown
Can.
Small Fiji Water
Photos
+44 photos
+43 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
There’s no place like Bagel Boys. I don’t know how they do it but their tuna salad, chicken, cranberry salad, egg salad, and white fish salad taste amazing. Expensive, but amazing!
October 2025
Place used to be so good when I was in high school. Not sure what happened. Super expensive now too. And it’s frustrating having to constantly repeat my order to someone, when they can just write it down on a piece of paper like every other place does!
September 2025
first time coming here. its off a very busy street. plenty of parking. i called to place an order 30 mins ahead of time and had to wait maybe 5 mins for it to be ready. wasnt busy at all. im eating my food which i got chicken cutlet on a flagel and its amazing! way better than bagel train. lady was nice at the counter. very clean place. will be back again to try more stuff on the menu!
August 2025
You May Also Like
Sutter's Mill - 214 NY-59
![]()
Bar & Grill, Pubs, Burgers, Chicken Wings
Mama Mia’s Pizzeria Restaurant Deli - 214 NY-59 Unit 2
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Salad
Guacamole Mexican Grill - 214 NY-59
![]()
Mexican, Vegetarian