I Bagel Cafe

180 I U Willets Rd, Albertson
(516) 747-4040

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Robert Figueroa

Was not a fan. I got a bacon egg and cheese, was not happy with how it came out. No, they do not offer real bacon. And from what it seems, the place gets backed up...

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Jenna

Coffee is amazing. Flagels are the best

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jenna M

Coffee is amazing. Flagels are the

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

J T

Great bagels! Nice people. My favorite is the egg everything

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marika C

Great local spot. Bagels are delicious and they have the best iced coffee flavors. Try the marshmallow and cappuccino ones. Also a plus if you have little kids because you can see the train go by through the windows.

Pablo Palomeque

Today was the day of a review I guess...Waited around 8 minutes (timed it) in an empty store to finally order something...and then order came in very wrong. Got a toasted roll bacon agg and cheese ..with NO cheese...and no toasted..and coffee had barely any sugar, And paid $12, for bad service and a bad order. Disappointing.

Jared Sharfman

This is my third visit and once again they could not get the order correct. I ordered two non toasted bagels with lox and a little cream cheese. I said it three times a little bit of cream cheese and I came home to a sloppy mess once again. No more. Thank you. And goodbye They only make it the way they want to they will not take your order.

Nick Sanders

Worst bagel I have ever had…..I can not begin to understand how they have any customers ….take the 2 minute ride to bagel spot on willis

victor Sforza

Phil leotardo spent 20 yrs in da can he wanted a big bagel with cream cheese, big hot cup of coffee ☕, he compromised, he ate grilled cheese off da radiator.. heheh

CEAF 97

Love the bagels and the salads. Yum.

Fred Adler

I used to go regularly. On my last takeout order they gave me tofu cream cheese instead of regular. No big deal. We used butter and I tried to return the container marked tofu cream cheese. They refused to refund the $7. At first they claimed that the tofu was the same price, and then said they don't carry tofu cream cheese even though the package said it was. I left the container and walked out,NEVER to return. They were more considered about $7 and being right than taking care of a customer. No problem as I now go to Bagel Boss,

Wiily Wonka

14 dollars for a hungry man, bacon rubbery besides that no ham guy ask me if I want turkey said no but I guess he wanted turkey on it oh ya and it's 14 dollars , inflation a bit

Mimi D

I told my dentist a lady yelled at me for asking her to scoop out my bagel at my fave place so he recommended this place.
I just paid $13 for a bagel with cream cheese and lox!!! Yikes!!! I feel like maybe I should go back to my original place and take the abuse for half the price for the same exact bagel. Idk if I’ll return bc of the price bc I like my lox from bagel shops but really didn’t expect to pay more than NYC prices.

Ryan

Walked in waited online line for about 5min ready to order and guy said we are closed

Rob foodsucks

14 dollars for a hungry man, bacon rubbery besides that no ham guy ask me if I want turkey said no but I guess he wanted turkey on it oh ya and it's 14 dollars , inflation a bit

Loading...