Coleman's Dock Of The Bay

2 James St, Alexandria Bay
(315) 482-7630

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Rob Ashton

Best Wings and beer battered shrimp I have ever had. Owner is cool and very Friendly.Always great service and great view. Highly recommend this place must stop in the Bay. Easy to find follow your nose.

Sergio Antonio García Robleto

The restaurant closed at the end of September and will open the 3rd week of April 2025

Tammy Marshall

We were not impressed.
My husband's bbq pulled pork was dry and little BBQ, my grilled chicken was very dry, my grandson's burger was too hard to eat and kettle chips were stale. No choc. Milk , no child cups with cover, no Bleu cheese for a salad. We asked to be seated inside out of the wind, we were seated right next to the open door which was very windy. The whole experience was a shit show.
I realize it was end of season, but not a good way to get repeat customers. We were not told it was going to be limited.
Another party of approx. 8 people got up and left before even ordering too.

JG

Food is pretty decent especially for a tourist trap the barbecue was well prepared ...although cold... the cornbread was good and the coleslaw was really good

Amy Del Prete

This was about Blues in the Bay, not really Colemans. We like to go for a day each Labors Day. Always a great selection of artists and a fun day. It does span the whole holiday weekend. You can pick your band and day to go.

Melissa T

Great food and friendly service!

K “1000islandsgirl_” G

We had the half rack and brisket. So much food and so good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michael Hurst

Bad service and no straws for drink's

Jamie Detota

Food super yummy and reasonably priced. Loved the bbq chicken and friendly service. Not a good wine beer selection but other than that awesome views laid back kid/dog friendly

Angela Crawshaw

Food was good, service was below par. Wanted a straw for our beverages and was told it's the end of the season and they had no straws. Waitress had no customer service appeal. Won't go back.

Mark Schmigel

The BBQ wings were very good with the meat falling off the bone. Nice place and good service.
2024: The Bang bang shrimp was good but the salmon was small, cold and not very flavourful. The fries we cold too.

Mrs. Goss “1000islandsgirl_”

We had the half rack and brisket. So much food and so good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tom Levi

Very good food. Good portions. Zach our waiter was very attentive. A lot of places are raising prices or cutting portions or both. Coleman’s has very good food, reasonably priced and ample portions for the money.

Zachary Lockhart

Got the pork nachos, cheese was dried out the pork might as well have been Jerry it was so dry. Waitress gave a dirty look when asked to take it away. Otherwise not bad but not worth the price.

Wes G

Depending on the time of the day you go, it could be a quiet place to eat. However, when we got seated, there were a rowdy group of maybe 15 people, and all of them were drunk and obnoxious. We could hardly carry on a conversation amongst our family. This was also between their explicit words when there's other families with small kids nearby. As for the food, my brisket poutine was OKAY, but the brisket was a tad dried out and had no flavor. My mother had a Ceasar salad, and idk how you can mess that up, but she said it tasted like everything wasn't fresh, the veggies to the dressing. My dad had half a rack of ribs, and it was dried out, and the mustard flavored rub was nasty tasting. He said the best part of his meal was the coleslaw and the beans. So that's our review of this place. Perhaps next time, we'll try it again to give it another shot, but it wasn't anything special. Sorry.

Loading...