The Old Mill Inn

1 Depot, Alfred Station
(607) 587-9060

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Joseph Szalay

Food and service was very good! Our waitress was excellent and great sense of humor, her name was Julie.

j shammah

This is a good place to eat. Food was good. Waitress attentive. Order French Onion soup- not such a fan of dark bread (rye?) in the soup. It overpowered broth. Parm fries need more parm. But the place was interesting. Upstairs didnt get to but filled w arcade games and pool tables. Outside seating nice in summer. Only felt uncomfortable in the final moments when people were arguing in the parking lot. It was Saturday evening about 8. I would come again, maybe a touch earlier.

Gail Bailey

We thoroughly enjoyed our lunch experience today, the food was tasty, our waitress was attentive and very patient. Will be back for sure on our next visit.

Wyatt abbey

I like trains

Jason Noll

One of the best local restaurants I've been to in this area. The PB&J wings were amazing as were the salt & vinegar wings. Our waiter was polite and helpful. A very nice quaint restaurant. We will be back sooner than later.

Luke Reisinger II

Very clean facility with a rustic feel, amazing wine selection and full bar, great dinning areas upstairs and down. Fit for a date or the whole family. Definitely a must stop.

Christopher Boswell

The staff is extremely professional.

Jeffrey Ormsby

Always have a good experience when dining or even just relaxing with a few drinks

Corinne Lapp

I have been taking a few days to think of how to properly write about my experience. My boyfriend and I went to get a bite to eat while visiting my brother at Alfred State. Once seated, the 2 top that came in at the same time, ordered AND was served food before we had even ordered. About 20 minutes in, a 6 top came in and ordered before ultimately I found a waitress who wanted nothing to do with us. We finally put our order in. The 6 top got served and ate before we even got our food. I am shock because lets just say we didn't look like the fellow customers. The blonde waitress was so rude when we asked for help and had her phone alarm was going off while taking care of OTHER tables. I am sadden because the menu was diverse and the game room upstairs was nice. To anyone who fits their 'wanted' clientele should expect to have a nice time. I am so angry and disappointed that we were treated the way we were especially in 2024. :(

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Amy Fanton

It was ok, nothing to brag about. But nice.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Robert Wise

Great food and drinks! Highly recommend!! I will definitely be back many times!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: French Fries, Chicken Wings, Mill Burger

Bobbie Morey

Extremely fun laid-back environment. We happen to be there on trivia night and it was a madhouse, but that did not affect the quality of food nor the quality of service . This will quickly become one of our new favorite places to come visit when we’re in New York . Thank you! Keep up the great work!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chris McGowan

Was in town for a game and had dinner after. Seems to cater more towards the drinking crowd. Had 5 folks and 1 had to sit on a chair at the edge of the table in the flow of traffic. The subs were the shining part of the meal. Both Mac and cheese options were not good - small portions, kinda bland, and broken sauce.

The fingers were soggy and no real heat.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Marta Gutigorri

It's a cool, cozy place to have a drink and a snack. The wings were delicious.
The waitress who served us was very unfriendly and rude.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 1

Leah Witherell

All the staff were friendly. Our server Dallas was pleasant, professional and attentive. Our food came quickly, everything was fresh and the prices are very reasonable. Nice place, large menu, decent food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Loading...