The Old Mill Inn
1 Depot, Alfred Station
(607) 587-9060
Customers' Favorites
Bacon and Blue Burger with Fries
Spicy Carolina Gold Wings
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Roadhouse Mac N Cheese
Mac N Cheese Bites
Battered Fish Fry
Roadhouse Burger
Pepperoni Pizza
Baby Back Ribs
Mac and Cheese
Menu
Photos
+30 photos
+29 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
This is a good place to eat. Food was good. Waitress attentive. Order French Onion soup- not such a fan of dark bread (rye?) in the soup. It overpowered broth. Parm fries need more parm. But the place was interesting. Upstairs didnt get to but filled w arcade games and pool tables. Outside seating nice in summer. Only felt uncomfortable in the final moments when people were arguing in the parking lot. It was Saturday evening about 8. I would come again, maybe a touch earlier.
One of the best local restaurants I've been to in this area. The PB&J wings were amazing as were the salt & vinegar wings. Our waiter was polite and helpful. A very nice quaint restaurant. We will be back sooner than later.
Extremely fun laid-back environment. We happen to be there on trivia night and it was a madhouse, but that did not affect the quality of food nor the quality of service . This will quickly become one of our new favorite places to come visit when we’re in New York . Thank you! Keep up the great work!
You May Also Like
Subway - 916 State Rte 244
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food
Little Sicily Pizza & Restaurant - 933 State Rte 244
![]()
Pizza, Pet Friendly