Jersey Mike's Subs

3030 Niagara Fls Blvd, Amherst
(716) 335-9996

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Steve Horton

Food was incredible! Service was incredible but what topped it off was the cook (Quran) was finishing his shift and on his way out stopped at our table where my son was sitting with a broken leg. He said “hope you feel better man” as my wife replied that it happened at football. Quran turned to my son and said “if you fall, you just have to get up stronger”
GREAT STAFF at this location!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Fred Oehler

Ordered a turkey & provolone and got NO PROVOLONE. Not impressed by $20 sub.

Brady Unger

I don’t usually write reviews, but I had to after my visit to Jersey Mike’s. From the second I walked in, the energy was on point! The staff was upbeat, super friendly, and genuinely seemed happy to be there—which made the whole experience even better. You don’t always get that kind of vibe at a sandwich shop!

Now let’s talk about the #9 Club Supreme… WOW. That sub is on another level. The roast beef, turkey, bacon, melted provolone—all stacked high and made fresh right in front of me. I got it Mike’s Way (obviously), and the combo of flavors with the juice, lettuce, tomato, and onions? Chef’s kiss. Every bite was loaded with flavor, and the bread was perfectly soft with a slight crunch—just how I like it.

Honestly, this wasn’t just a sandwich—it was an experience. Fast, fresh, flavorful, and served with a smile. Jersey Mike’s, you’ve officially earned a lifelong fan. 💯🥪🔥

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Emily Luchterhand

Loved it. Better subs than anywhere else. Get it with oil and vinegar. The Chipotle chk melt and the #2.

Frank Pizza

Good food. Good 👍

Jake Ferrari

Employees always super cool to me and the food is always great.

Zee

There are better sub places in the area. Hell! Even Wegman's subs are better than what they make here. They skimp on ingredients to an insane degree, to the point where I can take SEVERAL bites of my sub and only manage to bite off bread. The prices are too high, the ingredients aren't high quality, the bread is low quality. The only real upside is the people at the location rock. They're super nice and bust their butts to get work done ASAP. Everything else though sucks

debra gleaton

I thought I ordered a whole sub. When it was handed to me I realized it was not.. Since I was new to the shop I wasn’t aware that regular meant half sub.
When I let the server know she argued and justified. I was not upset just making her aware. It was rude.

crystal Kelly

I love the service it's quick and easy to order and the subs are amazing I tried the turkey this time The subs are pretty big especially if you get everything on it but I'm a picky person so I only got turkey cheese tomato mayo oil

Rachel Rocheleau

I usually love this location until my latest experience. I ordered from this location online and had it delivered. I clicked no dressing no mayo and wrote for it to be dry. When it arrived it was wrong. Not a problem. I call and speak with a manager who tells me if I can find a ride that day he will remake it. I said no Thank you as I had already placed another order from them with the same direction. The manager then proceeds to explain that he can not do that, he is the only one who will honor my remake, "that wasn't asked for" . I was then informed someone will call me in 3 days. I called again. No one is there to speak to me.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Moe Oren

Great place and great sandwiches ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Thomas Bolender

Second try. Very disappointing both times. $20 sandwich that I wouldn’t pay $8 for again. Stick with the proven local restaurants and shops. Never again.

Rashpal Jammu

The best sub I've ever had. The ingredients are fresh and that sub juice takes the flavour to the next level. The staff is friendly and know how to compile a quality sub.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Club Sub

Dripside Team

Great location.

Philip Waclawski

Unwrapped my sub and half of it was in the wrapper. Normally would say it’s fine, but at $13/sub I’d expect there to be better care on how it’s packaged.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Loading...