My Tomato Pie

Name: My Tomato Pie
Address: 3055 Niagara Fls Blvd, Amherst, New York, 14228, US
Telephone: (716) 838-0969
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.3

$$ • Italian, Pizza, Vegetarian

Hours:
3055 Niagara Fls Blvd, Amherst
(716) 838-0969

Menu Order Online

About My Tomato Pie

My Tomato Pie is a conveniently located restaurant with a parking lot in front and easy wheelchair accessibility. The facility is clean and well-maintained, featuring a welcoming entryway and a counter with a host to greet and seat guests. The restaurant offers a variety of menu options, including huge chicken fingers, a 1/2# cheeseburger, and personal pizzas like the Viagarro Pizza and Carissa Pizza with fresh dough and cheese. The menu also features the fantastic steak and banana pizza, along with other popular choices. The Cobb salad is a standout, with dressing that makes your mouth water, and the stuffed banana peppers and buffalo egg rolls are amazing. Customers appreciate the food for being cooked to perfection, with great attention to presentation and flavor. The staff is friendly, polite, and down-to-earth, providing excellent service. The restaurant is suitable for dates, families, and small seminars, with a banquet room available for private events. The pleasant atmosphere includes pull shades for natural light and privacy. Recent reviews highlight the delicious Eggplant Parm, served with a generous portion of spaghetti and an Olive Garden style bread stick, though some feel it should come with a salad or veggie side for the price. Many customers enjoy the variety of sandwiches and salads, praising the fresh dressings and homemade condiments. The personal pizzas are considered the best deal, with quick service and options to create custom combinations. While reservations can be made online, some find that unnecessary and prefer calling to avoid marketing emails. My Tomato Pie remains a great choice for those seeking delicious food and a comfortable dining experience.