My Tomato Pie

3055 Niagara Fls Blvd, Amherst
(716) 838-0969

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Courtney Sorrento

Delicious Eggplant Parm but for 20 bucks or so it really should come with a salad or veggie side. Comes with an Olive Garden style bread stick. It also comes with a LOT of spaghetti!! 🍝 I got extra sauce for $3 because sauce!! I love their sauce. Sometimes I order a quart for $8 because it's delish and have it a couple of nights with my own pasta for dinner.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

C Stramaglia

One of my favorite places to visit with friends and eat great food! Great service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Karin Rogers

The broiled fish was way too salty, and I could not eat it. The french fries were plain, they did not have a coating. Coleslaw was good. Overpriced compared to other places that have great fish fries in the area.

Bella Menza

I enjoyed an array of sandwiches and salads from this establishment at a bridal shower recently and I was blown away by the taste and quality. We had turkey sandwiches and Cajun chicken sandwiches on focaccia along with pasta salad and green salad. The dressings were fresh and there was a variety of toppings and home made condiments. I would definitely recommend and look forward to having their food again!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marlene

Surprisingly more formal than I expected. Not a pizzeria, but a pleasant sit-down restaurant with good food, excellent wait staff and cozy atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

NY Explorer

Their personal pizzas are the best deal here and affordably priced to create your own combination. Service was fast. You can make a reservation online but I don't think it's really needed. I have been getting marketing emails twice a day now since making a reservation. Maybe calling them and not giving your email would be better. They do have a rewards program too which is nice.

Food: 5

Connie Kudrna

Very disappointed with my meal. I ordered eggplant parm
for dinner. The skin was still on the eggplant, making it hard to cut. There was very little breading. A side salad was sold separately. This meal was on the expensive side ($30). When looking at other restaurants for the same meal,prices ranged from $20-24 including a side salad.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4

Stephen Zaleski

Very friendly people and good food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Suparna Banerjee

Ordered take out from her while visiting Niagara . It was very close to our Airbnb.

Viagarro Pizza-5/5 ( nice veg fresh, dough was fresh and so was the cheese) would have loved more veggies on them.

Carissa Pizza- 4/5.Chicken Pizza dough was also very fresh and the cheese was really good. Chicken protein was good. Would had loved more veggies.

Definitely worth visiting.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Robin Stevens

Tomato basil soup is superb!

M Black

The food is very good and the service was excellent.

Terri Ringler

My granddaughter loved the pizza.

Jodi Rizzo

Just fab! I cannot wait to return!!

Pat Lane

Slowest service ever. We were there at 2:30, not a busy time. The waitress mostly seemed to wander aimlessly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 2

Ange Bus

Not impressed. The service was poor and our meals were of poor quality. I ordered the eggplant Parmesan and found the cutlets to be tough and unflavored. The sauce was thick and brown in color which offered a strong acidic flavor. It appeared to have been made days ago. My husband had the chicken cacciatore which resembled shredded chicken with mushy onions and peppers possibly cooked in that same brown acidic sauce days ago. The texture and appearance was slop on the plate. The pasta itself was on point as it was Al Dante. Server was not interested in asking why my dish had 2 bites taken from it and our glasses sat empty from half way through the meal until we asked the hostess for take out containers and our check. The hostess provided our containers, and then the server brought our check and asked if we wanted another drink as she was preparing to hand us our check. It was a slow night as there were only a total of 4 tables. I'm not sure why the service was so poor. Overall, the restaurant itself offered a nice ambience, but kitchen and service could use some guidance.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...