Papi Grande's Mexican Restaurant and Cantina

4276 Maple Rd, Amherst
(716) 836-7274

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Sizzling Fajitas
Chips and Salsa
Burrito Grande
Refried Beans
Pulled Pork
Burrito Bowl
Tres Tacos
Quesadilla
Rice Bowl
Guacamole

Menu

Papi's Taco Cart
Arabe
grilled fajita chicken, cucumber, pico de gallo, diosa verde dressing, flour tortilla
Gringo
TACO BEEF ON SHREDDED QUESO BLANCO, LETTUCE, CHIPOTLE RANCH, FLOUR TORTILLA
Cancun Shrimp/Fish
sauteed shrimp or amberjack yellowtail, pineapple mango salsa, avocado, mojo sauce, flour tortilla
Tropical Bang Bang Shrimp
BEER BATTERED SHRIMP TOSSED IN BANG-BANG SAUCE, LETTUCE, PICO DE GALLO, TROPICAL CREMA, FLOUR TORTILLA
Stinger
HOT CHICKEN TENDER, CARNE ASADA, QUESO, LETTUCE, FLOUR TORTILLA
Nashville Hot
El Smoky Vegano
plant based taco "meat" in smoky viaigrette, mango fire roasted pineapple salsa, pepper adn onion blend, avocado, corn tortilla
Carnitas
PORK CARNITAS, GUACAMOLE, SALSA VERDE, CRUMBLED WON TON, CORN TORTILLA
General Tso's
Chicken in General Tso's Sauce, Fried Rice and Green Onion
Buffalo Bison Dip
Potato Chip Crusted Chicken, White American Cheese, Pico de Gallo Green Onion with Spicy Bison Dip
Philly Cheese Steak
BBQ Pulled Pork Mac n Cheese
Our famous Queso Mac n Cheese, paired with Chipotle BBQ Pulled Pork and topped with bread crumbs
Chicken Finger
Fiesta Veggie
Black Bean and Corn Medley, Cilantro Lime Rice, Pico de Gallo and Cotija Cheese finished with Chipotle Mayo
Pittsburgh
Grilled Carne Asada, Cajun tossed French Fires, Lettuce and Cheddar Cheese drizzled with Honey Mustard BBQ sauce
Birria
Chipotle Chicken Bacon Ranch
Adobo Chicken, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato with Chipotle Ranch
Hermano
BEER BATTERED CHICKEN ON SPANISH STYLE PIMENTO CHEESE, PICKLED CABBAGE & BBQ SAUCE, CORN TORTILLA
Felipe
FIRE GRILLED SKIRT STEAK IN FELIPE SAUCE & QUESO, FLOUR TORTILLA
Hibachi
Grilled Carne Asada and Shrimp, Fried Rice, Peppers, Onions and Cabbage with Teriyaki Sauce
Chicken Fajita Taco

Appetizers
Chips & Salsa
HOUSEMADE SALSA, WARM TORTILLA CHIPS
Guacamole & Chips
MASHED AVOCADO, PICKLED JALAPEÑO, ONION, CILANTRO, LIME
Papi's Famous Queso Dip
OUR FAMOUS MELTED QUESO BLANCO DIP, BACON 1/ GROUND BEEF 2/ CARNE ASADA 4
Papi's Kicked Up Queso Dip
Mexican Street Corn Dip
fire roasted mexican street corn, queso with chili peppers, lime, cilantro and cotija cheese served with corn chips
Papi's Nachos
MOUNTAIN OF WON TON CHIPS, QUESO, LETTUCE, PICO DE GALLO, PICKLED JALAPEÑO, BLACK OLIVES, SOUR CREAM, BEEF OR CHICKEN
Brussel Sprouts
CRISPY-FRIED BRUSSEL SPROUTS IN SMOKY ORANGE VINAIGRETTE, WITH A SIDE OF BANG-BANG SAUCE
Flight Of Amigos 3X
Fried Flour Tortillas Served with bowls of queso, salsa verde, street corn dip
Nashville Hot Buffalo Cauliflower
coated in a spicy Nashville breading, fried and served with a side of ranch
Grilled Mexican Street Corn
seasoned
Birria Egg Rolls
WON TON STUFFED WITH CHORIZO, SHREDDED QUESO BLANCO, BLACK BEAN & CORN MEDLEY, SIDE OF QUESO AND ENCHILADA RED SAUCE
Primos Poutine
FRENCH FRIES, GROUND BEEF, QUESO, LETTUCE, PICO DE GALLO, CREMA
Birria Nachos
Mami's Nachos

Entrees
Chimichanga
CRISPY FRIED FLOUR TORTILLA WITH MELTED CHEESE & CHICKEN OR BEEF, SMOTHERED IN QUESO, WITH SHREDDED CHEESE AND PICO DE GALLO
Burrito Grande
FLOUR TORTILLA LOADED WITH SPANISH RICE, BEANS, LETTUCE, PICO DE GALLO, CHICKEN OR TACO BEEF, SIDE OF SOUR CREAM & GUACAMOLE
Quesadilla
GRILLED FLOUR TORTILLA STUFFED WITH CHEESE, PICO DE GALLO, PEPPERS & ONIONS, CHICKEN, TACO BEEF OR VEGETARIAN
Tres Tacos
3 TACOS YOUR WAY. FLOUR TORTILLA OR HARD CORN, YOUR CHOICE OF SHREDDED CHICKEN OR BEEF, SERVED WITH LETTUCE, SHREDDED CHEESE, PICO DE GALLO & SOUR CREAM
Enchilada
4 OVEN BAKED BEEF & CHEESE ENCHILADAS IN CORN SHELLS, WITH ENCHILADA RED SAUCE & SHREDDED CHEESE, TOPPED WITH LETTUCE, SERVED WITH GUAC & SOUR CREAM
Sizzling Fajita
A HOT CAST IRON PAN SERVED SIZZLING WITH A BED OF SAUTÉED PEPPERS & ONIONS, YOUR CHOICE OF PROTEIN IN FAJITA SAUCE. SERVED WITH LETTUCE, CHEESE, SOUR CREAM, PICO DE GALLO AND FLOUR TORTILLAS
Margarita Carne Asada
8 oz new york strip steak marinated in our house made marg mix, topped with mojo citrus lime sauce and served with grilled Mexican street corn and Baja seasoned rice

Salads/Bowls
Baja Bowl
choice of protein "mexi-cali " seasoned rice and black beans, fire-roasted corn, avocado, pico de gallo, pickled onion, creamy cilantro and lime dressing carne asada +4 / fajita chicken +3
South Of The Border Cobb Salad
chopped romaine, fajita chicken, shredded queso blanco, black beans, corn, avocado, pico de gallo, cucumber, sliced egg, chipotle ranch
Taco Salad
shredded lettuce, taco beef, corn, pico de gallo, black olives, shredded cheese, sour cream and salsa served in a fried flour tortilla bowl guacamole +2

Sides
Mexican rice
Refried beans
Fries

Dessert
Churros
FRIED-DOUGH PASTRY COATED IN CINNAMON SUGAR COVERED IN A CHOCOLATE DRIZZLE SERVED WITH WHIPPED CREAM
Fried Ice cream
VANILLA ICE CREAM COVERED IN A CINNAMON SUGAR CEREAL COATING DEEP FRIED. COVERED IN A CARAMEL & CHOCOLATE DRIZZLE SERVED WITH WHIPPED CREAM

To-Go Margs
Single margarita
Quart Margarita

Enchilada Pack
Enchilada Pack

Taco Box
Taco Box

Quesadilla Pack
Quesadilla Pack

Appetizer Pack
Appetizer Pack

Cinco Grande Fiesta
Cinco Grande Fiesta

Birria Box
Birria Box

Dip Box
Dip Box

Specialty Taco Box (10)
Specialty Taco Box (10)

Specialty Taco Box (20)
Specialty Taco Box (20)

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+26 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+25 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

First thing, do not go expecting a traditional Mexican restaurant or you well be as disappointed as my wife and I. Second, portions are small for the price (3 tacos chips and dip, and 1 alcoholic beverage $50+) and the food was not seasoned well, salsa was definitely from a jar. The atmosphere is cool but more geared towards a younger crowd, loud music (profanity included). Hopefully the management takes some of these reviews as constructive criticism and makes a few changes
July 2025
I love it here and have always come here and gotten the same thing and I have never had an issue. However, the one blonde waitress is very rude and i receive severe attitude everytime i ask for a simple small modification and she tells me the cooks don’t speak english and i can’t do it… even tho i was able to do it all the time before. It’s literally like no tomatoes or something and the past couple times this has happened.
July 2024
Last night came out for the live music and it was such a great time. The food was delicious and made with love and the staff was all so friendly and kind. But I really was impressed by the manager Katrina. I watched her move from both inside and outside checking on tables and helping her staff anyway she could. But what I really wanted to point out was one of the staff was leaving for the night and Katrina thanked them for all their hard work. Managers like Katrina I don’t see...
July 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Sunshine Cafe II - 300 Corporate Pkwy # 100N
Cafe
Tea Leaf Cafe - 4224 Maple Rd Suite 124
Coffee & Tea, Bubble Tea, Asian Fusion, Vegan
Anchi A La Carte - 4224 Maple Rd #122
Vietnamese, Noodles

Papi Grande's Mexican Restaurant and Cantina

4276 Maple Rd, Amherst, NY 14226
(716) 836-7274