Oakley's Wood-Fired Pizza & Grill

44681 NY-28, Arkville
(845) 586-3474

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Donna Catlow

Great atmosphere, service and friendly staff. pizza was great

Megan LePage

We had the best dinner there this past Friday! The drinks were wonderful (Blueberry margaritas & local beers? Yes, please!), the apps were great (Fried pickles! Yes!), & the pizzas (Hawaiian & cheeseburger!) were soooo good. Just as wonderful, though, were the chill but festive ambiance, our lovely server’s attentiveness, & the pizza cook’s general awesomeness. (I’m sorry I don’t remember your name, dude, but my husband chatted with you at one point & said you were wicked sincere & good-natured, even with the crazy load of pizza orders you were filling!) Thanks for everything, Oakleys; we’ll be back! 🍻

Abhilash Pradhan

Everything about this place was outstanding! The pizza, food , the beers on tap & the desserts were on point !

After a long time I had such delicious pizza and the crust was just delectable!! The Greek pizza was noteworthy and a must order here !!

The Korean barbecue Chicken Wings I think are a must try and so are the Garlic Shrimp! You won’t get over the buttery sauce for a long time though.

On to the desserts and I bet you can’t stop at just one of their Bundt Toffee Cake ! Served warm ,these are every bit good as they look and impossible to forget for a long time .

If you are in the area , this should be the place for a nice meal and some good drinks .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Shrimp, Buffalo Chicken, Chicken Wings

A Y

Oakley’s makes one of America’s best burgers.
Well-worth the drive.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Edward Calhoun

Great place, great service and great food.

Cindy Cromwell

Sat outside with outstanding views of the mountains..The chicken cutlets were some of the best I ever had,salad was generous crisp and well chilled and the service was great , helpful and friendly. Great value and a must if you're in the area !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tony DiBattista

seemingly i am in a unique club by posting a less-than-stellar review of this establishment. essentially, I base reviews on the amount of money spent for services/food rendered.

twenty-eight dollars for a bar pie and a beer.

twenty-eight dollars.

I want to meet the person who wrote "Two meals, three drinks for $60 is amazing." - I find that sentence hard to understand.. the English makes sense, but the sentiment is ludicrous. I wish I had read it prior to popping in for a bite - as I would have stayed away.. though, I would have always wondered.. as I had in the past when I would drive by and see cars upon cars parked along the road. i digress; i entered. (and was accosted by fruit flies for the duration of my stay)

nine dollar beers are a travesty in every sense of the word.. concerts and professional sports charge far too much for a cold one and that should be viewed as criminal. i didn't expect to pay near double digit dollars for a beer along route twenty-eight on a random thursday afternoon - but I did. if I knew that a pint of pilsner would set me back $9.50 I would have drank water.

perhaps being open only Th, Fr, Sa & Su limits the ability to generate money. i'm not sure. If I'm in that area again for some reason, I might order take-out because the pizza was great but the prohibitive prices lead me to know that I won't be back.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 3

Elizabeth

The appetizer were delicious and the pizza was worth the wait….as they mentioned. Outside seating is nice , you get a nice view of the mountains enjoying a slice with your beer :) ? ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: BBQ Wings

Polina Bakhtina

Lovely pizza. Note that some of the menus on Google maps are outdated. Specifically, the impossible burger is no longer served here. Additionally, some of the prices have increased. We did take out for our meal from Oakley's. It was ready very fast, and the service once we came to pick it up was also quick and easy. We ordered over the phone, and that worked out great. Strongly recommend the margarita pizza!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza

David Grabovetsky

Great place to stop for a bite. Pizza quality was top notch. Staff was friendly and helpful.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza, Garlic Knots, Pie

Michael Grasso

The food BBQ pulled pork and potatoes salad was to die for the best this side of the Mason Dixon line. The portion were large and the price was right. Start off with the Buffalo Chicken wings. Get this they serve real blue cheese not ranch dressing. My buddy had a Margherita pizza that was wood fired. Again, he said it was excellent. The owner is a very nice person the atmosphere was great . Lots of wait staff. Good service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza, Buffalo Chicken, Pulled Pork

Collin Ansbach (Boomer’s Dad)

Super helpful staff and very pup-friendly! Would highly recommend the signature pizza as it was absolutely delicious. Will be back soon once snow season comes back around!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rebecca Messier

We picked a high-top table by the roadside near closing time and had such a sweet waitress. The burgers were AMAZING ? Soon to return!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brandon Ballard

Great spot. Loved the patio. Enthusiastic karaoke dj right at the end of our meal. Pizza was cooked well.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza, Garlic Knots

dean collins

Pizza base needed more time (eg not cooked through) this said flavours were nice.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 5

Loading...

Oakley's Wood-Fired Pizza & Grill

44681 NY-28, Arkville, NY 12406
(845) 586-3474