West Island Grill

1173 Grand Ave, Baldwin
(516) 214-6395

Recent Reviews

Sort by
MIKA'IL SANKOFA

This place reminds me of a relative of mine who went by the nick name of “Queen. “She’d ask me before I came to the table to eat - “Ya hand clean?” That’s what this place strikes you as being, as soon as you step in - cleanliness! It’s a relatively new addition to the neighborhood eateries and it’s spotless, the display of food is on point, and you have a side salad option in addition to the regular Caribbean favs - Ox Tail, Curry Goat, Jerk Chicken, etc. I had the goat tonight and the meat was tender and the gravy was an amazing combo with the coconut flavored rice and peas. They have an assortment of beverages sorrel, peanut punch and tonight I got a few coconut waters to finish the meal! This is my go to and they are open until 10 weeknights! Mmmmmm is all I can say! Food is so good when done right! Next level cuisine and service! Glad they are now in my neighborhood!😉🫶🏾🥰

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lucreitia Casper

The food is delicious and fairly priced I’ve been going since they opened. I can say that they are consistent with the quality of the food. Great customer service.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Eric Hill

The food is delicious, the employees are polite and the atmosphere was welcoming. I felt like they appreciated my business. They weren't rude and disrespectful like their close competition. 5 stars for that alone. Continued success!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marleny Calderon

They over charge...If you get a small size is the same price as the big one...I got a large so many times and went back and got a small of the same food and got charge the same price as the big one... ripped off

Service: 1

natasha rhodes

Great food. Poor customer service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 1

Thomas Sku

Food is good but sometimes cold. Porridge is amazing some days and other days it’s salty

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Calvin Gabriel

The food is absolutely amazing plus the service is top notch! Big props to Asheen and Brittany!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joseph Malenda

I’m a Returning Customer and the service I got today was so poor I will not be returning the last time I went they I got served by a serve Asheena or something like that and she was amazing but today I went with hoping to see her however she was not the one who serve me the young lady that served me has no manner she have a lot of attitude her customer service was so poor I think her name is briti her customer service is so poor worst I am spending my hard earned money I don’t play bout hospitality and customer service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 1

pauline anderson

I went to West Island G. this evening for dinner, and while the lady was serving meals to me and others, I noticed a conversation coming from her boobs —only to realize her phone was tucked there. I’m just wondering, are breaks no longer given? Why should customers have to listen to someone’s personal conversation while being served?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 2

Jeanette Janik

The food is amazing I had the jerk salmon with rice and peas today and I was service by a female her name is asheen I told her I was going to make a review because her customers service amazing and food is was worth every penny good Job West Island and thanks again asheen

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Honey Dipped

BRINTI IS THE ABSOLUTE BEST provided the greatest Hospitality ever... for a place that has come into the Baldwin atmosphere greatly appreciated with great food great people

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

taa paul

Excellent restaurant, the food is very tasty, the staff is very pleasant. 10/10

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Scidamenge

The food is really delish. Had the jerked salmon with mashed & Cabbage. Its all really good. They have a sweet sauce as well. The jerk chicken is great too. The girls are all very nice and respectful. They only have 1 table to sit though. It would be nice if they had more. Best Jamaican food I ever ate so far in my life. 😃

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chris Holman

I walked in at 945pm. They close at 10. I got bad attitudes, Cold beef patties and to make it worse she tried to overcharge me for more beef patties. I don’t want 5 beef patties at 10 pm, are you mad!😠 What makes it worse is that I really wanted PIZZA from next door but they closed because of an accident on Grand Ave. smh….do better my people!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Brittney Stoudemire

Sooo yea this was like my 4th try here. So i like the food, The oxtails is a bit on the extra spicy side. But my issue is… Every time i have to turn around because they forget something or didn’t prepare your food as you asked. I picked up a large oxtail for my husband. First off he complains about the basmati rice which they use but is okay if it has gravy on it. I asked for oxtail gravy on the rice three times! Just to get home after my kids came from the pool and to see he dissatisfied because they gave him a big plate of dry rice! I ordered a large! Got three oxtails cut in half?!?! For 22 dollars a plate. C’mon on! I’m cool paying but not when you’re being cheap on the food and charging top dollar.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Loading...