The Fish Store
836 Montauk Hwy, Bayport
(631) 472-3018
Customers' Favorites
Stuffed Clams 3pcs
Lobster Bisque
Seafood Bisque
Fish Sandwich
Fresh Seafood
Clam Chowder
Yellow Rice
Fish & Chips
Calamari
Scallops
Menu
Photos
+50 photos
+49 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
This was our second time here and we had an awesome 4 course meal for New Year's Eve lunch in this comfortable atmosphere with a spot-on waitress. It was a perfect way to bring some fresh seafood luck into the New Year!
My husband and I came here for Restaurant Week and had such a great experience! We started with the salad from their regular menu—the dressing is absolutely amazing. The entrees were fantastic, and the rice pudding… wow, it was UNREAL! The staff were so nice, our waitress Nicole was also great!
Perfect for a casual dinner out. Definitely recommend this place!
Perfect for a casual dinner out. Definitely recommend this place!
The Fish Store in Bay Shore is hands-down one of the best places for fresh seafood on Long Island. Everything is incredibly fresh — from the clams and shrimp to their beautifully cut fish fillets. You can tell they take real pride in quality and cleanliness.
The staff is always friendly, knowledgeable, and willing to help with cooking tips or recommendations. Their prepared foods and takeout meals are also fantastic — especially the lobster rolls and crab...
The staff is always friendly, knowledgeable, and willing to help with cooking tips or recommendations. Their prepared foods and takeout meals are also fantastic — especially the lobster rolls and crab...
You May Also Like
Sunflower Cafe - 825 Montauk Hwy
![]()
French, Cafe, Bakery, Pet Friendly
Satelite Pizza - 799 Montauk Hwy
![]()
Pizza, Gluten-Free, Vegetarian