Jersey Mike's Subs

869 Montauk Hwy, Bayport
(631) 419-5609

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ray Smith

It was a dam good fresh italian hero. Some deli's can't make them this good.

Utf1127s Biggest fan

The lady at the counter yelled at me for daring to try to get utensils saying its in the bag. Sorry you dont want to restock utensils, ma'am maybe you shouldn't be dealing with paying customers

John Halter

Decent sandwiches here. Made correctly and fast service.

Daniel Grant

Great service and delicious sandwiches

Tara Sinclair

Very fresh. Good sandwiches

Frederick Smith

Great hero.. but, $20.00 bucks is pricey for a hero... Just saying...

Will C

First time trying jersey mikes out.
Omg Delicious, really nice staff and the place is immaculate.
I'm in the restaurant business and very conscious of these things.i wish I had another sandwich.
Great job

Ryan M

The guy who took my order was kinda shot , I asked for a chipotle cheesesteak on rosemary parm and wanted to add mushrooms and he said you couldn’t do that, but you can for an additional fee. Also when they rang me up they were about to ring it up as a chicken one when I said the regular one. Finally when I got my sandwich it was not on rosemary parm when I opened it in my truck. Wake up dude. Everyone was nice.

Thomas Sirianni

Had an order delivered tonight via Grubhub, this is not the first time...all previous experiences were excellent. This time, 3 sandwiches approx 87 dollars. Upon arrival, one of the 3 was missing. The bag was sealed shut with 3 closures. I called the store to offer to pick up the sandwich, but was put on hold immediately and given to who identified themselves as the manager. She promptly told me, with indignation, she prepared my order and bagged it personally so there was no way it left the store without all 3 items. I tried to tell her that it was impossible for it to have been removed, as there were 3 closures on the bag. She would hear nothing, she just informed me as if I were a child to contact Grubhub. When I continued to try to resolve the situation (before I got angry with my treatment) she just put the phone down and walked away...leaving it off the hook.
What has happened to treating your customers with respect, I was not accusatory, just trying to rectify an error...everyone makes mistakes.
BTW..the food was very good as usual.

John Masem

Great sub sandwiches made fresh to your specifications.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Salad Bowls, Club Supreme, Club Sub

Business Badger

I had the worst experience at Jersey Mike’s. The place is an absolute dump. From the moment I walked in, it was clear the store wasn’t properly maintained—dirty floors, unorganized shelves, and just overall neglect. To make it worse, I found mold in my food. How does that even happen? It was honestly disgusting. The entire place is a dump, and it’s clear they don’t care about cleanliness or quality. This location is an absolute dump, and I won’t be coming back. Wouldn’t recommend it to anyone.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Legacy Ndl reviews

Can't go wrong with a chicken Philly or tuna.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kevin Carey

Great staff and service. Awesome sandwhiches

J Dolce

Roast beef sandwich is always delicious! Consistency counts. Have never heard anything negative about this place. Try it.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Cheesesteak

Kerri Gottlieb

Staff is amazing! Go out of their way to help. Sandwich was as good as can be for a chain. Would go back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Phil Cheese Steak, Salad Bowls, Kids Meal, The Original Italian, Jersey Shore's Favorite, Cheesesteak

Loading...