Weir's Ice Cream

2159 NY-94, Salisbury Mills
(845) 496-4258

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Sara B

Always the highlight of my summer. 10/10

Tinntq “TTVthegoatkid”

I had a great experience today Weirs! The young kid who helped me was extremely polite and helpful. He gave me plenty of recommendations, and was very nice and polite even though I was very picky. He even helped me in picking my new favorite flavor, All the Chocolate. Definitely a must for ice cream lovers.

Tanner Wright

When I came to this establishment from Westchester and didn't know what to expect, from a vast selection of flavors to the customer service. I asked for the small cone of the cookie monster I believe and I gotta say 10/10. The service was excellent thanks to the young man with the striking mullet oh man haha. Can't wait for next year.

Savannah minckler

Great ice cream with great service from jess!!

Cee Tee

Went to Weir's with the family. Ordered a Hot Fudge sundae, they forgot to put the fudge on. Asked to sample the Vegan option, very quickly to say no. My medium size serving was smaller than ones small size.
Not ever going back.

Jodi Christel Brandal

Michael Weir, Kevin and the rest of the staff at Weir's Ice Cream are AWESOME! They went way above and beyond to help me with a special order. Thank you all and please never stop making the best ice cream ever!

Gina Marie Miele

This ice cream stand is outstanding. They have the best ice cream, really fresh and creamy- with a thousand types/flavors to choose from. The servers are happy and friendly. The only bad thing is they're not open year round!!

AngelSky Grace

We basically have to stop here every time we come to visit and lately its been often. They will just about make you anything you can dream of. Homemade ice-cream. I love the sundaes, ice cream floats, milkshakes everything here is Soooooo GOOD!!! The staff are some of the nicest people you will encounter. There's a lovely space to sit at tables outside. If you are in the vicinity make this place a priority!!

Regina M. Carfizzi

Absolutely amazing! We experienced the honey bizarre which was full of walnuts, dates, and figs! Then we had the chance to try pralines and cream and chocolate peanut butter. All of them were amazing.!! Then there’s a spot to actually sit down in the shade and enjoy the ice cream. It was really a nice experience and I am surprised being that it’s so close to me that I have not been there more but it’ll definitely be a regular place for us to visit.!!!!! The staff was attentive and helpful and sweet as can be ! I read that someone said something about the price we paid $15 for two ice cream cones that were in waffle cones and stuff to the brim with ice cream. I had no problem at all paying that $15 and I will pay it again.!!

Allen Fuhrman

Going here for decades. Excellent soft serve

Tony Mack

Need better and larger to read menus

Sarah “Tata” Binns

OMG I was so lost in my single scoop of mint chocolate chip in a cup for my angel Xavie. That ice cream was so wonderful. The mint and mini chips danced perfectly together.
My Phee enjoyed her chocolate soft serve with rainbow sprinkles. A great Sunday afternoon.

Steven

The best ice cream stand in the Hudson Valley. They have an amazing selection of seasonal flavors. The ice cream is always refreshing and delicious.

A huge bonus they don’t charge extra for using a credit card!!!!! This alone should be 10 stars! A+++++

Sandy S.

Great variety of flavors. Nice ambience, and great outdoor seating.

Kathryn Squitieri

Delicious, amazing selection of homemade ice cream at very reasonable prices. Lovely outdoor grounds to enjoy the many treats that Weir's has to offer.

Loading...