Weir's Ice Cream

2159 NY-94, Salisbury Mills
(845) 496-4258

Recent Reviews

Bluesdriver63 A.

Classic old time ice cream stand. Weir's was used for a scene in the movie "The Irishman". We go there all summer. It's open now for the season.

Kristina M.

All homemade ice cream but not a fan of the taste. However, great atmosphere and most people love it!

Amelia M.

I love weir's ice cream! Classic ice cream stand with many choices! Their ice cream cakes are great too !

Sonda Durbin

Loved it best ice cream

Ric Gee

Always fresh, delicious, and worth the trip!

Brady Doyle

The ice cream is awesome very cheap and nice the ice cream cakes wow just wow! The prices really match for the size of the ice cream cake you buy.I mean $65 for the biggest one I mean it does make sense I can't wait till next summer:)

Thomas Severino

Both the ice cream and the prices were great

MightyMightyScott

Classic, I Grew up around this place all my life and I absolutely love it, I get a bit emotional being away from Orange County I always loved their Nerdy Bear?

Jose A Chavarria

Very good service and the ice cream delicious, I had the rocky road

embee Kay

Popa & I take our grandsons here!! Excellent ice cream!

Ashley McEwan

Lots of variety and reasonably priced. Best ice cream!

Padma W.

This is a very popular local ice cream parlor. I almost never asked for a sample. However, I didn't want to risk trying the coconut milk ice cream. But, he said they don't give samples, which was a bit disappointing. Otherwise, the ice cream was average, and I'm not really sure what all the hype is about.

Noreen Fennell, Realtor

Fabulous homemade ice cream. My personal favorite: Coconut Almond Joy.

Jorge Boneta

Good ice cream, but the menu was to complicated.

Trevor Allen

What a delightful surprise when we were in the area. I have certainly been missing out. I loved all the flavors of ice cream I tried, but the Spicy Hot 'Chocolate was a standout. I can't wait to go back!

Load More