Carla Marla has so many different flavors of ice cream and specialty sundaes/milkshakes that you are sure to find the right sweet treat for you! I loved how the building resembled a candy store from the 1900s, with shelves and buckets filled with all sorts of candies. I got to try their mint flavor, birthday bash, and cookie dough and everything was so good. It reminded me of childhood flavors which was very nice. I definitely want to go back to try their floats and specialty sundaes!
Nicole D.
Here's the scoop: Carla Marla's is the sweetest little ice cream parlor on Long Island! From mint chip and strawberry ice cream to peanut butter shakes and root beer floats, this shop has classic and fun flavors. Plus, the prices are fair for the amount of ice cream you get.With its charming small town vibe and welcoming atmosphere, Carla Marla's is a sweet spot to visit while strolling through Bellport Village.
Tameca Hayward
I don't eat ice cream often, but when I do I'm a kid again. I had the birthday cake ice cream, and I topped it with pop rocks ?
Hammer
Ice is good here , but there are other places that are better..
sheila ferguson
No sugar free ice cream
Steve
Ice is good here , but there are other places that are better..
Aimee skaggs
The pistachio ice cream is fabulous!!
Mariah B.
Who wouldn't love some homemade ice cream? The ice cream parlor is a tiny, little cottage. Although small, the line moves pretty quick. I ordered chocolate ice cream with rainbow sprinkles and my husband ordered coffee. My chocolate ice cream was extremely creamy and delicious. Their sprinkles were also fantastic. My husband said his ice cream was outstanding! They offer a looooot of toppings. Come hungry!
Brian Forseth
I've gone there with my granddaughter a few times. We always enjoy our birthday bash and coffee ice creams. The young people there work really hard and do a nice job.
Great place to go after a visit to the beachDelicious coffee shakes and root beer floats hit the spot.
Health More
Great ice cream and friendly staff. I tried the cookie dough and it was amazing. I will definitely be back!
Alyson K.
This place is extremely adorable. Prices are fair! They seemed very clean! Definitely would recommend Delicious
Jeff L.
Love this place! Friendly staff and all the flavors we've tried have been great. Even when the line is jammin' they keep things moving quickly. Feels like a little slice of "vacation land" off Main Street.
Carla Marla has so many different flavors of ice cream and specialty sundaes/milkshakes that you are sure to find the right sweet treat for you! I loved how the building resembled a candy store from the 1900s, with shelves and buckets filled with all sorts of candies. I got to try their mint flavor, birthday bash, and cookie dough and everything was so good. It reminded me of childhood flavors which was very nice. I definitely want to go back to try their floats and specialty sundaes!
Here's the scoop: Carla Marla's is the sweetest little ice cream parlor on Long Island! From mint chip and strawberry ice cream to peanut butter shakes and root beer floats, this shop has classic and fun flavors. Plus, the prices are fair for the amount of ice cream you get.With its charming small town vibe and welcoming atmosphere, Carla Marla's is a sweet spot to visit while strolling through Bellport Village.
I don't eat ice cream often, but when I do I'm a kid again. I had the birthday cake ice cream, and I topped it with pop rocks ?
Ice is good here , but there are other places that are better..
No sugar free ice cream
Ice is good here , but there are other places that are better..
The pistachio ice cream is fabulous!!
Who wouldn't love some homemade ice cream? The ice cream parlor is a tiny, little cottage. Although small, the line moves pretty quick. I ordered chocolate ice cream with rainbow sprinkles and my husband ordered coffee. My chocolate ice cream was extremely creamy and delicious. Their sprinkles were also fantastic. My husband said his ice cream was outstanding! They offer a looooot of toppings. Come hungry!
I've gone there with my granddaughter a few times. We always enjoy our birthday bash and coffee ice creams. The young people there work really hard and do a nice job.
Best ice cream EVER
Restaurantji Recommends
Great flavors at a great price
Great place to go after a visit to the beachDelicious coffee shakes and root beer floats hit the spot.
Great ice cream and friendly staff. I tried the cookie dough and it was amazing. I will definitely be back!
This place is extremely adorable. Prices are fair! They seemed very clean! Definitely would recommend Delicious
Love this place! Friendly staff and all the flavors we've tried have been great. Even when the line is jammin' they keep things moving quickly. Feels like a little slice of "vacation land" off Main Street.