The Irish Mafia Brewing Company

This place has gotten to be one of our favorite stops. Food variety is excellent and always delicious. People are wonderful and extremely attentive!

I came here for my birthday with my son and daughter in law and friends two years ago had an amazing birthday the food and service is excellent and have become a regular ever since the beers 🍻 are always great the entire staff is amazing and I do have some favorites such as Hanna

If I could leave no stars I would based on the service. I have always loved this place since it opened, the food is outstanding. However you should hire competent staff that know what they are doing. My Moscow mule was made with lemonade not ginger beer. The bartender asked if I wanted my jamo shot chilled and then didn’t even pour a full shot. When the rest of our group joined we were told they can’t split the check with a party of 6 or more. Which I understand but we had been there for an hour before they arrived and our bill was already at $100. To be told the best they can do it split 3 cards equally is insane. Why should the rest of our group pay for our bill when they only had one drink. I’ve been a server and bartender for 10+ plus years, I know it’s not hard to make a new check. Go above and beyond for your customers. I will never return to this establishment after being a frequent customer from the day they opened.

This is a long shot but... I really hope Gordon Ramsay considers bringing Kitchen Nightmares to the Irish Mafia! I've been living in Bloomfield for four years, and my first visit to the Irish Mafia was fantastic. Unfortunately, the quality has significantly declined since then. My boyfriend's grandmother experienced food poisoning, and I couldn't even finish my ruby egg rolls because they were so dry they stuck in my teeth. To make matters worse, my boyfriend's grilled cheese was served cold, with unmelted cheese. Honestly, a frozen meal from Dollar General would have tasted better! Additionally, the bathroom sink looks like it hasn't been cleaned since my first visit.

I’ve gone here many times as I’ve was told they had one of the best Rueben’s. From the first time I tried the food til now, I’ve always been blown away and happy. The atmosphere is great, service is awesome and food is one of my favorite ever. We will continue to be regulars at this place and recommend it to anyone looking for a small town, chill environment with amazing food across the board!

One of our favorite stops when we're out and about. They Have an excellent selection of craft beers and the food's amazing.

This Is Such A Great Place With Good Food & Fantastic Craft Beers. Every Year We Come To The Finger Lakes From The Western NY Area, And This ALWAYS Our First Stop! Grab Some Beer To Go, You Wont Regret It!

We stopped by traveling from Buffalo to Penn Yan and had a delicious lunch. Highly recommend the Kirby and a Road Trip beer. Great combination! Emily was our server and she was friendly, helpful and seemed to go the extra to make us feel comfortable and well taken care of. We will be back with friends and family!!!

Came here on NYE mid day, super quiet only a few people. We ordered the inciders and the gangster garbage plates. I am sooooo picky with my garbage plates but these were the best by far. Their cheese sauce is awesome and a twist on a garbage plate. Our server Zach was very friendly. We will definitely stop back again! The proportions are well worth the price.

I enjoyed the Mafia Rules 101 and wings

Once again I need to add in reply: no we did not eat your food, only tried. It was bad. Your server admitted it was cooked yesterday. Particularly she was proud she “cut salad cucumbers yesterday herself a night before and sorry it is not fresh”. She was not stiffed, she did not get tip because she brought food which was not fresh, greedy and tasted bad. Yes I drank the stout . What it had to do with serving poor quality food, charging extra for using MC and charging for salad you substituted French fries with?!
No, I did not See original review below. Because business replied I would like to add:
Your reply is not without a twist. I was brought glass of lager which I did not ask for, I asked for ipa. Yes I said I do not drink larger. I don’t. I offered your hostess/waitress to pay for it anyway.
I did return salad and asked for one without onions? So what? I was suppose to eat it?I am allergic . I did not ask for carrots. Buy the way those carrots were bitter and stale.
I indeed was charged for both salads though salad was a substitute for French fries. And yes the food was bad and she admitted she did it herself a day before. She did not get a tip because those who bring bad food and overcharge do not deserve it. It is simple. I did have a lady with me , my friend, she was a witness to this and said she never comes back. We felt bad after your food. That’s all.
If you look on your cameras we barely touched your food - it was bad. Greasy . Ugly presented. But we still paid you money.
And you did charge extra two dollars for using a card. It was not a discount. I wonder if it violates your NC or Visa agreement. Find out. I wonder if we got it like this from her and place because we both were not local? No? Regards
I want to start with positive - beer and IPAs are good. Place is clean. Great atmosphere. Prices are reasonable. To regret food is dearly bad. Burgers are distastefully greasy, giving impression of being made from stake meet. Sales are made from stake dying tomatoes, frost bitten cucumbers. Hummus looked strange and tasted like a hummus paste from a cane. Hostess was nice and polite. I asked to substitute French fries for salad and was billed for salad, twice, $3 not a big deal. When we asked about quality hostess replied that Dhaka precut and precooked it herself day before and now it is old. But it is what it is she said. She also added $2 for using credit card. Sad experience , bad food, ipa was wonderful.

This establishment is so welcoming and friendly! I have been here many times and the staff is very diligent and accommodating to all situations. My husband and I have gone for date night and really enjoyed ourselves. We are also able to go as a family and bring our 5m old baby. This restaurant is versatile and overall maintains an amazing atmosphere no matter what brings you in. HIGHLY RECOMENDED!

Do the bbq sundae. So weird but delicious.

Maybe just an understaffed bad day... Food was great but some things pricier than they should be.

Excellent example of a modern brewery serving craft beers and great food. Seems like it's located in the middle of nowhere, but the drive will be worth it. Soups and burgers are fantastic. Prices are reasonable for what you get.