Fabulous dining experience. Delicious cocktails and food with HUGE portions. The staff were friendly and warm. We'll be back the next time we're on Long Island.
Lorelei
It was Father's Day, and we waited a long time for our main meal to be served. Two tables of four arrived after us, and they received their meals and dessert before we received our meals. Our waiter seemed very nonchalant. The waitresses at the other two tables hustled and were very attentive. We had to flag our waiter down to ask where our meals were. He was not apologetic and did not come to see how they were after they were served by the busboys.....
Jared
Brought my wife here for her birthday. This was the first time we tried this gem. Service and food were excellent. Probably most tender clams and veal I have ever tasted. Will definitely be back.
Bruce
A pleasant surprise. A Friendly staff and great food. Large portions of well prepared Italian dishes. I will Definitely return.
Janet
We were seated promptly by the hostess. The ambiance of Stella's is on point. Service was good. I ordered the beet salad and split it with my Aunt knowing how huge that salad is. We both loved the rainbow beets, candied walnuts and goat cheese balls. My husband enjoyed his Caesar salad. I ordered pasta with sausage and broccoli rabe, delicious. Portions are huge. My husband had chicken Parmesan and my Aunt had veal Parmesan. They both loved their meals. My husband had the prix fix meal so he also enjoyed chocolate mousse cake, very rich deep chocolate. My Aunt and I shared the cheesecake Always great food at Stella's.
Joy P
We had a First Holy Communion party there. The food that was selected was served family style so that everyone had the opportunity to taste everything from the menu. Our servers were very attentive making sure no one was without a drink, water, soda, juice, clean silverware or plates, etc. Can't wait to go back for dinner!
Alexis Alpert
Yesterday, I had my baby shower at the restaurant and the staff, food, etc. exceeded all of my expectations. To start the staff is amazing. As soon as guests walked through the door, they were greeted and asked if they wanted a drink. They were on top of bringing out the food, and making the guests feel welcome. The food was absolutely delicious. At the end of the party a lot of our guests came up to me to say how much they loved the food and also how pretty the room was. The staff also took great care of one of our family members who has a food allergy.
Shout out to Bayron who took such good care of us since the day we walked in to book the party! Cannot thank him enough for all of his help and enthusiasm to make the party perfect.
Fence guy
Fabulous dishes. Fantastic staff If you haven't been, go now. If you have go back.
Eric Lovastik (QuidEstVeritas)
Bland bland bland. The bread has more flavor than the food.
Steven T
Just had our daughter's Bridal shower there. Food, service and atmosphere were all Stella. Everyone had a great time. Food was fantastic.
Excellent food, so delicious and the portions are amazing. Great friendly staff. Beautiful atmosphere both inside and outside.
Dorothy Mann
Food was very good, service was great. Our waiter Angelo was fantastic
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Ravioli, Caesar Salad
AIM
I was very excited about our 7:30 pm reservations with my family. I noticed google review had 4.3 stars but the people who reviewed this establishment must of gave 5 stars to White Castle!! On our arrival we noticed for a Saturday night the restaurant was half full. The hostess proceeded to sit us at a 4 top in the busiest part of the restaurant. We ordered mussels for an appetizer which took at least 20 minutes so we thought WOW this must be worth the wait . When the mussels arrived, half were unopened and the broth had no flavor at all. We knew then we were in trouble. After waiting yet another half an hour our entrees finally came out. My wife ordered the special, steamed Seaford Platter that was recommended by the waiter. I ordered Veal Sinatra and my son ordered Surf and Turf. The Veal Sinatra looked like a bad Chinese take out dish ,soupy and the veal was tough. Surf and Turf came with planko buttered lobster with no lobster shell steak and was undercooked. The Steamed Seaford Platter was the worst. ENTIRE DISH WAS COVERED IN THE SAME PLANKO AND BUTTER SAUCE.Red snapper was heavenly covered with buttered planko. When I cut into the Snapper the fish did not flake which told me it was at least 2 weeks old . The scollops were not scollops they looked like they were punched out from skate wings. These entries were over $50.00 each . The owner and chef should be ashamed for putting out such poor quality food. If u dine at this restaurant make sure u bring a portable potty in your vehicle because this food will go right through you!! Not quality food for what they are charging.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jayne Bushmann
We celebrated my husband’s 75th birthday last night with 25 family members I can’t begin to say how exceptional everything was. Byron was incredible! So many rave reviews about food , ambience,service! Thank you to everyone at Stella trattoria
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Q
Excellent Food, Excellent Drinks, Excellent Service, Excellent Music, Excellent Atmosphere. If you have not been here, you are missing out. Our favorite restaurant! I would give 10 stars if I could. A great time for the entire family! Thank you Stella for a wonderful experience every time!
Fabulous dining experience. Delicious cocktails and food with HUGE portions. The staff were friendly and warm. We'll be back the next time we're on Long Island.
It was Father's Day, and we waited a long time for our main meal to be served. Two tables of four arrived after us, and they received their meals and dessert before we received our meals. Our waiter seemed very nonchalant. The waitresses at the other two tables hustled and were very attentive. We had to flag our waiter down to ask where our meals were. He was not apologetic and did not come to see how they were after they were served by the busboys.....
Brought my wife here for her birthday. This was the first time we tried this gem. Service and food were excellent. Probably most tender clams and veal I have ever tasted. Will definitely be back.
A pleasant surprise. A Friendly staff and great food. Large portions of well prepared Italian dishes. I will Definitely return.
We were seated promptly by the hostess. The ambiance of Stella's is on point. Service was good. I ordered the beet salad and split it with my Aunt knowing how huge that salad is. We both loved the rainbow beets, candied walnuts and goat cheese balls. My husband enjoyed his Caesar salad. I ordered pasta with sausage and broccoli rabe, delicious. Portions are huge. My husband had chicken Parmesan and my Aunt had veal Parmesan. They both loved their meals. My husband had the prix fix meal so he also enjoyed chocolate mousse cake, very rich deep chocolate. My Aunt and I shared the cheesecake Always great food at Stella's.
We had a First Holy Communion party there.
The food that was selected was served family style so that everyone had the opportunity to taste everything from the menu. Our servers were very attentive making sure no one was without a drink, water, soda, juice, clean silverware or plates, etc.
Can't wait to go back for dinner!
Yesterday, I had my baby shower at the restaurant and the staff, food, etc. exceeded all of my expectations. To start the staff is amazing. As soon as guests walked through the door, they were greeted and asked if they wanted a drink. They were on top of bringing out the food, and making the guests feel welcome. The food was absolutely delicious. At the end of the party a lot of our guests came up to me to say how much they loved the food and also how pretty the room was. The staff also took great care of one of our family members who has a food allergy.
Shout out to Bayron who took such good care of us since the day we walked in to book the party! Cannot thank him enough for all of his help and enthusiasm to make the party perfect.
Fabulous dishes. Fantastic staff
If you haven't been, go now. If you have go back.
Bland bland bland. The bread has more flavor than the food.
Just had our daughter's Bridal shower there. Food, service and atmosphere were all Stella. Everyone had a great time. Food was fantastic.
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent food, so delicious and the portions are amazing. Great friendly staff. Beautiful atmosphere both inside and outside.
Food was very good, service was great. Our waiter Angelo was fantastic
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Ravioli, Caesar Salad
I was very excited about our 7:30 pm reservations with my family. I noticed google review had 4.3 stars but the people who reviewed this establishment must of gave 5 stars to White Castle!! On our arrival we noticed for a Saturday night the restaurant was half full. The hostess proceeded to sit us at a 4 top in the busiest part of the restaurant. We ordered mussels for an appetizer which took at least 20 minutes so we thought WOW this must be worth the wait . When the mussels arrived, half were unopened and the broth had no flavor at all. We knew then we were in trouble. After waiting yet another half an hour our entrees finally came out. My wife ordered the special, steamed Seaford Platter that was recommended by the waiter. I ordered Veal Sinatra and my son ordered Surf and Turf. The Veal Sinatra looked like a bad Chinese take out dish ,soupy and the veal was tough. Surf and Turf came with planko buttered lobster with no lobster shell steak and was undercooked. The Steamed Seaford Platter was the worst. ENTIRE DISH WAS COVERED IN THE SAME PLANKO AND BUTTER SAUCE.Red snapper was heavenly covered with buttered planko. When I cut into the Snapper the fish did not flake which told me it was at least 2 weeks old . The scollops were not scollops they looked like they were punched out from skate wings. These entries were over $50.00 each . The owner and chef should be ashamed for putting out such poor quality food. If u dine at this restaurant make sure u bring a portable potty in your vehicle because this food will go right through you!! Not quality food for what they are charging.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 1
We celebrated my husband’s 75th birthday last night with 25 family members
I can’t begin to say how exceptional everything was. Byron was incredible! So many rave reviews about food , ambience,service!
Thank you to everyone at Stella trattoria
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent Food, Excellent Drinks, Excellent Service, Excellent Music, Excellent Atmosphere. If you have not been here, you are missing out. Our favorite restaurant! I would give 10 stars if I could. A great time for the entire family! Thank you Stella for a wonderful experience every time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...