Stella Trattoria & Bar

7 Montauk Hwy, Blue Point
(631) 363-7500

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Marc

Beautiful decor, modern, bright and very clean. The French Martini was excellent, beer was excellent too. The Caesar salad was fantastic, pasta dish was great, but the veal was very tough and hard to chew. We sent it back for a chicken dish, They were quick and happy to exchange the dish for us, and the chicken was great. Excellent friendly service, our waitress was Isabella. Yes, we will return, we really liked it (except for the veal).

Barbara

So much food we each brought home another nights dinner. Drinks are fantastic and Angel is perfect!!

Lee

If you order a dish with filet mignon you expect it to be rare and tender not well done and tough. And not enough waitstaff for the number of tables. Very nice when available but not available enough to say that dinner was not what was expected.

Customer

The restaurant and restrooms were very clean and pleasantly decorated. Convenient location and food was decent. On this particular evening, the restaurant was pretty empty, so it's hard to understand why it took forever to get our food and for our waiter to attend to our needs. He was nice but very quiet and a bit awkward and noticeably absent enough for it to become a joke amongst our guests. After he asked if we wanted dessert and we said no, he just never came back with the check. We had to flag down a busboy and ask for it. Other than this, I would come back again as my hope is this was an anomaly.

Catherine

Lovely meal. Wait staff was good but busy and took longer than necessary to get attention but all fine. Definitely give it a try

Noreen

I celebrated my 50th birthday at Stella on Friday night with 3 of my closest girlfriends. We all enjoyed our meals, service was top notch and I had a wonderful time!

Rochelle

Food was plentiful and delicious. Service was friendly and professional. Lovely restaurant. Our first visit but won't be our last.

david

This has been our third time visiting Stella‘s and again we've been blown away absolutely delicious food. The cosmos are perfect and the service was impeccable and we keep bringing our friends back. This is our go to place. Thanks again.

Annie

Our waiter Angel was very nice but he was very slow and noticed it took awhile for him to put our dinner order in the kitchen he took at least 1 more order. We waited over an hour for our dinner and he delivered my husbands surf & turf minus the turf! Doesn't your wait staff check the food prior to delivering? Not a good experience at all.

Jessica

Food was excellent as always. Just wished you itemized the bill . Wish I knew how much I was charged for everything. You used to itemize everything this time it just gave a us the total price. Otherwise you would have received 5 stars all around .

Jason Hart

Roaches in the bathroom and the kitchen area, Greedy rude owner and staff.. So we reserved a day for 10 for dinner and me and my fiancée just wanted to be officially wedded by a officiant outside, then the ten of us would have dinner. They wanted to charge us 1000 dollars just to let us do that outside and they wouldn’t have any part of it.. They not only lost a big party.. They lost some potential customers and they definitely lost our business for good. They would have had lots of good reviews with pictures.. Now they will get all bad feedback and bad reviews. They don’t even care, they act like they don’t even need our business truthfully.. We already found a nicer restaurant who welcomed us in and didn’t try to milk us for every penny and show a snob attitude.. I would never recommend Stella’s ever again..

Alison Elizabeth

My husband and I enjoyed our wedding anniversary dinner here and we can’t give enough stars ⭐️ for such a wonderful dinner. From the moment we walked in the service was impeccable. Such a beautiful place, romantic and upscale. Enjoyed a peach martini 🍸, Lobster 🦞 ravioli, clams oreganta ,… Dinner was delicious. Portions were large, plenty’s to take home. Finished the night with a surprise chocolate cake to celebrate our special event. This was our first visit and definitely not our last ! Thank you for the wonderful service and memorable experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

kenneth

We had a very enjoyable dinner with our company. The service and food were both very good.

Laura Congema

We had a 70th birthday party for my husband on Sunday … one word describes our total experience…awesome!! Byron coordinated everything to absolute perfection … !! The table was beautifully decorated… the cake gorgeous (and delicious)! Now for the food … words cannot describe… everything was DELICIOUS… beginning with appetizers through family style feast dining!!
I really cannot rave enough about Stella’s!! Staff was attentive and professional!! Shout out again to Byron!! 🥰

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joseph Mazzella

This is our first of what will be many visits. Excellent service, ambience and staff. Byron is how all waitstaff should be, very personable and friendly and professional. The lobster ravioli was amazing. The fried calamari and the octopus salad were delicious. Spaghetti carbonara and the chicken Marsala were outstanding! We highly recommend this restaurant and we will be back soon! Again our compliments to the staff!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Lobster Ravioli, Linguine Carbonara, Calamari Fritti Arrabbiata

Loading...