Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

Sept 2025: 5 star review. sat down inside and was treated perfectly. It was three of us. The waitress was so nice. The food was absolutely perfect. The garlic knots were the best knots I’ve ever had. Cheesy and garlicky perfection. Would order these every single day. Ordered 16” Paulie’s pie with pepperoni. It did not come out burnt. The taste was perfect!!! Also order buffalo and garlic parm wings. The buffalo sauce was out of this world. The garlic parm was average but still tasty.
I have to say I would return.

August 2025: was a 4 star review. Ordered online and did a pick up. Pizza tasted yummy but lots of the pizza was burnt from the coal fired oven. We couldn’t eat the crust. Otherwise, great flavor

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Fast friendly service, never crowded in this location. My favorite anthony's 😍

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

This was our first time at Anthony’s! We went to the one in Bohemia, NY tonight 8/16/25 at 4:00 pm. When we got there, there was only one other table. Another family came in while we were there. The kitchen staff preparing our food was talking so loudly that my husband and I could not even hear each other across the table. I am all for a lax work environment, but to be this loud and disruptive is unacceptable. We couldn’t hear each other across the table and there were only two other tables in the whole restaurant. The waitress was lovely and attentive! But it was so loud inside because of the kitchen staff that we will not be returning.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 4

Once upon a time, I would fixate on Anthony’s food. Something happened in 2025 that the service and food changed. I run here on my 30 minute lunch break occasionally and either have to eat the incorrect/not made well food, or go back with the few minutes I have left on my break because my order just hasn’t come out right or good this year at all. I paid $14+ for this sandwhich today that as usual was mostly arugula and this time instead of undercooked Focaccia, I received thick, burned foccacia. It was eating a steak. The picture does not do it justice. What is going on that customers are paying over $14 for arugula ????? I assumed the first few times it was a fluke. This has been consistent now. I can’t waste anymore time or money here. I used to love this place.

Pizza 5.5/10 barstool sports

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Grreat personal pies! Salads too...crispy crust, flat pizza

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 5

We were so happy to find this place! Great family-friendly restaurant, and the food and service were excellent! Adult beverages available too! Pictured is a meatball and ricotta pizza, which was delicious 🤤 The cheese pizza was too!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Just enjoyed another evening at Anthony’s Coal Fired, Bohemia. Meatballs, wings and chop salad were delicious. Our server Sam was amazing in every way! Thank you for making our visit so enjoyable. See you soon, Joe & Donna

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

First time to this location, same stuff we loved at the Wantagh location.
The well done wings and the well done pizza is what we are used to and this airport location does it just as good.
We have been ordering the cauliflower pizza for years and just love the combo!
The wings with onions is a signature combo for ACF too, love them both.
We were greeted upon arrival for our p/u, and shortly after we were on our way home to enjoy our two favorites!
No stars for atmosphere since we didn't stay, but check the pic for yourself.
I'd recommend Anthony's keep the area behind the counter a little cleaner...(see pic).

Food: 5

Service: 5

I was in Bohemia due to some flight re-routing out of LaGuardia. Which is to say I would have never have planned to be this deep in Long Island on vacation. I wanted to salvage the travel day with a good meal. I was blown away. I know that you need high temperatures to get the char right for pizzas. But 900 degrees from a coal-fired oven? We ordered three different pizzas and they were all amazing. This pizza is orders of magnitude better than what you can get at most walk-in places in Manhattan. I'm sure you can find comparable pizza in downtown New York, but you might have to mortgage your house to pay for it. We also got some garlic knots and their dessert platter. Every part of this meal was fantastic. The place was clean and the service was very good. If you can't get to Bohemia, the company has other locations in New York, Pennsylvania and Florida.

Went there for dinner tonight. There were no garlic knots left?!? What pizza place runs out of garlic knots. Half the pizza was completely burned, so I guess if you like burnt pizza this is your spot. Everything was mediocre at best. The waitress was the best part, she was super friendly.

Pizza was just fine. I was looking forward to good NY pizza and was disappointed. Crust was dark and hard and flavor of cheese and sauce was just okay.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Food is very good, but if you pay with ur rewards they will fuss about giving ur drink even though its on the receipt as a combo they told i did not pay for it and only give half the normal portion on my sandwich. I got a takeout and found only half the sandwich present and the special instruction not followed. So dont use rewards even if they give you i guess - a joke of a rewards program to retain customers. Def not going back

Food: 4

Service: 1

The food is good, pizza is a little disappointing. The service however is excellent. If you can ask for Kayla. She was professional, helpful & one step ahead of us all night. She did a great job

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 5

Good pizza & baked ziti was yummy too! Service was also great, thanks for the good food before my flight.