Sundaes on Main

2414 Main St, Bridgehampton
(631) 488-7692

Recent Reviews Order Online

Menu

Frozen Yogurt and Ice Cream
You Choose Frozen Treat & Toppings
You choose 12oz of frozen yogurt and toppings. Although we're very careful when filling the machines, for those who have a peanut allergy, please note the chocolate yogurt is in the same machine as the peanut butter yogurt. Frozen yogurt cups will arrive with yogurt and toppings packaged individually, so the toppings don't loose their texture during travels. Once you receive the order, it's just like coming to the store and creating your own sundae. We strongly advise utilizing the priority option that Uber Eats offers for delivery. We realize it's an extra expense, but being the frozen yogurt is a bit time sensitive, priority guarantees a better product.
Toppings
If you'd like to add toppings to your fro-yo!
Pineapple Dole Whip Straight Up 12oz
The name says it all ;) We strongly advise utilizing the priority option that Uber Eats offers for delivery. We realize it's an extra expense, but being the frozen yogurt is a bit time sensitive, priority guarantees a better product.
Pineapple Creamsicle 12oz
12oz of Pineapple Creamsicle - it's a must try as it holds the title of best seller! A twist of Dole Pineapple and Velvety Vanilla Ice Cream. We strongly advise utilizing the priority option that Uber Eats offers for delivery. We realize it's an extra expense, but being the frozen yogurt is a bit time sensitive, priority guarantees a better product.
Traditionalist, Vanilla Ice Cream with Rainbow Sprinkles
12oz of Plain Ol' Vanilla along with a cup of rainbow sprinkles. All our frozen yogurt cups come with the yogurt and toppings packaged individually, so the toppings don't loose their texture during travels. Once you receive the order, it's just like coming to the store and creating your own sundae. We strongly advise utilizing the priority option that Uber Eats offers for delivery. We realize it's an extra expense, but being the frozen yogurt is a bit time sensitive, priority guarantees a better product.
Sundaes On Main Sundae
12oz of Southampton Salted Caramel fro-yo along with cherry sauce, hot caramel, almonds, chocolate sprinkles, chocolate crunchies & whipped cream. Yum! Frozen yogurt cups will arrive with yogurt and toppings packaged individually, so the toppings don't loose their texture during travels. Once you receive the order, it's just like coming to the store and creating your own sundae. We strongly advise utilizing the priority option that Uber Eats offers for delivery. We realize it's an extra expense, but being the frozen yogurt is a bit time sensitive, priority guarantees a better product.
Chocolate on Chocolate on Chocolate Ice Cream Sundae
12oz of chocolate ice cream along with chocolate sprinkles, chocolate crunchies, chocolate chips and hot fudge. The more chocolate the better! Frozen yogurt cups will arrive with yogurt and toppings packaged individually, so the toppings don't loose their texture during travels. Once you receive the order, it's just like coming to the store and creating your own sundae. We strongly advise utilizing the priority option that Uber Eats offers for delivery. We realize it's an extra expense, but being the frozen yogurt is a bit time sensitive, priority guarantees a better product.
Peanut Butter Whoa Frozen Yogurt 12oz
12oz cup of peanut butter frozen yogurt, along with crushed Reeses Pieces, chopped peanuts and peanut butter sauce. Frozen yogurt cups will arrive with yogurt and toppings packaged individually, so the toppings don't loose their texture during travels. Once you receive the order, it's just like coming to the store and creating your own sundae. We strongly advise utilizing the priority option that Uber Eats offers for delivery. We realize it's an extra expense, but being the frozen yogurt is a bit time sensitive, priority guarantees a better product.
Pup Cup, Vanilla Ice Cream
Don't forget about a treat for your pup! 4oz of vanilla ice cream topped with a milk bone dog biscuit & drizzled with peanut butter.
Peanut Butter & Jelly Fro-Yo Sundae
12oz of peanut butter fro-yo, along with peanut butter sauce, strawberry sauce, chopped peanuts and crushed Reeses Pieces. Frozen yogurt cups will arrive with yogurt and toppings packaged individually, so the toppings don't loose their texture during travels. Once you receive the order, it's just like coming to the store and creating your own sundae. We strongly advise utilizing the priority option that Uber Eats offers for delivery. We realize it's an extra expense, but being the frozen yogurt is a bit time sensitive, priority guarantees a better product.
**Caramel Frozen Yogurt Turtle Sundae
12oz cup of caramel frozen yogurt, along with hot fudge, chopped almonds and miniature caramel filled chocolate turtles. So CUTE! Frozen yogurt cups will arrive with yogurt and toppings packaged individually, so the toppings don't loose their texture during travels. Once you receive the order, it's just like coming to the store and creating your own sundae. Frozen yogurt cups will arrive with yogurt and toppings packaged individually, so the toppings don't loose their texture during travels. Once you receive the order, it's just like coming to the store and creating your own sundae! We strongly advise utilizing the priority option that Uber Eats offers for delivery. We realize it's an extra expense, but being the frozen yogurt is a bit time sensitive, priority guarantees a better product.
Mystery Grab Frozen Dessert
12oz of randomly selected frozen yogurt flavors. Please note these cups may contain nuts, peanuts, milk, eggs, wheat. If you have an allergy to any of the above, we would suggest avoiding this offer. This offer includes just the yogurt, toppings sold separately. Flavors will be chosen at random. Some flavors contain gluten, nuts, peanuts, milk, eggs. We strongly advise utilizing the priority option that Uber Eats offers for delivery. We realize it's an extra expense, but being the frozen yogurt is a bit time sensitive, priority guarantees a better product.
Alana's Sundae
12oz of Fat Free Montauk Mint fro-yo is sandwiched between two very generous servings of rainbow sprinkles (on the top & bottom of cup) then topped with crushed Reese's peanut butter cups.

Candy
Pop Rocks Watermelon
Candy Mystery Grab Bag
A mystery of candy awaits you!
Chocolate Covered Cherry Marshmallow Twists
Dark Chocolate Covered Marshmallows
Two jumbo dark chocolate covered marshmallows. Thick, crunchy chocolate coats two jumbo and oh so soft marshmallows. One of our personal favorites.
Airhead Xtremes
Gummy Worms 8oz
8oz of gummy worms packaged up and ready for your enjoyment.
Mini Chicles Gum Pouch
Cinnamon Bears
Wiley Wallaby Australian Apple Licorice
Hubba Bubba Bubble Tape Chewing Gum
Pop Rocks Gum
Silly Sour Legs - Sour Sugar Candy
Nik L Nip Bottle Candy
Salty Licorice Starfish
Whirly Pop Lollipop
Whirly Pop flavor will be chosen at random.
Soda Can Fizzy Candy
Bazooka Chewing Gum 20 pieces
Nerds Clusters
Bag of Gummy Bears 8oz
8oz Bag of Haribo Gummy Bears
Assorted Nonpareils 8oz
White chocolate Dark chocolate Milk chocolate
Mini Charleston Chew Theater Box
3.5oz theater box of mini vanilla Charleston Chews
Happy Valentine's Day Candy
Gummy Worm Sampler
8oz mixture of: Gummy Worms Sour Neon Gummy Worms Gummy Centipedes
Black Licorice Sampler
9oz mix of assorted black licorices.
Rainbow Shoestring Licorice
Jelly Belly Jelly Beans
Swedish Candy Mix 9oz
9oz of assorted Swedish made candies. Candies will be packaged at random and due to high demand, cannot promise what candies will be included in the mix.
Assorted Nonpareil Berries 8oz
Giant Smarties

Drinks
Ramune Original Soda
Boxed Water

Desserts
Traditional Ice Box Cake
Simple and delicious. Layers of chocolate wafers and homemade whipped cream sprinkled with a few chocolate chips on top.
Sundaes On Main Ice Box Cake
From our secret menu, chocolaty gooey goodness in each bite of our ice box cake. Layers of chocolate, toffee and whipped cream make up this delicious dessert. So yummy! Best served at refrigerator temperature. (Dessert arrives frozen) If you're at the store and would like one, ask for the secret menu item and we'll grab one for you!
Pup Cup, Vanilla Ice Cream
Don't forget about a treat for your pup! 4oz of vanilla ice cream topped with a milk bone dog biscuit & drizzled with peanut butter.
Cookie Dough
7oz of cookie dough ready to take you back to your childhood and memories of stealing a bite out of your grandmothers mixing bowl.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+18 photos
Photo credit: google
+17 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

This is clearly a stored owned by someone who cares about the details. Glitter, sugar, sprinkles and smiles address all that enter. Sundaes on Main, leave no topping or candy out. A very efficiently set up stored and fun flavors for all. The vanilla was perfect, the peanut butter tasted off.

Fun for all ages
September 2025
Kids love this place. Parents, well, not so much. The highs from the nostalgic candy selection in the back is balanced by the lows of the sticker shock from the prices at the scale.
July 2025
This is the best frozen yoghurt spot in the Hamptons. Or anywhere on LI… incredible selection so many flavors to choose from. All are fresh!! Cute little candy store in the back too. Homemade whipped cream is a MUST. That’s what makes this place really special. Nice staff
May 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Dopo il ponte bridgehampton - 2402 Montauk Hwy
Italian
Bobby Van's Steakhouse - 2393 Montauk Hwy
Steak House, Seafood, American
Yama Q - 2395 Montauk Hwy
Japanese, Sushi Bar, Bar, Sushi, Vegan

Sundaes on Main

2414 Main St, Bridgehampton, NY 11932
(631) 488-7692