red door baking company

2083 Albany Post Rd, Montrose
(914) 293-0295

Recent Reviews

Sort by
chrissy juliano

Ordered a custom 1st birthday pink bow & number 1 cookies & a cake for my daughter birthday and everything was absolutely perfect!! The cake & cookies looked exactly like I wanted !
The owners are super sweet & helpful
Not only did the cookies and cake look great but tasted even better !!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Deb Ora Liljegren

I needed some varied sweets for a birthday lunch. I got there shortly after they opened, and they had a great selection. Their credit card machine or service was down, but they made it simple to use cash or Venmo. I had a couple of questions about the pastries and the gentleman at the counter was polite and helpful. These were a huge hit with my dad, and the man is discerning about his sweets. The raspberry lime mousse and lemon meringue were light and flavorful without being overly sweet. The s'mores cupcakes were the perfect size. I didn't try to the double chocolate braid, but it looked amazing. I will definitely be back.

Side note: I usually go to another bakery about 5 mins from here, but the majority of the times that I have gone in there, they make me feel like I am bothering them, and the ordering/menu is chaotic. Not everyone there is unfriendly, but the offerings are not so good that is makes the iffy customer service and shopping experience balance out. Now, I won't go there at all since I know about Red Door.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Natalie Fleysher

Everything is great here! I have not been disappointed with any of the pastries or sandwiches I have order. Be aware they are only open Thursday thru Sunday.

Darryl Richardson

We had Deb make our 30th wedding anniversary desserts and cake three years ago and it's been love ever since. She is wonderful and can bake. She makes it like Mamma made it, but better, if that's possible.
You've got to go and check out all the sweet treats. Have breakfast or lunch while you're there and tell 'em I sent you.
Alabama

CG RS

Delicious one of a kind desserts! Their chocolate mousse cones are my favorite!

C. Wilner-Miguel

Today was our first time visiting. We purchased one of quite a few treats. Such a lovely place and people. I highly recommend. My son and I will make the trip again soon.

J. O.

Can’t thank you enough! The cake was beautiful and delicious. Everyone raved about it. Definitely my go to bakery. Let’s support our small businesses!

Judyth Gladstein Powers Stavans

Wow, a friend recently told me about this lovely bakery and I finally had a chance to stop by today. It's everything I could have hoped for. I picked up a tantalizingly warm Irish Soda Bread, which I was very happy to get, but I got even happier when I found out that it came with Orange Butter. So yummy! I will definitely be back!

Judyth Stavans

Wow, a friend recently told me about this lovely bakery and I finally had a chance to stop by today. It's everything I could have hoped for. I picked up a tantalizingly warm Irish Soda Bread, which I was very happy to get, but I got even happier when I found out that it came with Orange Butter. So yummy! I will definitely be back!

Nahila

I can’t say enough great things about this bakery. I found this bakery because our original bakery didn’t work out. Thank God from looking on google, it led me to Red Door. The bakery is so cute and clean inside. Debbie is extremely sweet and accommodating to what you want. The prices were reasonable, the cake was absolutely delicious and beautiful. I ordered a vanilla bean with cannoli filling cake for my sister’s baby shower. The cake was so moist! Everyone was asking where did we get it from. Thank you so much! I can’t wait to order from you guys again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sarah Stewart

I ordered a carrot cake for my friend’s baby shower this past weekend. The process of ordering was very easy and friendly, pick up was a breeze. The cake was so pretty it made me tear up. Simple yet beautiful. The owner was so sweet.

I am not a carrot cake person yet this cake was DIVINE! Everyone absolutely loved it. So beautifully crafted and delicious. I have tried many of the popular bakeries in the area and this one, based on this experience is the best! Can’t wait for the next celebration so I can try more (although there were tasty looking things at the counter that I could pop in and grab when they’re open!) loved it! 10/10!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shabray Noel

I came here for my son’s 1st Birthday cake & Debbie did a phenomenal job ! The cake was moist and the flavor hit it out the park. I will be coming here again. Also the ice coffee 10/10

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

valerie scanga

Our go-to for any occasion! From their warm, inviting atmosphere to their delectable treats, every visit is a delight. Their pastries are always fresh, bursting with flavor, and beautifully presented. The staff is friendly and attentive, making each experience memorable. (Pictured: sfinge/zeppole & fig cake).

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mollie Reznick

Chicken pot pie pastries: a revelation.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Melanie Butler

BEST hot chocolate with homemade marshmallow you will EVER have! Literally everything on the menu is delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...