Angel's Pizza Restaurant Italian & Mexican Food

They use really fresh and quality ingredients, portions are great and food is fantastic.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great Service and food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I had lasagna and it had no flavor. I couldn't tell the noodles from the cheese because they were so over cooked. The chicken on my salad was rubbery and old. The soup was good but needed salt to enhance flavor.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 4

I ordered delivery, they took my address, I paid and they said it would be about an hour. After half an hour the delivery driver called me to ask for directions, then he said I was 12 miles away and they have a limit of 10 miles. Then Angel’s called me back and said they don’t know what happened but for them to deliver to me I would have to meet the minimum of $75. I cancelled the order and I’m not happy with the service at all

My husband and I moved into an RV several months ago. We decided to start a tradition where we order pizza from a local business when we get set up at a new place. Angel's is number 7! To be honest, they weren't our first choice. The place we chose had a sign on the door saying they were "taking a break". Kinda weird. Angel's wasn't the first choice because of the huge menu. They serve Mexican food, burgers, sandwiches, ribs, "down home" food, pasta, as well as pizza. I always shy away from those types of places because I feel like it's hard to do anything really well when you have that many choices. However, we were pleasantly surprised by the quality of the pizza. The crust was exceptional. Really crisp with a nice chew. Note that the small was quite large, I can't imagine how big the large is! I tried the tomato and basil, which was basically a Margherita style with ricotta added. It was really well done, though I would have loved a bit more basil. My husband ordered the meat lovers with tomato and pineapple added. He was really happy with his as well. They are generous with the toppings too, as a side note. They do have a nice outdoor seating area, but we ate inside. There really wasn't anything special about the inside. It was pretty bland and could use a good cleaning, which we found was typical for this area. The staff was super friendly, which will always outweigh decor deficiencies in my book. We would make this our go-to for pizza if we lived around here.

This place has really gone down hill...food quality is really down hill...

I usually get pizza here, which is very delicious, they make piza dough very thin and sos is not stron tasted which makes good combination, would be perfect pizza if they add bit more cheese, we all love melted cheese. Pay in cash if you dont want to pay commission.

Really great breakfast!

Let’s start with the good news: the woman who took my phone order deserves five stars all on her own. She was kind, professional, and repeated everything back to make sure it was correct—rare and refreshing in today’s world of “what did you say again?” customer service. My order was spot-on. Unfortunately, the pizza itself didn’t quite follow the same five-star trajectory.

I ordered a large cheese pizza with extra cheese, extra sauce, and half sausage and pepperoni. Sounds like a pizza dream, right? Well, it was more like a mirage in the desert of flavor. Even with extra sauce, the pizza was dry—which makes me wonder what the regular amount of sauce is…a whisper? As for the toppings, the sausage and pepperoni were so scarce I thought maybe they were hiding underneath the cheese out of embarrassment.

The crust was fine. Not great, not terrible. Just… there. Kind of like a background character in a TV show—present, but not making any impact.

Bottom line:
Would I rush back? No.
Would I give them another chance someday because of the excellent service? Maybe.
Would I order extra extra sauce and a side of humor next time? Absolutely.

Three stars for accuracy, kindness, and the potential that with just a little more love in the kitchen, this family restaurant could become a family favorite.

“Food that feeds the soul, beauty that speaks volumes, and travel that tells a story always through the eyes of Italy Loves India.”
— Alyson Savino

Had breakfast which they now serve starting at 8am Thursday through Tuesday. Good American diner food.

The people here are always very friendly and I love their pizza! They have such a great menu with a variety of foods to choose from

I personally love Angels Pizza in Cairo, NY. Been ordering from them for 10 years!!!! Now, don’t get me wrong there has been times an order wasn’t right, or I wasn’t happy with a meal. But!!! They have always been good to me as a customer! They will correct the issue make sure I’m happy and fed! I love that they deliver, and I also love that they are so good to local businesses with delivery! I highly recommend Angels Restaurant! And remember, always let the owner know if something isn’t appeased to your liking or you are not happy with the service! Because, he is all about correcting it and making the customer happy!! 😊😍 Which I love! Thank you Angels Pizza and Restaurant! Now, I will say the exact OPPOSITE and just DON’T with Mateo’s in Cairo, NY… it’s entirely opposing of my review. Feed ya belly here!!!

Never had a bad meal here ,I recommend the

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

We have no complaints about Angels at all, weve been going there for dinner since we came to area 6 months ago and have yet to be disappointed. We've tried something from every available option on the menu. The pizza is amazing and so big, the Mexican is the most authentic the quesadilla is worth trying for sure, the burgers are a good size and cooked perfectly everytime, the Panini's are huge and packed with meat and the Philly cheesesteak is the best we've found in a 40 mile radius. Definitely worth a try if your in the area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Had a crisp garden salad with chips and salsa. The salsa was homemade and delicious.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Side Salad