Mateo's Pizza

247 Main St, Cairo
(518) 622-3764

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jaylen

Just as a disclaimer, this was MY experience.
I found this place on maps and decided to give it a try. I ordered sausage and peppers (picky eaters take a hike with your opinions) and the toppings were pretty massive. The sauce lacked so much flavor, as if they used too much water and the peppers were so full of life it made the pizza watery. I also ordered garlic knots and I’m not sure if they made garlic knots previously and just had them ready for someone to order but my garlic knots were so hard, I immediately thought they must’ve been the display garlic knots or something. I dipped my garlic knot in the “marinara sauce” and the sauce did not stick… it lightly coated my garlic knot but I ended up just taking a tough bite and sipped some of the sauce to accompany the hard garlic knot. I’m 6’2 and weigh 200+ lbs and I can eat a decent amount of pizza… I was only able to consume 2 slices and half of one garlic knot. The food made me feel heavy. After I got home and took a nap from overconsumption, I decided to give the pizza another try because I felt I might’ve been harsh on my judgement after all it’s difficult to f’up a pizza… I’d recommend bringing the pizza home if you order from here and heating up slices individually. This slice is far better than whatever I ate earlier. The garlic knots are just as hard, if not harder but they feel they have much better texture. Idk this was my experience, after leaving the place and trying a slice I felt robbed lol but the massive toppings I guess made me feel like I got my moneys worth but food shouldn’t make you feel this heavy.

Also in the pic, I enjoy my food crispy. Possibly my mistake for not specifying how I like my pizza…

Sean Temple

Sucks. Garbage cheese. Garbage sauce. Good talk.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Marissaann White

Good food that you don't find in other places
The service was fast and friendly
Good location and parking
More for take out then for eating in but there are tables if you'd like to sit and eat

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Medusa Ann

Nice people. Pizza is okay

Kelly Myron

Hey there! Momma Donna here. The owners and everyone there are great. The food is delicious, and we have tried many items both eat in and delivery and pick up. It is about time we have a good Italian restaurant . Never disappointed and you will love the portions they give you. Try the Sicilian pizza as well as traditional pizza. yum yum.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

MoOk RuLz

Good italian food I highly recommend the rice balls they are the best around and my go to when I visit .they are delicious.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Peggy Kennedy

The food is good . The prices are fairly high but a 12 ounce bottle of water was $ 2.70 . Ripping people off for a bottle of water is ridiculous.

DaNON Flasher

Pizza is OK at best and some pizzas are weird flavors and combos.
I wasn't a fan but you may like it?

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 3

Matthew Penniston

I got food poisoning from there. They where nice but can barely understand them on the phone.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Bella Antonelli

Really nice workers. Love my food every time. Penne alla vodka is my favorite.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

cj pelliccia

Great food most of the time. Last time I ordered chicken parm and the chicken was not good. First time I didn't enjoy the food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Ed

Food is always

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hillary DiGiorgio

Great food, great people!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mistanylee White

There subs are super dry !!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Troy Boi

It was pretty good pizza, quickly served and a nice selection

Loading...