The food is mostly edible if that’s your thing. I’ve tried a variety of things off the menu from pizza, to burgers, to wings and apps, and pastas. Not once have I ate anything that I’ve been like, yeah I’d eat that again. Also just don’t ever order the bacon bleu burger unless you like it covered in creamy salad dressing… it honestly might have even been ranch. I’d say save your money, there’s better pizza joints in the area… but that’s not even really true unless you go down to Catskill.
J Baron
I have been to this place 3 times at approximately the same time over the last week. I got the same thing all 3 times. 2 slices of pepperoni and a 20 oz bottle of iced tea. I have been charged 3 different prices. 1st time, $9.70. 2nd time, $10.26. 3rd time $11.35. The 1st time it was a younger guy and the other 2 times it was a tall older bald man. Honesty apparently isn't on the menu here.
Edit; Owner response...Market price, Blame Biden. So, $1.65 increase in prices in a 5 day period? Just skip this place and go to the competition down the street!
James Carr
I ordered from this awful place tonight. When i walked in the lady behind the counter didnt say a word to me. I ordered fried dough ($4.50) sausage and peppers sub($8.00) eggplant parm sub ($10.95) and two slices of meat lovers ($7.00). This should have came to $32.89 but instead came to $39.50. While ringing up my order i noticed the lady ring up $11.95 twice,$5.50 and $7.00. I didnt think these prices were right but didnt say anything. When i got home i look at their google page (says it was updated last week) and sure enough the prices displayed are what i thought they were. So i call and ask how much each thing cost and was told all subs are $11.95, thats not what any menu says. She also admitted the fried dough is $4.50 but she charged me $5.50. I told her those arent the prices displayed on their google menu and she said she will “tell brian” Seems like she over charged me because you have to pay with cash and they dont give you a receipt. Based on the looks of this women its no surprise shes stealing from people. On top of all of that, the food was terrible. Its only a matter of time until they get run out of time. Mateos is 1000x better. Dont waste your money here
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
william morelli
The pizza is average Fiona seems nice enough once or twice a week they have a buffet I'll give the buffet four stars
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Anthony Favorito
Fantastic pizza and a great place to eat.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Milani Anderson
I love the food here it’s amazing amazing service and the food was amazing I got some chicken and it was cooked perfectly I also got some calamari witch from here was amazing it was really good and I recommend this to everybody who is around the area
Dayyan
Lwk pretty chill the food is really good never disappointed me
Vanessa Becker
I forgot to tell my father not to go there anymore so he went tonight. He got a large plain and a large pepperoni pizza. They charged him $46!!! And as usual it was terrible. I would like to understand how it came to $46?
Evan B
I ordered from this place on Uber Eats. I tried to order half Hawaiian half plain but they made it half ham and the other half was pineapple. The pie was so soggy the bottom of the box was about to fall through. The pizza completely separated from the cheese and toppings and we couldn’t even eat it. It was a disaster. When I called to give them feedback the woman who answered put a man on the phone who immediately blamed the driver despite this obviously being a quality issue. First he said it was because the driver took too long to get here despite it being a 3 min drive, then he said they barely put any sauce on their pizza so it can’t be soggy, then finally he hung up on me. Terrible pizza and no accountability. Avoid this place when in Cairo!
Dottell Grossmann
Food is very inconsistent. And the workers are rude. Last time we attempted to order food we called at quarter to 8 and the guy yelled at me through the phone that they were closed and hung up on me. Needless to say they will no longer get my business.
Food is always delicious and great value. Weekly buffet specials are delicious. Nice people, too!
Main Street Community Center, Windham NY
A huge thank you to Two Brothers Pizza III for going above and beyond for our Build-A-Bear Pizza Party at the Main Street Community Center! The owners went out of their way to make our pizzas early in the morning – before they even opened – so the kids could enjoy a fresh, delicious lunch.
Everything was absolutely fantastic – the pizza was hot, flavorful, and a huge hit with both the kids and adults. We’re so grateful for your generosity and dedication to our community. If you’re looking for amazing pizza and incredible service, Two Brothers Pizza III is the place to go!
Brittany DiDomenico
One of the best places to get pizza in Greene county hands down!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Garlic Knots with Sauce, BBQ Bacon Chicken Ranch Pizza, All You Can Eat Italian Buffet Every Monday and Tuesday from 4to8pm 11 95, Any Wrap with French Fries, Chicken Bacon Ranch, Mozzarella Sticks 6, Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce
Nick Walker
They didn't have any plain or pepperoni slices when we arrived, which was a bit odd, but they they did offer to make a plain pie, which we certainly appreciated.
Every table was grease smeared, so we found the least dirty one to wait. It is a pizza place. It happens I suppose.
The slices were just ok... doughy and undercooked for my personal taste, Iots of cheese with not much sauce. I know every place does their pizza different, and I am sure some people like this style, but it is not for me.
Be aware that they keep a large German Shepherd dog in the restaurant where they store their assembled pizza boxes, which I noticed when it started barking and jumping. When the pizza was ready I asked the guy who worked the register for a box that wasn't from that room (I am allergic to dogs). He provided a box from behind the counter and I asked why the dog was with the pizza boxes. He said "I don't know. I just work here." I'm not a health inspector but I would imagine this practice is a pretty major violation. And even giving the benefit of the doubt that it is a service dog, I can't imagine this would excuse it being kept in the same room as the pizza boxes were stored.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Melissa Leonardo
Went for the Tuesday buffet. Great food for a great price! Definitely recommend everything from here.
The food is mostly edible if that’s your thing. I’ve tried a variety of things off the menu from pizza, to burgers, to wings and apps, and pastas. Not once have I ate anything that I’ve been like, yeah I’d eat that again. Also just don’t ever order the bacon bleu burger unless you like it covered in creamy salad dressing… it honestly might have even been ranch. I’d say save your money, there’s better pizza joints in the area… but that’s not even really true unless you go down to Catskill.
I have been to this place 3 times at approximately the same time over the last week. I got the same thing all 3 times. 2 slices of pepperoni and a 20 oz bottle of iced tea. I have been charged 3 different prices. 1st time, $9.70. 2nd time, $10.26. 3rd time $11.35.
The 1st time it was a younger guy and the other 2 times it was a tall older bald man.
Honesty apparently isn't on the menu here.
Edit; Owner response...Market price, Blame Biden.
So, $1.65 increase in prices in a 5 day period?
Just skip this place and go to the competition down the street!
I ordered from this awful place tonight. When i walked in the lady behind the counter didnt say a word to me. I ordered fried dough ($4.50) sausage and peppers sub($8.00) eggplant parm sub ($10.95) and two slices of meat lovers ($7.00). This should have came to $32.89 but instead came to $39.50. While ringing up my order i noticed the lady ring up $11.95 twice,$5.50 and $7.00. I didnt think these prices were right but didnt say anything. When i got home i look at their google page (says it was updated last week) and sure enough the prices displayed are what i thought they were. So i call and ask how much each thing cost and was told all subs are $11.95, thats not what any menu says. She also admitted the fried dough is $4.50 but she charged me $5.50. I told her those arent the prices displayed on their google menu and she said she will “tell brian” Seems like she over charged me because you have to pay with cash and they dont give you a receipt. Based on the looks of this women its no surprise shes stealing from people. On top of all of that, the food was terrible. Its only a matter of time until they get run out of time. Mateos is 1000x better. Dont waste your money here
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The pizza is average Fiona seems nice enough once or twice a week they have a buffet I'll give the buffet four stars
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Fantastic pizza and a great place to eat.
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love the food here it’s amazing amazing service and the food was amazing I got some chicken and it was cooked perfectly I also got some calamari witch from here was amazing it was really good and I recommend this to everybody who is around the area
Lwk pretty chill the food is really good never disappointed me
I forgot to tell my father not to go there anymore so he went tonight. He got a large plain and a large pepperoni pizza. They charged him $46!!! And as usual it was terrible. I would like to understand how it came to $46?
I ordered from this place on Uber Eats. I tried to order half Hawaiian half plain but they made it half ham and the other half was pineapple. The pie was so soggy the bottom of the box was about to fall through. The pizza completely separated from the cheese and toppings and we couldn’t even eat it. It was a disaster. When I called to give them feedback the woman who answered put a man on the phone who immediately blamed the driver despite this obviously being a quality issue. First he said it was because the driver took too long to get here despite it being a 3 min drive, then he said they barely put any sauce on their pizza so it can’t be soggy, then finally he hung up on me. Terrible pizza and no accountability. Avoid this place when in Cairo!
Food is very inconsistent. And the workers are rude. Last time we attempted to order food we called at quarter to 8 and the guy yelled at me through the phone that they were closed and hung up on me. Needless to say they will no longer get my business.
Restaurantji Recommends
Food is always delicious and great value. Weekly buffet specials are delicious. Nice people, too!
A huge thank you to Two Brothers Pizza III for going above and beyond for our Build-A-Bear Pizza Party at the Main Street Community Center! The owners went out of their way to make our pizzas early in the morning – before they even opened – so the kids could enjoy a fresh, delicious lunch. Everything was absolutely fantastic – the pizza was hot, flavorful, and a huge hit with both the kids and adults. We’re so grateful for your generosity and dedication to our community. If you’re looking for amazing pizza and incredible service, Two Brothers Pizza III is the place to go!
One of the best places to get pizza in Greene county hands down!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Garlic Knots with Sauce, BBQ Bacon Chicken Ranch Pizza, All You Can Eat Italian Buffet Every Monday and Tuesday from 4to8pm 11 95, Any Wrap with French Fries, Chicken Bacon Ranch, Mozzarella Sticks 6, Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce
They didn't have any plain or pepperoni slices when we arrived, which was a bit odd, but they they did offer to make a plain pie, which we certainly appreciated.
Every table was grease smeared, so we found the least dirty one to wait. It is a pizza place. It happens I suppose.
The slices were just ok... doughy and undercooked for my personal taste, Iots of cheese with not much sauce. I know every place does their pizza different, and I am sure some people like this style, but it is not for me.
Be aware that they keep a large German Shepherd dog in the restaurant where they store their assembled pizza boxes, which I noticed when it started barking and jumping. When the pizza was ready I asked the guy who worked the register for a box that wasn't from that room (I am allergic to dogs). He provided a box from behind the counter and I asked why the dog was with the pizza boxes. He said "I don't know. I just work here." I'm not a health inspector but I would imagine this practice is a pretty major violation. And even giving the benefit of the doubt that it is a service dog, I can't imagine this would excuse it being kept in the same room as the pizza boxes were stored.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Went for the Tuesday buffet. Great food for a great price! Definitely recommend everything from here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...