My Big Fat Cookie Calverton

Legit the best cookies/ sweets I’ve ever had! I’ve only tried a handful of flavors so far! I can’t wait to try the loafs as well. Everything is so good and you can truly taste the quality difference! Do not stop doing what yall are doing 10/10 recommend!!! 🍪 ❤️

The cookies are amazing!!!!! They are the best cookies we have ever bought. I wish I could buy stock in this business.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The cookies are out of this world!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We stumbled upon My Big Fat Cookie Company last year at the Welcome Center on the LIE. From that very first bite, we knew these weren’t your average cookies, they’re big, bold, and absolutely delicious! Everyone in our family has their go-to flavor: I’m all about the rainbow cookie (so nostalgic and perfectly made), my husband is hooked on the gooey, over-the-top s’mores, and my kids can’t get enough of the fun sprinkle cookie. Honestly, you can’t go wrong no matter which one you pick. The packaging makes them feel extra special! Colorful, fun, and perfect for gifting (though we usually end up keeping them for ourselves!). Beyond the cookies, it’s been really fun to watch the brand grow, and every interaction we’ve had with the owner has been so kind and genuine. You can tell how much heart goes into this business, and that makes supporting it even sweeter. If you’re looking for a cookie that feels like a little celebration in every bite, I can’t recommend My Big Fat Cookie Company enough. They’ve officially become part of our family’s favorite treats, and we’re always excited to see what new flavors pop up next!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

These cookies are an EXPERIENCE! You can tell they care about the quality of ingredients. The flavors are out of this world.
We warm them up and serve them with a scoop of ice cream :D
Be sure to try the THICK MINT when they are in stock!!
So dang good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

These are the absolute best cookies, brownies and rice treats that I have ever ordered and got shipped in the mail. This company is my go to whenever I want cookies.

Food: 5

Service: 5

I just ordered 7 cookies and they came within 2 business days. Cookies are huge and very delicious

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I tried the peanut butter cream cookie and it is INCREDIBLE!!!!! 🤤🤤🤤

Food: 5

One of the worst cookie experiences I’ve ever had.

I first bought these cookies at an airport store, thinking they’d be a decent travel snack. Big mistake. The package I opened was completely stale… dry, crumbly, and tasted like it had been sitting around for months. I figured maybe it was just bad luck, so I gave them another chance when I saw them again at a retail store later on. Unfortunately, that was even worse.. the cookies were mushy, underbaked, and had an unpleasant raw dough texture that was honestly inedible.

To make things even more frustrating, it’s clear these cookies are trying to copy another brand’s original version (which I later tracked down to compare). The difference was night and day. The original cookies which is a really cool company based in Chicago were fresh, balanced in texture, and actually enjoyable everything these knockoffs failed at.

Between the stale batch, the undercooked mess, and the obvious imitation of a superior product, I wouldn’t recommend these to anyone. Save your money and go for the real thing.

Food: 1

Sensational Cookies. I Love them 🍪 😍

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

my kid and husband loved the. cookies 🍪 gave them a 10/10

Best cookies EVER! 🙌 I have these shipped all the way to SW Florida by the box full! 🤣 The stuffed cookie butter is our favorite, but I haven’t tried one I do not like! Can’t wait to try new flavors as they are released! 😋

If you aren’t warming them up with a damp paper towel you’re missing out!! The softest, gooiest, most delicious cookies ever!! Absolutely love smores and the brownie remix! First time ordering online , I usually purchase them from the rest area on 87 North

So i got my big fat cookie from a local coffee shop and to say i was disappointed is an understatement. First, the advertising is deceiving. On the package it highlights the 5g of protein in the cookie, which made me think it was an actual protein cookie type of thing, but after looking at the package, it has around 68 grams of carbs and sugar. That is NOT a protein healthy cookie and the measly 5g of protein should not be a key highlight or selling point. Second, i was so grossed out by the consistency and texture of the cookie. It’s dry. Tastes like too much flour and to top it off, completely hollow inside. I bought 3 different flavors and each one was completely hollow in the middle. I threw all of them out because the taste was just too fake for me. Definitely do not recommend these especially to anyone thinking they’re getting a “premium ingredient” cookie. Waste of money in my opinion.

Omg!!! I love these cookies. Soo soft and big. Ridiculous. I hope they make more locations across the US...

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Rainbow, S'Mores, Chocolate Chip Cookie