Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings
137 Old Country Rd, Carle Place
(516) 877-7750
Customers' Favorites
Traditional Brick Oven Pizza
Underside of Burned Pizza
Meatball & Ricotta Pizza
Small Salad with Chickem
Slice of Cheese Pizza
Eggplant Marino
Original Wings
Pepperoni Pizza
12 Inch Pizza
Roasted Wings
Summer Specials
Mike's Hot Honey & Burrata Pizza
Italian Plum tomato sauce, red onions, fresh Burrata, and prosciutto topped with fresh basil, then drizzled with Mike's Hot Honey and balsamic glaze
Burrata & Prosciutto Spaghetti
Fresh burrata and crispy prosciutto with spaghetti in our Italian plum tomato sauce, topped with a basil flower
Burrata & Prosciutto Sandwich
Fresh Burrata, prosciutto, roasted red peppers, arugula, balsamic glaze, and our homemade Italian dressing
Strawberry Cake
Summer is here! Each buttery-moist layer is topped with cream cheese icing and finished with fresh strawberry glaze
Italian Shrimp Festival
Shrimp Scampi
Jumbo shrimp sautéed in garlic butter served with focaccia bread
Shrimp Scampi Spaghetti
Jumbo shrimp and garlic butter sauce served over spaghetti and garnished with fresh parsley
Shrimp Scampi Pizza
Jumbo shrimp, garlic butter sauce, red onions, mozzarella, and a sprinkle of Romano atop a crispy, charred crust
Shrimp Alfredo Pizza
Jumbo shrimp, creamy Alfredo sauce, caramelized onions, mozzarella, and a sprinkle of parsley atop a crispy, charred crust
Buffalo Shrimp Pizza
Jumbo shrimp tossed in buffalo sauce, red onions, and mozzarella atop a crispy, charred crust
Family Bundles
16" One Topping Pizza & 10 Wing Bundle
(1) Large 16" Pizza with 1-topping and choice of 10 Chicken Wings. Additional pizza toppings available for additional cost.
16" One Topping Pizza & Large Salad Bundle
(1) Large 16" Pizza with 1-topping and a choice of Large Anthony's Classic Italian Salad or Large Caesar Salad. Additional pizza toppings available for additional cost.
Family Value Bundle
(1) Large 16" Cheese Pizza, choice of a Large Anthony's Classic Italian Salad or Large Caesar Salad, and 6 Garlic Knots. Additional pizza toppings available for additional cost.
Football Feast
(1) Large 16" Cheese Pizza, 10 Chicken Wings, and 6 Garlic Knots. Additional pizza toppings available for additional cost.
Lunch Specials "Pranzo Pairings"
10" Create Your Own
Mozzarella, hand crushed Italian plum tomato sauce, and hand grated Romano cheese
Lunch Sandwich & Soup
*Due to quality control issues with Arugula, you may be receiving shredded Romaine lettuce instead of Arugula on the Tuna Sandwich or Coal Oven Chicken sandwich. We apologize for the inconvenience.*
10" Meatball & Ricotta
Our Traditional Pizza topped with baby meatballs and ricotta cheese
Lunch Salad & Soup
10" Carnivori
Square pizza with thick cut pepperoni, Italian sausage, baby meatballs and smoky bacon
10" Mike's Hot Honey
Our thick cut pepperoni served over fresh mozzarella & our own tomato sauce drizzled with Mike's Hot Honey for the perfect blend of sweet and spicy
Lunch Salad & Sandwich
*Due to quality control issues with Arugula, you may be receiving shredded Romaine lettuce instead of Arugula on the Tuna Sandwich or Coal Oven Chicken sandwich. We apologize for the inconvenience.*
10" Caprese
Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes and fresh basil
10" Roasted Cauliflower
Square pizza topped with cauliflower roasted with olive oil, crushed red pepper and garlic, Romano, mozzarella cheese and breadcrumbs
10" Broccoli Rabe & Sausage
Bitter Italian greens, sautéed in garlic and olive oil, served with our crumbled Italian sausage
10" Paulie's Pie
Baby meatballs, our Italian sausage, hot peppers (or substitute sweet peppers) and ricotta cheese
Pasta Fagioli
10" White
Ricotta, mozzarella and hand grated Romano
10" Burrata
Italian Plum tomato sauce, red onions, fresh Burrata, and proscuitto topped with fresh basil, then drizzled with Mike's Hot Honey and balsamic glaze
Shrimp Scampi 10"
Jumbo shrimp, garlic butter sauce, red onions, mozzarella, and a sprinkle of Romano atop a crispy, charred crust
Shrimp Alfredo 10"
Jumbo shrimp, creamy Alfredo sauce, caramelized onions, mozzarella, and a sprinkle of parsley atop a crispy, charred crust
Buffalo Shrimp 10"
Jumbo shrimp tossed in buffalo sauce, red onions, and mozzarella atop a crispy, charred crust
10" Square Margherita
Fresh mozzarella and our Italian plum tomato sauce, topped with hand grated Romano and fresh basil
10" Eggplant Marino
Thinly sliced eggplant, layered with our Italian plum tomato sauce then topped with hand grated Romano
Starters & Salads
Chopped Salad
Chopped Romaine, red onions, kalamata olives, roasted red peppers, pepperoni, with crumbled gorgonzola, bacon & garbanzo beans tossed in our homemade Italian dressing, drizzled with balsamic glaze.
Caesar Salad
Romaine tossed in our homemade Caesar dressing with made-from-scratch focaccia croutons, sprinkled with Romano cheese
Garlic Knots
Garlic Knots made with fresh baked dough, garlic, olive oil, parsley, Romano Cheese.
Anthony's Classic Italian Salad
Romaine, celery, red onions, garbanzo beans, Kalamata olives, tomato and hard cooked egg tossed in our homemade Italian dressing.
Eggplant Marino
Thinly sliced with our Italian plum tomato sauce and hand grated Romano
Caprese Salad
Our fresh mozzarella & tomatoes layered with olive oil and drizzle of balsamic glaze.
Pasta Fagioli
Shrimp Scampi
Jumbo shrimp sautéed in garlic butter served with focaccia bread
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
Creamy blend of baby spinach, mozzarella, and marinated artichokes served with our Romano Focaccia
Arugula Burrata Salad
Fresh arugula, oven-roasted red peppers, and red onions tossed in our homemade Italian dressing topped with fresh burrata and shaved Romano
Broccoli Rabe & Sausage
Bitter Italian greens, sautéed in garlic and olive oil, served with our crumbled Italian sausage
Stromboli with Pepperoni & Nonna's Italian Sausage
Our signature pizza dough folded with a savory fusion of pepperoni and Italian sausage, mozzarella, and Romano
Wings
5 Wings
Coal Oven Roasted Chicken Wings. Choose your flavor.
10 Wings
Coal Oven Roasted Chicken Wings. Choose your flavor.
20 Wings
Coal Oven Roasted Chicken Wings. Choose your flavor.
Pasta & Meatballs
Meatballs
Large beef meatballs slowly cooked in our Italian plum tomato sauce.
Burrata & Prosciutto Spaghetti
Fresh burrata and crispy prosciutto with spaghetti in our Italian plum tomato sauce, topped with a basil flower
Fettuccine Alfredo
A classic Italian pasta dish featuring fettuccine pasta tossed in a sauce made from butter, heavy cream, and grated Parmesan cheese. Served with our home-made focaccia bread.
Spaghetti & Meatballs
A beloved Italian-American comfort dish that brings together the heartiness of al dente pasta, homemade meatballs, and our own tomato sauce, sprinkled with Romano cheese. Served with our home-made focaccia bread.
Shrimp Scampi Spaghetti
Jumbo shrimp and garlic butter sauce served over spaghetti and garnished with fresh parsley
16" Pizzas
Create Your Own 16" Pizza
Grande mozzarella, hand crushed Italian plum tomato sauce, hand grated Romano cheese, basil and olive oil.
Meatball Ricotta 16"
Our Traditional Pizza topped with baby meatballs and ricotta cheese
The Square Margherita 16"
Fresh mozzarella and our Italian plum tomato sauce, topped with hand grated Romano and fresh basil flower
Mike's Hot Honey 16"
Our thick cut pepperoni served over fresh mozzarella & our own tomato sauce drizzled with Mike's Hot Honey for the perfect blend of sweet and spicy
Roasted Cauliflower 16"
Square pizza topped with cauliflower roasted with olive oil and garlic, Romano, mozzarella cheese, and breadcrumbs
White 16"
Ricotta, mozzarella and hand grated Romano
Paulie's Pie 16"
Baby meatballs, our Italian sausage, long hot finger peppers and ricotta cheese
Carnivori 16"
Square pizza with thick cut pepperoni, Italian sausage, baby meatballs and smoky bacon
Eggplant Marino 16"
Thinly sliced eggplant, layered with our Italian plum tomato sauce then topped with hand grated Romano
Caprese 16"
Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes and fresh basil
Broccoli Rabe & Sausage 16"
Bitter Italian greens, sautéed in garlic and olive oil, served with our crumbled Italian sausage
Burrata 16"
Italian Plum tomato sauce, red onions, fresh Burrata, and proscuitto topped with fresh basil, then drizzled with Mike's Hot Honey and balsamic glaze
Shrimp Scampi 16"
Jumbo shrimp, garlic butter sauce, red onions, mozzarella, and a sprinkle of Romano atop a crispy, charred crust
Shrimp Alfredo 16"
Jumbo shrimp, creamy Alfredo sauce, caramelized onions, mozzarella, and a sprinkle of parsley atop a crispy, charred crust
Buffalo Shrimp 16"
Jumbo shrimp tossed in buffalo sauce, red onions, and mozzarella atop a crispy, charred crust
12" Pizzas
Meatball Ricotta 12"
Our Traditional Pizza topped with baby meatballs and ricotta cheese
White 12"
Ricotta, mozzarella and hand grated Romano
Carnivori 12"
Square pizza with thick cut pepperoni, Italian sausage, baby meatballs and smoky bacon
The Square Margherita 12"
Fresh mozzarella and our Italian plum tomato sauce, topped with hand grated Romano and fresh basil flower
Mike's Hot Honey 12"
Our thick cut pepperoni served over fresh mozzarella & our own tomato sauce drizzled with Mike's Hot Honey for the perfect blend of sweet and spicy
Roasted Cauliflower 12"
Square pizza topped with cauliflower roasted with olive oil and garlic, Romano, mozzarella cheese, and breadcrumbs
Caprese 12"
Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes and fresh basil
Paulie's Pie 12"
Baby meatballs, our Italian sausage, long hot finger peppers and ricotta cheese
Broccoli Rabe & Sausage 12"
Bitter Italian greens, sautéed in garlic and olive oil, served with our crumbled Italian sausage
Eggplant Marino 12"
Thinly sliced eggplant, layered with our Italian plum tomato sauce then topped with hand grated Romano
Create Your Own 12" Pizza
Grande mozzarella, hand crushed Italian plum tomato sauce, hand grated Romano cheese, basil and olive oil
Burrata 12"
Italian Plum tomato sauce, red onions, fresh Burrata, and prosciutto topped with fresh basil, then drizzled with Mike's Hot Honey and balsamic glaze
Shrimp Scampi 12"
Jumbo shrimp, garlic butter sauce, red onions, mozzarella, and a sprinkle of Romano atop a crispy, charred crust
Shrimp Alfredo 12"
Jumbo shrimp, creamy Alfredo sauce, caramelized onions, mozzarella, and a sprinkle of parsley atop a crispy, charred crust
Buffalo Shrimp 12"
Jumbo shrimp tossed in buffalo sauce, red onions, and mozzarella atop a crispy, charred crust
Stromboli with Pepperoni & Nonna's Italian Sausage
Our signature pizza dough folded with a savory fusion of pepperoni and Italian sausage, mozzarella, and Romano
Half & Half Specialty 12"
12" Gluten Free Pizzas
Meatball Ricotta 12" Gluten-Free
Our Traditional Pizza topped with baby meatballs and ricotta cheese
Carnivori 12" Gluten-Free
Square pizza with thick cut pepperoni, Italian sausage, baby meatballs and smoky bacon
White 12" Gluten-Free
Ricotta, mozzarella and hand grated Romano
Roasted Cauliflower 12" Gluten-Free
Square pizza topped with cauliflower roasted with olive oil and garlic, Romano, mozzarella cheese, and breadcrumbs
Eggplant Marino 12" Gluten-Free
Thinly sliced eggplant, layered with our Italian plum tomato sauce then topped with hand grated Romano
Paulie's Pie 12" Gluten-Free
Baby meatballs, our Italian sausage, long hot finger peppers and ricotta cheese
Broccoli Rabe & Sausage 12" Gluten-Free
Bitter Italian greens, sautéed in garlic and olive oil, served with our crumbled Italian sausage
Caprese 12" Gluten-Free
Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes and fresh basil
Create Your Own 12" Gluten-Free Pizza
Grande mozzarella, hand crushed Italian plum tomato sauce, hand grated Romano cheese, basil and olive oil
Burrata 12" Gluten-Free
Italian Plum tomato sauce, red onions, fresh Burrata, and prosciutto topped with fresh basil, then drizzled with Mike's Hot Honey and balsamic glaze
Shrimp Scampi 12" Gluten Free
Jumbo shrimp, garlic butter sauce, red onions, mozzarella, and a sprinkle of Romano atop a crispy, charred crust
Shrimp Alfredo 12" Gluten Free
Jumbo shrimp, creamy Alfredo sauce, caramelized onions, mozzarella, and a sprinkle of parsley atop a crispy, charred crust
Buffalo Shrimp 12" Gluten Free
Jumbo shrimp tossed in buffalo sauce, red onions, and mozzarella atop a crispy, charred crust
Mike's Hot Honey 12" Gluten-Free
Our thick cut pepperoni served over fresh mozzarella & our own tomato sauce drizzled with Mike's Hot Honey for the perfect blend of sweet and spicy
The Square Margherita 12" Gluten-Free
Fresh mozzarella and our Italian plum tomato sauce, topped with hand grated Romano and fresh basil flower
Desserts
Mini Cannolis
Tiramisu
Dessert Platter
Savor our Dessert Platter: Chocolate Cake, Tiramisu, NY Cheesecake, and (4) Mini Cannolis. Desserts drizzled with chocolate syrup and whipped cream-option to substitute Pumpkin Cheesecake.
Chocolate Cake
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Chocolate Chip Brownie
Strawberry Cake
Summer is here! Each buttery-moist layer is topped with cream cheese icing and finished with fresh strawberry glaze
NY Cheesecake
Sandwiches
Long Hot Meatball Mozzarella Sandwich
Meatballs, mozzarella cheese and long hot finger peppers
Coal Oven Roasted Chicken Sandwich
Chicken breast topped with prosciutto, roasted red peppers, melted mozzarella, arugula and our homemade Italian dressing*Due to quality control issues with Arugula, you may be receiving shredded Romaine lettuce instead of Arugula. We apologize for the inconvenience.*
Italian Sausage & Peppers Sandwich
Anthony's grandmother's Italian sausage recipe with mozzarella, caramelized onions, roasted sweet peppers served on our homemade focaccia bread, served with a side of our tomato sauce
Chicken Broccoli Rabe Sandwich
Chicken breast topped with broccoli rabe and melted mozzarella.
Italian Tuna Salad Sandwich
Lemon, olive oil, tomato and arugula with our homemade Italian dressing*Due to quality control issues with Arugula, you may be receiving shredded Romaine lettuce instead of Arugula. We apologize for the inconvenience.*
Burrata Sandwich
Fresh Burrata, proscuitto, roasted red peppers, arugula, balsamic glaze, and our homemade Italian dressing
Beverages
Coke Can
Diet Coke Can
Sprite Can
Acqua Panna
Pellegrino
Party Platters
(20) Meatballs
Large beef meatballs slowly cooked in our Italian plum tomato sauce
Banquet Caesar Salad
Romaine tossed in our homemade Caesar dressing with made-from-scratch focaccia croutons, sprinkled with Romano cheese
Small Pan Eggplant Marino
Thinly sliced with our Italian plum tomato sauce and hand grated Romano. Serves 10-15.
(50) Roasted Chicken Wings
Coal oven roasted jumbo chicken wings. Choose a flavor.
Banquet Anthony's Classic Salad
Romaine, celery, red onions, garbanzo beans, Kalamata olives, tomato and hard cooked egg tossed in our homemade Italian dressing. Serves 10-15 people
Banquet Chopped Salad
Small Broccoli Rabe & Sausage
Bitter Italian greens, sautéed in garlic and olive oil, served with our crumbled Italian sausage
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
Creamy blend of baby spinach, mozzarella, and marinated artichokes served with our Romano Focaccia
Photos
+72 photos
+71 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Anthony's coal fired pizza, the name seemed nice and we thought the place would be rustic. But no, this was more like a rundown sports bar. A bunch of hillbillies were permanently stationed at the bar and sometimes were loud enough to distract us. The place did not feel that clean, especially the floors. On top of that, they forgot about our order. After waiting for a while we asked for it again, then they rushed to make the pie and guess what, it had raw tomato sauce all...
February 2025
Very delicious pizza. Mine wasn’t burned. Came out perfect. Cozy place. Paulie pie was great. Great atmosphere. Don’t see many places like this anymore. It’s casual. They had the football game on. Sound was good not too loud. Recommended.
January 2025
A winning spot for pizza lovers! We first tried Anthony's during their Super Bowl promotion and were hooked! Subsequent visits, including a dinner date and team lunch, only reaffirmed our delight. The atmosphere is decent, service is good, but the real star is the food - their pizzas and garlic knots are absolutely delicious! Consistency is key, and Anthony's delivers. A great spot for casual gatherings or dates. 4/5 stars!
August 2024
You May Also Like
Chipotle Mexican Grill - 135 Old Country Rd
![]()
Mexican, Fast Food
Carle Place Diner - 151 Old Country Rd
![]()
Diner, Bar, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian