Bagel Boss Carle Place

Bagel is overpriced 5.60$ plus 3% charge for just a plain bagel like I understand time is tough but I promise you I can get a bacon egg and cheese for that price and that with egg being a top commodity

I stumbled upon this bagel spot while trying to find a new go-to in the area—still getting my bearings since I just started working nearby. A quick Google search led me here, and I’m glad I checked it out!

The inside was clean and had a decent amount of space, which is always a plus. The staff was super friendly and immediately greeted me. They were also patient and understanding since it was my first time visiting. They let me know it’s a kosher restaurant, which means no meat on the menu—definitely a bit of a letdown since I had my heart set on a bacon, egg, and cheese.

I decided to switch gears and ordered an egg bagel with cheese and black pepper. I’ll admit, it was a good bagel—fresh, flavorful, and nicely toasted. But I couldn’t help but miss that extra savory punch from some meat.

Would I come back? Maybe, but only if I was craving a simple butter bagel or another egg and cheese fix. It’s a solid spot for what it is, but meat lovers might feel like something’s missing. Still, worth checking out if you’re in the area!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Gonna give a real simple review here.

I ordered a corn muffin, potato peroegi and a piece of fried eggplant.

The corn muffin was fried and hard. (Couldn't finish it)

Eggplant tastes like soap and has a strong freezer taste. ( One bite and tossed it)

Peroegi was average.

Food was a little pricey especially for the quality.

Overall 4.5/10

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

I saw what seemd to be a nasty roach!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

I grew up with great bagels from Pop's Bagels in the Peninsula Shopping Center in Hewlett so I'm spoiled. Bagel Boss of Carle Place is not a great bagel. Their everything bagel wasn't hot or even warm and it was soft with little texture no poppy seeds garlic or onion just an abundance of sesame seeds and salt. Cream cheese here is very tasty but bagel has no crisp just mushy and at these prices I won't be back. Even Starbucks and Paris Baguette have a better bagel....

Great fast service and Coffee was good but $10 for a bagel with cream cheese and coffee should blow your socks off. Not here....

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 4

Went in for a bacon, egg and cheese bagel. To my surprise, your establishment is kosher Only ask me how I know that ??? one of your employees got testy with me because I asked for bacon, nowhere on the outside. Does it say kosher, only so? Maybe you should train your staff to be a little more understanding when people walk in and don't know what your place really is. First and last time I'll be here

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

I was there on a Sunday — prime time. They only had 2 people working and a 20 minute line

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Bagel with Our Classic Tuna Salad

It’s very hot in there. Workers are sweating. The prices there are just outrageous. I paid almost $5 for a hard dry muffin. I got lox’s on a bagel with cream cheese and it was almost $20. That’s just absurd! I understand lox’s is expensive but it’s not like this at other places. I usually pay $13. The bottled drinks are even expensive too. Very disappointed with this bagel boss. Will definitely not be coming back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

OMG $4.59 for a regular hot coffee??? Are they insane never coming back here again

Fast friendly service and good food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Egg White Wrap

Great bagel but pricier than most… bagel with cream cheese was $7?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This place is terrible food sucks. Forgot to put ketchup on and they go and say that can’t put it on there bc it is opened. Forgot to give me my other bagel!!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

2 guys working the counter, total of 8 customers in the store, some of them already eating, and I couldn't get service. I waited 5+ minutes with no one ahead of me before being acknowledged at all, when the worker said he'll be right with me; then when he came back he went directly to a customer that came in after me without even making eye contact with me. So I left without getting to try the food. It smelled good and the bagels looked nice though.

Service: 1

Plain bagel with cream cheese is $5.18 and a medium coffee is $3.58. Down the block you can go to My Three Sons (which was voted best bagels on Long Island and has excellent coffee) and get a plain bagel with cream cheese for $3.75 and a medium coffee for $2.25

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Just as Amanda Review, First the original owner retired with the large store, this new store is down size.(2) At $2.25 a bagel, you can keep them ,cinnamon raisin no raisins or cinnamon (NoTaste at all, as for plain bagels there are terrible too! Try using real ingredients,Likebread flour,cinnamon,sugar, and if you are using them it’s time to find a new food distributor for ingredients.Because your bagels have no taste! I will give you credit for your bagels not being like (balloon bagels) “Work on it and your lines will be out the door! Or put the key ? in the door and call it day cause I’m done throwing food away! And getting ripoff ”Money comes to hard to make”All the best.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 2