Cafe Formaggio
307 Old Country Rd, Carle Place
(516) 333-1718
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Certainly a place worth stopping by, the food is awesome and well prepared, the cost is fair and it is constantly well organized there. Highly recommended.
Had a great experience here with my kids. The food comes quick and the service is just excellent. Prices are reasonable.
Absolutely a spot worth visiting, the food is great and well prepared, the cost is affordable and it is regularly well kept in here. Keep it up.
My first choice was the taglatelli ragu, but at 7:30 they were all out, as well as the gluten free bread. I ordered the capollini fra diavolo, which was delicious as was my calamari appetizer, but my wife's shrimp with risotto was very salty. Granted this was Valentine's day but you should not run out of items that early, especially when you are just offering a prefix menu. When we left at around 9:00, there was a large crowd, maybe 40 people, waiting to be seated, can't imagine what else they would be out of by the time these people got to order. Will give the place another chance on a regular dining night.
Great gluten free options. They also have gluten free bread that they bring.
I’m on a gluten free diet so my girlfriend looked for a restaurant that serves gluten free food. Well neither of us expected to find a restaurant that has an actual menu . I never expected to have gluten free bread or fried squid and it was really good. Then I had a veal dish which was delicious. We finished off the dinner with a brownie and ice cream. Never thought I could enjoy gluten free. And the service was great.
Amazing food. Has tons of gluten free options. Would definitely recommend.
NEVER AGAIN..... We were rushed out the door, and the place wasn't even busy. Food came almost immediately after ordering. Our dishes were disgusting. Absolutely no flavor, or seasoning. Some of the worst italian food I've ever encountered. The waitstaff leaves much to be desired as well.
Waiter seemed like he had better things to do the wait on us. Also, we were called to confirm reservation and told to make sure we were on time, which we were, and then we were seated 1/2 hour late. Food was good though.
This is definitely one of the most attractive place in the region. Every time I visit this place I am truly pleased. They preserve their very high standard service and the highest level of meals they serve. You are always happy with this restaurant. Warmly recommended.
Restaurantji Recommends
food is delicious, nice atmosphere, good service
Wonderful service. Terrific appetizers and soups. Relaxed atmosphere.
I love this place. Whenever I am visiting family on Long Island I make them take me here. The food is delicious and they can accommodate so many food allergies! Last night though, they lost my family’s patronage. A cockroach fell from the ceiling directly into our bread basket. This really happened and it was the grossest thing I’ve experienced in a restaurant in a long time. Yes, the waiter comped the most expensive entree and gave us a 15% discount from our meal, but a cockroach fell from the ceiling into our bread basket. We shouldn’t have had to pay a cent. We also did not get a real apology or the royal treatment after this happened. Our waiter seemed pretty nonchalant about it. I’m still cringing about this experience and am saddened that it was not handled well by the staff at this restaurant. We have spent so much money at this establishment over the years with many special occasion dinners and catering orders. It’s really a shame about how we were treated at dinner last night.
Gluten free heaven! Had the ravioli & fried calamari gluten free. Wish I lived in the area to come here as a regular
I had the most delicious and relaxed dinner last night w/friends. Anyone with celiac knows why I said relaxed, Beautiful, extensive gluten free menu from Appetizers to desserts, knowledgeable, friendly staff. My food came flagged gf. I highly recommend any w/celiac try it, I doubt you will be disappointed. They even have gf bread!
Loading...