Gyro Jimmy's

165 Voice Rd, Carle Place
(516) 279-6481

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Large Greek Salad with Chicken Souvlaki
Chicken Souvlaki - Skepasti
Beef and Lamb Gyro Sandwich
Chicken Souvlaki - Sandwich
Traditional Gyro Sandwich
Chicken Gyro Meat Only
Stuffed Grape Leaves
Traditional Gyro
Horiatiki Salad
Grilled Chicken

Menu

Appetizers
Avgolemeno
Our traditional chicken lemon rice soup.
Lentil Soup
Traditional Greek lentil soup.
Spanakopita - Spinach Pie
Savory spinach and feta rolled in a crispy Phyllo dough.
Tiropita Cheese Pie
Savory cheese rolled in a crispy Phyllo dough.
Saganaki Imported Kefalotiri Cheese
Imported Kefalotiri cheese - pan fried & sprinkled with imported oregano.
Halloumi Cypriot Goat Cheese
Grilled & sprinkled with imported oregano.
Feta
Drizzled with olive oil & imported oregano
Grape Leaves
Stuffed grape leaves with rice, herbs & extra virgin olive oil.
Falafel - Appetizer
Ground chickpea cooked with fresh herbs & spices. Served with 3oz tahini cup.
Greek Pizza
Mozzarella, tomato sauce, spinach and feta cheese on a crispy pita bread

Salads
Horiatiki Salad
Authentic Greek salad - traditional Greek villager's salad with Arahova feta, plum tomatoes, cucumber, onions, olives & extra virgin olive oil.
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, grated parmesan cheese & croutons, topped with Caesar dressing.
Prasini Chopped Salad
Chopped salad - chopped lettuce, dill, scallions & feta in a extra virgin olive oil dressing.
Lahano Cabbage Salad
Cabbage salad - white & red cabbage served with feta in a lemon extra virgin olive oil dressing.
Dakos Traditional Cretan Salad
Chopped tomatoes, onions, Arahova feta, capers. Topped with traditional Cretan dry bread (Rusks) & flavored with herbs & extra virgin olive oil.

Sandwiches
Chicken Gyro - Sandwich
Thinly sliced chicken gyro meat, cooked in fresh herbs & spices. Served in pita bread with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, french fries & tzatziki sauce inside the sandwich . You can modify your sandwich fillings to your preference below.
Pork Gyro - Sandwich
Layered pork gyro meat, cooked with fresh herbs & spices. Served in pita bread with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, french fries & tzatziki sauce inside the sandwich . You can modify your sandwich fillings to your preference below.
Grilled Chicken - Sandwich
Sliced chicken breast cooked with fresh herbs & spices. Served in pita bread with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, french fries & tzatziki sauce inside the sandwich . You can modify your sandwich fillings to your preference below.
Traditional (Beef & Lamb) Gyro - Sandwich
Thinly sliced beef and lamb (combination) gyro meat, cooked with fresh herbs & spices. Served in pita bread with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, french fries & tzatziki sauce inside the sandwich . You can modify your sandwich fillings to your preference below.
Falafel - Sandwich
Falafel - Sandwich Ground chickpea cooked with fresh herbs & spices. Served in pita bread with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, french fries & tahini sauce inside the sandwich . You can modify your sandwich fillings to your preference below.
Chicken Souvlaki - Sandwich
Cubed pieces of chicken on skewers cooked with fresh herbs & spices. Served in pita bread with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, french fries & tzatziki sauce inside the sandwich. You can modify your sandwich fillings to your preference below.
Pork Souvlaki - Sandwich
Cubed pieces of pork on skewers cooked with fresh herbs & spices. Served in pita bread with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, french fries & tzatziki sauce inside the sandwich. You can modify your sandwich fillings to your preference below.
Meatless Gyro - Sandwich
House made, all-natural & vegan, cooked in fresh herbs & spices Served in pita bread with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, french fries & tzatziki sauce inside the sandwich. You can modify your sandwich fillings to your preference below.

Plates
Chicken Gyro - Plate
Thinly sliced chicken gyro meat, cooked in fresh herbs & spices. Served with choice of 2 sides, pita bread and choice of sauce
Pork Gyro - Plate
Layered pork gyro meat, cooked with fresh herbs & spices. Served with choice of 2 sides, pita bread and choice of sauce.
Grilled Chicken - Plate
Sliced chicken breast cooked with fresh herbs & spices. Served with choice of 2 sides, pita bread and choice of sauce.
Traditional (Beef & Lamb) Gyro - Plate
Thinly sliced beef and lamb (combination) gyro meat, cooked with fresh herbs & spices. Served with choice of 2 sides, pita bread and choice of sauce.
Falafel - Plate
Ground chickpea cooked with fresh herbs & spices. Served with choice of 2 sides, pita bread and choice of sauce.
Meatless Gyro - Plate
House made, all-natural & vegan, cooked in fresh herbs & spices. Served with choice of 2 sides, pita bread and choice of sauce.
Chicken Souvlaki - Plate
Cubed pieces of chicken on skewers cooked with fresh herbs & spices. Served with choice of 2 sides, pita bread and choice of sauce.
Pork Souvlaki - Plate
Cubed pieces of pork on skewers cooked with fresh herbs & spices. Served with choice of 2 sides, pita bread and choice of sauce.

Oven Roasted Chicken

1/2 Chicken
Slowly oven roasted & flame grilled chicken, served with lemon potatoes, horiatiki side salad, pita bread & tzatziki.
Whole Chicken
Slowly oven roasted & flame grilled chicken, served with lemon potatoes, small horiatiki salad, pita bread & tzatziki.
2 Whole Chickens
Slowly oven roasted & flame grilled chicken, served with (2) lemon potatoes, large horiatiki salad, pita bread & tzatziki.

Specialty Dishes
PASTICCIO
LAYERS OF GROUND BEEF & ZITI PASTA, TOPPED WITH CREAMY BECHAMEL SAUCE. SERVED WITH CHOICE OF (1) SIDE.
MOUSAKA
LAYERS OF EGGPLANT, GROUND BEEF & POTATOES, TOPPED WITH BECHAMEL SAUCE. SERVED WITH CHOICE OF (1) SIDE.
Vegetarian Mousaka
Layers of eggplant, zucchini & potatoes, topped with bechamel sauce. Served with choice of (1) side.

Burgers
Cyprus Burger
Bifteki patty served in toasted pita bread with grilled halloumi cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and onions, and french fries on the side.
Greek Burger
Bifteki patty served in toasted pita bread with feta cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and onions, and french fries on the side.
Classic Bifteki Burger
Bifteki patty served with lettuce, tomatoes and onions inside toasted pita bread, and french fries on the side.
Classic Cheese Burger
Bifteki patty served in toasted pita bread with American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and onions, and french fries on the side.

Skepasti
Chicken Gyro - Skepasti
All natural, cooked in fresh herbs & spices.
Pork Gyro - Skepasti
All natural, layered meat, cooked with fresh herbs & spices.
Grilled Chicken - Skepasti
All natural, chicken breast cooked in fresh herbs & spices.
Traditional (Beef & Lamb) Gyro - Skepasti
All natural, cooked in fresh herbs & spices, thinly sliced.
Falafel - Skepasti
Ground chickpea with house blend spices.

Sides
Garlic Green Beans
Sauteed green beans in garlic & extra virgin olive oil.
Greek Fries
Freshly cut French fries, topped with feta cheese, salt & oregano.
Greek Rice Pilaf
Greek rice pilaf with onions, garlic, carrots, fresh lemon & herbs.
Greek Slaw
Cabbage mixed with fresh herbs & spices, extra virgin olive oil & vinaigrette.
Beet Salad Side
Roasted red beets, crumbled feta, & walnuts served with EVO.
Lemon Potatoes
Roasted potatoes in lemon, EVO & herbs.
French Fries
Freshly cut French fries seasoned with salt & oregano.
Horta
Dandelion greens with extra virgin olive oil & fresh lemon juice.
Tomato Cucumber
Plump tomatoes, cucumbers, oregano, extra virgin olive oil & vinaigrette.
Greek Gigantes
Giant baked butter beans in a tomato base with herbs & spices.

Fresh Dips
Tzatziki Spread
Cucumber, dill yogurt spread.
Melitzanosalata Spread
Eggplant garlic spread.
Hummus
Chickpeas, tahini, garlic, lemon juice, & EVOO.
Tirokafteri Spread
Spicy Greek feta cheese spread.
Taramasalata Spread
Fish roe spread.
Tasting Trio Spread
Pick any 3 spreads

Sauces
Tzatziki Sauce
Yogurt, cucumber, dill, garlic, salt, EVOO.
Tahini Sauce
Sesame paste, lime juice, vinaigrette, salt, EVOO.
Gyro Jimmy's Secret Sauce
It's a secret mayo based sauce.
Tirokafteri Sauce
Spicy Greek feta cheese
Garlic Cream Sauce
Whipped Yogurt, Cucumber, Dill, Garlic, Salt and EVOO.

Beverages
Coke
Diet Coke
Sprite
Gingerale
Seltzer
Red Bull
Greek Soda - Lemonade
Greek Soda - Orange
Greek Soda - Cherry
Water Bottle (Poland Spring)
Souroti (S) Sparkling Water
Souroti (L) Sparkling Water

Desserts
Baklava
Greek Rice Pudding
Galactobouriko
Greek Yogurt Natural Greek Yogurt

Coffee
Frappe
Regular Coffee
Decaf Coffee
Fredo Espresso

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: facebook
+29 photos
Photo credit: grubhub
+28 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Best gyro I’ve had in a long time - EXCELLENT! Customer service was amazing - I was very late to pick up my order and they made me a new sandwich which they didn’t have to do it.
January 2025
Gyro Jimmy's is a must for anyone looking for Greek food.
Gryo, Beets, Horiatiki, and lemon potatoes some of the best I've ever had EVER. Good ingredients, immaculate clean, served with a smile. This is how to run a place!
November 2024
This place is a gem. Friendly and fast service, clean inside, and the food is of a really high quality. The value was great and they have lots of choices. I just wish I found this place sooner. This place stands out on Long Island for sure.
September 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

The Monster Crab all you can eat seafood & Bar - 242 Voice Rd
Seafood, Cajun/Creole, Bar
FYHRE Hibachi Sushi Lounge - 246 Voice Rd
Sushi, Japanese, Asian Fusion, Sushi Bar, Vegan
Jersey Mike's Subs - 202 Glen Cove Rd
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food

Gyro Jimmy's

165 Voice Rd, Carle Place, NY 11514
(516) 279-6481