Carmel Creamery

105 Towners Rd, Carmel Hamlet
(845) 225-0890

Recent Reviews

Sort by
CARLO BRUNO

Too expensive. Staff was not very friendly i always try to patronize small local businesses but once was enough.mediocre

Rosey Day

Lots of flavors. Blueberry pistachio in a cone- flavor and ice cream texture was exactly how it should be. Cone was crispy.

Grabbed some pre made ice cream sandwiches. Crispy fresh cookies were too sweet for me. Vanilla had a clean vanilla taste. Chocolate was deep. Strawberry could've use more of that sweet tart Strawberry flavor. Mint was heck a minty- not a complaint...lol...

Tight indoor space. No indoor seating. Decent parking. Nice large grassy outdoor area.

La suerada

Ice cream delicious 1A

Miranda Canedo

We went for the first time last night and it will NOT be our last! Walked in just happy knowing they had DF/GF flavors but it didn't stop at that, they had GF Brownies, GF Cones and GF Cookies to make a cookie sandwich with (which I happily chose) and to top it all off, Dye-Free Sprinkles! I think the price was around ~$7 which I was SHOCKED at how affordable it was when everyone nowadays is insanely jacking up the price of ice cream in general, let alone vegan and GF options and it was huge! See you again soon!

Renee Richardson

Consistently great tasting ice cream!!
I' m not one to crave ice cream , but the ever changing variety leaves you screaming for more. So far i have tried a few great ones and some interesting, for example Ube, Cannoli Waffle and Jamaican Hibiscus.
Cant wait to try something new next time .
P.s. love that they use natural sources instead of dyes !

Melinda Cardoso

The ice cream was delicious. I got the Chocolate ice cream and I can say it is amazing after a hot summer day. The workers were very kind and sweet even with the rush.

Karl Sieburg

Great dairy free options

Anastasia Kuroda

Aloah, my Oahu people. If you're in New York, come by Carmal Creamery. The girls there were so friendly and kind. The girls asked if we wanted to sample some of the ice cream. All the ice cream is homemade locally made. Every week, they have new flavors.

Aloha and Mahalo (Thank you) to the staff at Carmel Creamery. Located in Carmel New York.

Liam Hegarty

A wide and varying selection of ice creams. Plenty of parking.

Jean Logan

Im sorry I didn’t think you could screw up ice cream but this place sure can. I got the black raspberry brownie. I was expecting a rich creamy taste, what I got was a very weird bland taste and I could hardly taste the brownie. It was the worst ice cream I have ever tasted. It was only a counter you can’t even sit in the place. It was raining so I just ate it in the car. A word to the wise, try the flavors before buying it, because it might really be that bad.

Amy Estersohn

Amazing flavors with a lot of variety. Delicious homemade cones. Loved the ice cream and food and coffee!

Unoriginal Planner

Been randomly coming here for the third summer because we live nearby but with each visit I get more and more disappointed. The environment is far from friendly, the ice cream is ok, nothing extraordinary, but the prices keep going up. Would love to support local but hope this place improves.

CC Treadway

Amazing, high quality and unique ice cream for a great price! The maple bourbon pecan was really special.

Jo-ann Connelly

The staff are very nice. The base of the vegan ice cream is tapioca syrup which does not have the texture or flavor of most ice creams. Based on reviews, alot of people seem to like it. Ice cream should be creamy not overly sweet. I don't like the base.

R. Dietrich

Cool flavors!!!

Loading...