Stefano's Pizzeria & Restaurant
258 State St, Carthage
(315) 493-0400
Recent Reviews
Sort by
258 State St, Carthage
(315) 493-0400
Always delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of our favorite go to places when we are in the North Country. Love their pizza and pasta dishes. Great atmosphere with a small town feel. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Found this place by accident on one of my road trips. My family and I greatly enjoyed the place. You've got to try the cinnamon garlic knots and the waitress was amazing full dining room and she didn't even break a sweat very professional
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This Stefano's is definitely better than the one in Great Bend. The food, the atmosphere, and the staff.
Great food. Only have a star because of prices. It's quite expensive for pizza.
Our favorite authentic Italian restaurant in Carthage NY.
We've never had a bad meal here ever, we def recommend the pepperoni knots!
Too expensive, food at the gas station taste better
I older a pizza from there and they give me a new one from there and the pizza was hard
Pizza is pretty good for the area. Just make sure which one you're ordering from so you don't drive to the wrong one.
Tony and his crew are great. Food was excellent. Never a bad meal.
Restaurantji Recommends
Always a value and amazing food and service! First restaurant that makes eggplant Parm as good as you can at home and that's the highest compliment there is! More food with a typical dinner order than you can possibly eat. Have never had a bad meal there in 30 years of frequenting this establishment!
So much more than pizza.
Service and food were both excellent. They were able to accommodate our party of nine people. Excellent! Highly recommend.
I took my parents, brother, and his wife who are from Alabama to Stefanos Carthage location, as they hadn’t been there before. The spaghetti was wonderful, as were the riggies, and the sausage/peppers/mushrooms pizza was spot on. I personally have been to Stefanos many many times, and their performance on this occasion was no different from my past experiences. No let downs. The owner flat out knows what he is doing running his restaurants, and their product is just killer. Consistent, hot, fresh, and delicious. I’d recommend it to anyone. You can’t lose here!
Recommended dishes: Dinner
Great pizza!! Friendly service…. Our go to for Friday night pizza!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Loading...