I got a pepperoni pizza and a meat lovers Pizza on January 15, 2022 and it was the worst Pizza I've ever had. This new ownership does not know how to cook a pizza even the garlic boneless chicken tasted weird never go to this place
Rebecca Schermerhorn
Do not waste your time or money! Went there today for the first time under it's new ownership. They clearly should not be in this type of business. We ordered two Chicken Caesar Salads and an Italian Mix Sub. I was told 25 minutes, it took 40 minutes while watching the employees shuffle around doing nothing. We did add two slices of pepperoni pizza when we got there and that was done before our phone order was. The bread was stale on the sub and the salads weren't even close to half the size they were before. Apparently, they do not know that parmesan cheese goes on a Caesar Salad either. Also, the chicken used to be grilled fresh when ordered. Now, it's pre-cooked and stone cold. One of the salads was inedible due to white, plastic stings being in the salad. We used to order from this establishment at least three days a week. Now, under the new ownership, we will not be going back ever. So disappointed and disgusted.
Laura Amesse
Will never eat here again. The new ownership have not a clue what they are doing or make food. Its very deploreable to see such an amazing establishment go down the hill in just a couple of days. Catskill needs Marc Amthony's origanal team to come back please
Orien Playz
Got a pizza at an amazing price, best pizza place ever
danny phillips
The pizza here is phenominal! Price is good and the people are very nice. I just stopped in for a slice and the whole thing was amazing but the crust especially was done so crisp and perfect and I cannot seem to find another place that has that good of a crust nor pizza overall you must try!?
Sue Lester
First time I ordered from this amazing place they were friendly and the food was out of this world
Nathaniel Galloway
Great food, he makes a top notch pizza.Though I recommend getting a little extra sauce.They offer a variety of specials and the Realty brokerage I work for has use them for our catering on multiple occasions.
Andy Chase
Vacationing from Massachusetts, stopped at Mark Anthony's. Had appetizers and dinner. Everything was very good from the mozzarella sticks and garlic knots to the subs and pizza. Highly recommend this place. Also had a chance to talk to the owner, very nice guy and passionate and it carries over to the food he prepares!
Tommy Glock
Small dine in area with a BIG taste! We are out of towners that LOVED this pizza and mozzarella sticks. Owner took the time to welcome us and male sure we were happy with everything. We were.
Pamela Nichols
Vacationing from Massachusetts, searched up nearby restaurants this came up. Everything was amazing. Garlic knots with real garlic and buttery flavor. Mozzarella sticks were yummy. Pizza was delicious. Garlic parmesan boneless wings were so flavorful. My dtr had Philly cheese steak sub, she said it was the best she has ever had. The subs and portions are huge!! Bring your appetite! Definitely would recommend.
Best pizza around, hands down! Try the white pizza!
Denise Davis
Just picked up a large pizza with onions snd black olives . Awesome tasting pizza
Cletus VanDamme
Best pizza I have ever had in my life. And the owner is fantastic.
Steve Stone
Have stopped in a few times. Food is always fresh and delicious. Pizza is very good. Eating the two cheese slice lunch special right now. So good. Highly recommend you try Marc Anthony’s for dining in or takeout. 5 stars from me!
Mary B
The Food and people was wonderful. We had Been traveling all day when we found them. The food came fast but we were never hurried
I got a pepperoni pizza and a meat lovers Pizza on January 15, 2022 and it was the worst Pizza I've ever had. This new ownership does not know how to cook a pizza even the garlic boneless chicken tasted weird never go to this place
Do not waste your time or money! Went there today for the first time under it's new ownership. They clearly should not be in this type of business. We ordered two Chicken Caesar Salads and an Italian Mix Sub. I was told 25 minutes, it took 40 minutes while watching the employees shuffle around doing nothing. We did add two slices of pepperoni pizza when we got there and that was done before our phone order was. The bread was stale on the sub and the salads weren't even close to half the size they were before. Apparently, they do not know that parmesan cheese goes on a Caesar Salad either. Also, the chicken used to be grilled fresh when ordered. Now, it's pre-cooked and stone cold. One of the salads was inedible due to white, plastic stings being in the salad. We used to order from this establishment at least three days a week. Now, under the new ownership, we will not be going back ever. So disappointed and disgusted.
Will never eat here again. The new ownership have not a clue what they are doing or make food. Its very deploreable to see such an amazing establishment go down the hill in just a couple of days. Catskill needs Marc Amthony's origanal team to come back please
Got a pizza at an amazing price, best pizza place ever
The pizza here is phenominal! Price is good and the people are very nice. I just stopped in for a slice and the whole thing was amazing but the crust especially was done so crisp and perfect and I cannot seem to find another place that has that good of a crust nor pizza overall you must try!?
First time I ordered from this amazing place they were friendly and the food was out of this world
Great food, he makes a top notch pizza.Though I recommend getting a little extra sauce.They offer a variety of specials and the Realty brokerage I work for has use them for our catering on multiple occasions.
Vacationing from Massachusetts, stopped at Mark Anthony's. Had appetizers and dinner. Everything was very good from the mozzarella sticks and garlic knots to the subs and pizza. Highly recommend this place. Also had a chance to talk to the owner, very nice guy and passionate and it carries over to the food he prepares!
Small dine in area with a BIG taste! We are out of towners that LOVED this pizza and mozzarella sticks. Owner took the time to welcome us and male sure we were happy with everything. We were.
Vacationing from Massachusetts, searched up nearby restaurants this came up. Everything was amazing. Garlic knots with real garlic and buttery flavor. Mozzarella sticks were yummy. Pizza was delicious. Garlic parmesan boneless wings were so flavorful. My dtr had Philly cheese steak sub, she said it was the best she has ever had. The subs and portions are huge!! Bring your appetite! Definitely would recommend.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best pizza around, hands down! Try the white pizza!
Just picked up a large pizza with onions snd black olives . Awesome tasting pizza
Best pizza I have ever had in my life. And the owner is fantastic.
Have stopped in a few times. Food is always fresh and delicious. Pizza is very good. Eating the two cheese slice lunch special right now. So good. Highly recommend you try Marc Anthony’s for dining in or takeout. 5 stars from me!
The Food and people was wonderful. We had Been traveling all day when we found them. The food came fast but we were never hurried
Loading...