Really nice authentic place, friendly waitress. Price is a little high, for the entree ( 6 Coconut Shrimp) 18 Bucks was a bit hefty. But the rest was fine. Unfortunately there was a drunk man screaming lound in his phone for the entire time. Would recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dana L
Not great, unfortunately. A good portion of our food came out cold and poorly prepared. Fish that came with fish & chips seemed like it was from the frozen section of a supermarket, which isn’t what you’d expect in a place that sells fresh fish. Server was friendly & attentive, though.
Linda Hill
Nice place good food
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Al Warrell
Best place for seafood on long island
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Clams, Lobster Roll, Seafood, Oysters on the Half Shell
wayne jeanes
Outside is loud due to traffic. Fra diavolo was tasty but costly, couple pieces of bread would have been nice to sop up sauce. We order out a lot from here, basic seafood joint, not fancy. Fresh seafood on display inside also to purchase.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Kai Ng
Service was good. Foods were at best mediocre. No plans to ever return.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
George Sharratd
Visiting Long Island, NY after a too long absence. I drove by Atlantic Seafood and it looked just right for lunch. I was not disappointed. They featured Fresh sea food and good beer. Just what I wanted.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Clams
Rachel Tomasky
I've wanted to try this place for a while, and I'm so glad we did this weekend. The food was great, the crab 🦀 lovers platter was TO DIE FOR. The lobster was fresh !!
The shrimp cocktail was made fresh there and very good. We had a great dinner and service from Sarah was fantastic too!
We will be back.
Andrew Kirwin
Best burger around, service was great too.
Richard Elling
Wow… one of the worst Lobster Rolls I’ve ever had reminded me of tuna fish, not one lump of lobster for $41… Manager was completely unapologetic they could care less…. Tried crab cakes / soup Ordinary seafood overpriced * Honorable mention to the curly fries….. at least they know how to operate a fryer
Very good seafood and service. Great atmosphere with the fishing theme.
Wheelchair accessibility: The front and side door are wheelchair accessible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Bisque, Seafood
María Matute
I loved it
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Rita Victoria
Unfortunately I had a bad experience on a very busy Saturday night. But the food is delicious and good portions. Not enough staff. Only one person to clean up tables. Full drinks in small, weak, plastic glasses. Hot coffee served in paper cups. Add all the plates and stuff piling up on the small, unstable table with a handicap person. Coffee was everywhere. Orders didn’t come as requested. It was a bit chaotic. At busy times not a place for small children, large people or disabled to dine indoors.
Kelly Raia
Excellent as always! Fresh food, yummy and great service.
Michele E
Went here on a Sunday night around 6p. We were seated right away. We requested inside seating so there would be less flying bugs in the middle of July. Really like how casual the restaurant is. They use plastic utensils and plates. Service was okay. Was fine until the end where it seemed our waitress kind of forgot about us. There was a party of five of us and the bill was $300. The following is what we ordered and our thoughts: -seared sesame crusted tuna: appetizer served with a side of coleslaw. Great taste and the Asian sauce was delicious, however it could’ve been a little less seared. -clams: appetizer with butter and broth. Tasty and local clams. -lobster Bisque: great flavor. No chunks of lobster meat in the soup but still great flavor. Served with oyster crackers. -the curly works burger w/ curly fries: burger cooked to requested temperature well. Comes with a pickle. Fries were a tad cold. -seafood lovers platter broiled: comes with shrimp, flounder filet and bay scallops in a garlic butter marinade. Very good and flavorful. Served with one side, with was vegetable- broccoli. Ordered an additional side of Mac and cheese. Broccoli needed salt and butter. No salt or pepper at the tables. Mac and cheese was cheesy and perfect! -stuffed flounder with seafood stuffing w/ coleslaw: tasty and stuffing was super, perfect amount of food. -sliced brisket, w/ sauce on side and curly fries: amazing taste in the meat and very soft and fall apart. Didn’t even need the sauce on the side. -brown butter cod: it was delicious and would order again.
Overall would come back, especially for the market.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cod, Flounder, Tuna, Lobster Bisque, The Curly Works Burger, Seafood
Really nice authentic place, friendly waitress.
Price is a little high, for the entree ( 6 Coconut Shrimp) 18 Bucks was a bit hefty. But the rest was fine.
Unfortunately there was a drunk man screaming lound in his phone for the entire time.
Would recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not great, unfortunately. A good portion of our food came out cold and poorly prepared. Fish that came with fish & chips seemed like it was from the frozen section of a supermarket, which isn’t what you’d expect in a place that sells fresh fish. Server was friendly & attentive, though.
Nice place good food
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best place for seafood on long island
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Clams, Lobster Roll, Seafood, Oysters on the Half Shell
Outside is loud due to traffic. Fra diavolo was tasty but costly, couple pieces of bread would have been nice to sop up sauce. We order out a lot from here, basic seafood joint, not fancy. Fresh seafood on display inside also to purchase.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Service was good. Foods were at best mediocre. No plans to ever return.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Visiting Long Island, NY after a too long absence. I drove by Atlantic Seafood and it looked just right for lunch. I was not disappointed.
They featured Fresh sea food and good beer. Just what I wanted.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Clams
I've wanted to try this place for a while, and I'm so glad we did this weekend. The food was great, the crab 🦀 lovers platter was TO DIE FOR. The lobster was fresh !! The shrimp cocktail was made fresh there and very good. We had a great dinner and service from Sarah was fantastic too! We will be back.
Best burger around, service was great too.
Wow… one of the worst Lobster Rolls I’ve ever had reminded me of tuna fish, not one lump of lobster for $41… Manager was completely unapologetic they could care less…. Tried crab cakes / soup Ordinary seafood overpriced
* Honorable mention to the curly fries….. at least they know how to operate a fryer
Recommended dishes: Fries
Restaurantji Recommends
Very good seafood and service. Great atmosphere with the fishing theme.
Wheelchair accessibility: The front and side door are wheelchair accessible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Bisque, Seafood
I loved it
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Unfortunately I had a bad experience on a very busy Saturday night. But the food is delicious and good portions. Not enough staff. Only one person to clean up tables. Full drinks in small, weak, plastic glasses. Hot coffee served in paper cups. Add all the plates and stuff piling up on the small, unstable table with a handicap person. Coffee was everywhere. Orders didn’t come as requested. It was a bit chaotic. At busy times not a place for small children, large people or disabled to dine indoors.
Excellent as always! Fresh food, yummy and great service.
Went here on a Sunday night around 6p. We were seated right away. We requested inside seating so there would be less flying bugs in the middle of July.
Really like how casual the restaurant is. They use plastic utensils and plates.
Service was okay. Was fine until the end where it seemed our waitress kind of forgot about us.
There was a party of five of us and the bill was $300.
The following is what we ordered and our thoughts:
-seared sesame crusted tuna: appetizer served with a side of coleslaw. Great taste and the Asian sauce was delicious, however it could’ve been a little less seared.
-clams: appetizer with butter and broth. Tasty and local clams.
-lobster Bisque: great flavor. No chunks of lobster meat in the soup but still great flavor. Served with oyster crackers.
-the curly works burger w/ curly fries: burger cooked to requested temperature well. Comes with a pickle. Fries were a tad cold.
-seafood lovers platter broiled: comes with shrimp, flounder filet and bay scallops in a garlic butter marinade. Very good and flavorful. Served with one side, with was vegetable- broccoli. Ordered an additional side of Mac and cheese. Broccoli needed salt and butter. No salt or pepper at the tables. Mac and cheese was cheesy and perfect!
-stuffed flounder with seafood stuffing w/ coleslaw: tasty and stuffing was super, perfect amount of food.
-sliced brisket, w/ sauce on side and curly fries: amazing taste in the meat and very soft and fall apart. Didn’t even need the sauce on the side.
-brown butter cod: it was delicious and would order again.
Overall would come back, especially for the market.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cod, Flounder, Tuna, Lobster Bisque, The Curly Works Burger, Seafood
Loading...