Mama's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Centereach Mall, Centereach
(631) 585-1498
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Centereach Mall, Centereach
(631) 585-1498
Last pie we purchased was pre cooked and pre sliced ask for well done, tasted like cardboard.
Great food with a warm comfortable atmosphere. Pretty decor and authentic food. A great place for small gatherings and quiet dinners .
The pizza is excellent. I haven't tried any of the dinners or sandwiches. But I would highly recommend this place! They've captured the ambiance of a traditional authentic Italian restaurant imo.
We just had takeout from Mama's in Centereach. We ordered Chicken alla Mama and linguine with clam sauce. Food was ready, hot and tasted great.
I'll start by saying we have been there before and enjoyed it. But in our last experience we walked in and there was a lot of joking amongst the very young staff. It was no toilet paper in the bathroom and not one of the tables was clean. My wife and I were not confident that the staff would act professionally while cooking our food
Good pizza. Crunchy, thin crust. Very tasty. Definitely worth a return trip
Has potential of 4 star.Its more a 3 star.It depends wich cook is on.Portions are good size.Pizza is good I guess it's by preference. To me it's a must try.The dough is like Italian bread .AWSOM. ?
Best pizza I’ve ever tasted absolutely delicious?????
I have ordered from this place for the past 2 years and it has gotten worse and worse as time goes by. I ordered a well done pie with extra cheese . I got an under cooked pie with all the cheese to one side and the center soaked with saucy substance. The guy flat out told me he cut the pie and all was well as if I somehow sabotaged my own pizza. This place sucks
We went there as a group of about 30 people. The food was fantastic and the service was excellent.
Restaurantji Recommends
In and out quick and great food
My son and I dine-in often.Their garlic bread crust pizza is to die for! Must have at least once a week. Always fresh. The best pizza I've ever had, by far. Employees are friendly. Never had a less than perfect experience.
The regular slice is way to thick. It does not even flop down when you pick it up. Like a stiff board. Service is good. Pinwheels are good.
Food was good but place was a complete mess. Instead of doing every other table to social distance they closed off almost all their tables and the ones u can sit at are filthy. Dirtiest pizza place I have ever been 2. Sauce and crumbs all over table and seat. Floor looked like it hadn't been cleaned in awhile as well.
The garlic knot slice is my new go-to
Loading...