The Cookie Shop

115 Mark Tree Rd Suite 6, Centereach
(631) 285-2962

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Tina Swezey

The people were so sweet and the cookies were so good definitely coming back

Salsaconsoul

My Son ordered six cookies macaroons for my birthday and Mother’s Day from Florida and had them deliver These were the worst cookies I’ve ever tasted. They were complete stale full of sugar. Even the filling was full of sugar. They were very very small which was fine but they were horrible. I can’t even tell My Son how badly these cookies taste it. You guys should be ashamed of yourselves. The people will buy these things for their mother and their fathers and they are just sugar syrup some kind of concoction no flavor and you charge people money. I’m so disgusted.

diana vey

Came here to get cookies for my wedding, very cute little shop and the staff is just as sweet as the desserts! I gave her a brief description of what I wanted and they came out perfect, even better than what I asked for! Would highly recommend coming here for anything custom or even to stop in and grab a sweet treat. Thanks again for making my special day sweeter!

Sandra Eybs

The Cookie Shop never disappoints! We’ve ordered custom cakes as well as many items from the case. Everything is utterly delicious and very fresh. Their tart cakes have the freshest fruit inside and they’re light and indulgent. The cookies and cookie sandwiches are fresh and huge! The macarons are divine! We’ve ordered them as teacher gifts, for parties, celebrations, and for gluten free friends. The flavors change monthly and they’re interesting and seasonal. The owners are friendly and welcoming and the space is simply beautiful.

Debra Saunders

The shop is so pretty and now they are also serving delicious soups. There is some seating there if you want to enjoy soup and a cookie.
The custom cakes I have ordered several times both numbers and chocolate chip cookie towers.

Christopher Baiata

Hidden gem of a cookie shop I stumbled upon yesterday!

Had a wide variety of macaroons, and cookies which I will be going back to try ASAP!

Got two awesome cookies to start and they were excellent 🙃

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jordan Lumley

cookies are very goods driver dean approves

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

hiram santiago

The design and flavor, omg this cakes are the best

Erik Briar

🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

Biscuits and gravy—it's like breakfast and a hug had a baby. I walked into this place just expecting to fill my belly, but I left with a full heart and the belief that everything in life would be okay as long as I had another plate of these biscuits and gravy. The biscuits were fluffier than a cloud having a good hair day, and the gravy—oh, the gravy! It was so rich and savory that I’m pretty sure it could pay off my student loans if it wanted to.

One bite and my taste buds started singing gospel, complete with a choir and tambourines. I don't know what kind of wizardry goes into making something that can soothe the soul and unclog your arteries at the same time, but whatever it is, they’ve got it down to a science.

Forget therapy—just get yourself a plate of these biscuits and gravy. Guaranteed to solve all your problems, or at least make you too full to care!

The cookies are good too, but you already know that.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The Nick Singh Foundation Inc.

Our foundation recently hosted a Sweet 16 for an extraordinary individual who has bravely faced a life-threatening illness. We were delighted to partner with The Cookie Shoppe for the occasion. We can’t thank Stefanie enough for generously donating the beautiful tart cake for our guest’s special day! Your creation was not only a stunning centerpiece but also a delicious treat that everyone loved. It truly added a special touch to the celebration and made the moment of cutting the cake even more memorable. We’re incredibly grateful for your thoughtfulness and skill—thank you for making the Sweet 16 unforgettable! Highly recommend!

Lauren Ashley Jainarine

Stephanie and her team created the most beautiful and unique butterfly cake for the sweet 16 we hosted. It was so beautiful we almost couldn’t cut it but it was delicious! Will definitely be ordering for her in the future

Larissa Damato

It was my moms birthday and my mom and daughter don’t eat traditional “cake”… I tried to find an alternative as this was a last minute surprise party!

Not only did we discover the best alternative to cake but we found our favorite place to order dessert from!
They made me a 65 (casino theme) last minute cookie cake in 4 days. It was a HUGE hit at my mom’s party and they actually got to enjoy dessert!! We are ordering another for my daughter Quinceañera! (Even getting a small one to keep home that we don’t plan on sharing!)
They are amazing and kind and so so accommodating!!
I highly recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bethany Perkins

This was my first time here, I purchased the creamsicle macaroon and snickerdoodle cookie sandwich. Both tasted divine! Customer service was amazing! It smelled wonderful inside. I will definitely be back!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Danielle Torre

This place is was discovered serendipitously and I feel like I found pastry heaven. If the Lord wanted a French macaroon, he'd come here ?

Then store itself is beautiful and inviting. Love the eclectic staff as well. They're artistic ability when decorating anything really is magnificently beautiful and elegant.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mike Walsh

One of the best tart cakes Ive ever had! Also the cupcakes , macaroons and cookies are delicious! 10/10

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...