The pizza here is consistently pretty good and my customer experience has always been pleasant. Tonight, however is the second time in the last 2 months that the bottom of the pie has a burnt residue on it! The oven needs to be brushed and cleaned!!! Hopefully they read this and clean that oven!!! Maybe just an oversight, it's hard enough to run a small business these days, but let's go Jimmy's, clean that oven and get back to cranking out nice, fresh pizza !
Adela Smith
Ordered take out, when I received the order from Seamless, they forgot the soda. Called restaurant, 1st person didn’t understand the situation. 2nd person stated they could bring me my soda I purchased, but would have to tip AGAIN bc it’s their driver not seamless. (I had already tipped, and paid a delivery fee)They blamed everything on the Seamless driver for not picking up the entire order (but they’re the ones that give it to him & check he takes everything) and said they could only refund me, they would not deliver it. Then they hung up on me.
Food: 4
Service: 1
Bill O.
Tried the other day to give the pizza a try since we moved locally. Walked in the door to a angry counter girl cursing at an employee in the back of the store. When I approached the counter to order another employee asks what do I want? I said pizza maybe?? He then tells me your going to have to wait nothings ready yet. I looked him in the face and laughed and walked right out. This place is a joke. Like previous reviews of this place the customer service and respect is NOT here. Go elsewhere to support small businesses that are pleasant.
Jack M.
Terrific pizza. Fair price. Good service. This was my forte time there (having lived in Huntington for years) I will now become a regular.
Sueann Palma
Best garlic knots iv ever had ate a whole 12 by myself !!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Cheese Pizza
Melissa F.
Just got a pizza. 1st, delivered to the wrong house. Second, folded over in the box, third ordered well done and its barely cooked. I'm done. Used to be good. Been a customer for 20 years. No more
justin mednick
This is one terrible place, I order 10 pies for a high school basketball team and ask for them to be delivered in between 6:45 and 7 pm and the guy came 25 minutes early when the basketball game goes until 6;45 and by the time the kids ate it was cold, I called to make a complaint and the girl at the counter was so rude and when I finally got the manager he was worse and literally told me to screw myself after I paid $200 including tip for 10 pies.
CPNY
I like the regular slice here, and here's a little secret-probably the best pizza in the Northport/Centerport area.
R Niz (Culinaria73)
Cheese Pizza not very good, salads always swimming in dressing and pricing is whacked!! I try and give it a chance hoping it’s always gonna be better but! Sorry
Ashley DelGiudice
Love this pizza place! The salad slices are delicious and they offer Italian ices which I love!
Perfect crust every time! Speaking with the owner one night he explained that every pizza he makes it's like he's doing it for his family and I believe it. Jimmy's does it right!!!
Gina
One star should be less. Emily and her girlfriend actually hung up on me 3 times when I called to say that I liked my food. You will NEVER see me again! Horrible treatment of a loyal customer! Maybe you can hire some little girls that were raised right!
G B.
Jimmy's is a family favorite. No visits without an order of white pizza. THE BEST. Any time the family is in town Jimmy's will be on the dinner menu.
J McGuire
We used Jimmy’s to cater our daughter’s 3rd birthday party. The food - salads, pizzas, pasta, apps was all hot and delicious. Delivered on time and all correct. Thank you!
Shelli Price
Brst Garlic knots ever, in fact whole menu is outrageous delish
The pizza here is consistently pretty good and my customer experience has always been pleasant. Tonight, however is the second time in the last 2 months that the bottom of the pie has a burnt residue on it! The oven needs to be brushed and cleaned!!! Hopefully they read this and clean that oven!!! Maybe just an oversight, it's hard enough to run a small business these days, but let's go Jimmy's, clean that oven and get back to cranking out nice, fresh pizza !
Ordered take out, when I received the order from Seamless, they forgot the soda. Called restaurant, 1st person didn’t understand the situation. 2nd person stated they could bring me my soda I purchased, but would have to tip AGAIN bc it’s their driver not seamless. (I had already tipped, and paid a delivery fee)They blamed everything on the Seamless driver for not picking up the entire order (but they’re the ones that give it to him & check he takes everything) and said they could only refund me, they would not deliver it. Then they hung up on me.
Food: 4
Service: 1
Tried the other day to give the pizza a try since we moved locally. Walked in the door to a angry counter girl cursing at an employee in the back of the store. When I approached the counter to order another employee asks what do I want? I said pizza maybe?? He then tells me your going to have to wait nothings ready yet. I looked him in the face and laughed and walked right out. This place is a joke. Like previous reviews of this place the customer service and respect is NOT here. Go elsewhere to support small businesses that are pleasant.
Terrific pizza. Fair price. Good service. This was my forte time there (having lived in Huntington for years) I will now become a regular.
Best garlic knots iv ever had ate a whole 12 by myself !!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Cheese Pizza
Just got a pizza. 1st, delivered to the wrong house. Second, folded over in the box, third ordered well done and its barely cooked. I'm done. Used to be good. Been a customer for 20 years. No more
This is one terrible place, I order 10 pies for a high school basketball team and ask for them to be delivered in between 6:45 and 7 pm and the guy came 25 minutes early when the basketball game goes until 6;45 and by the time the kids ate it was cold, I called to make a complaint and the girl at the counter was so rude and when I finally got the manager he was worse and literally told me to screw myself after I paid $200 including tip for 10 pies.
I like the regular slice here, and here's a little secret-probably the best pizza in the Northport/Centerport area.
Cheese Pizza not very good, salads always swimming in dressing and pricing is whacked!! I try and give it a chance hoping it’s always gonna be better but! Sorry
Love this pizza place! The salad slices are delicious and they offer Italian ices which I love!
Restaurantji Recommends
Perfect crust every time! Speaking with the owner one night he explained that every pizza he makes it's like he's doing it for his family and I believe it. Jimmy's does it right!!!
One star should be less. Emily and her girlfriend actually hung up on me 3 times when I called to say that I liked my food. You will NEVER see me again! Horrible treatment of a loyal customer! Maybe you can hire some little girls that were raised right!
Jimmy's is a family favorite. No visits without an order of white pizza. THE BEST. Any time the family is in town Jimmy's will be on the dinner menu.
We used Jimmy’s to cater our daughter’s 3rd birthday party. The food - salads, pizzas, pasta, apps was all hot and delicious. Delivered on time and all correct. Thank you!
Brst Garlic knots ever, in fact whole menu is outrageous delish