The pizza recipe was better under the prior management. The man in the picture no longer works there, and he had good conversation while waiting for my order. They need to bring back the prior recipe!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Phil Ryan
This place was great in the early 90’s, not so good anymore. Food is decent at best and way overpriced. Much better options around.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Miss Pretty
Clean, relaxed pizzeria. I had CBR slice and took a POP hero home for later. I ordered pick-up via GH. I ate my slice inside.(They do offer dine-in) Delicious ?Parking: Safe. Very well lit. Inside a shopping plaza, so the lot is shared but has lots of spaceKid-friendliness: Booths. Tables w/ chairs attached.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Slice
daisy d.
Vegan pizza so good. Delivered within 30 mins. Love the customer service and how they always accommodate to my dietary restrictions
Jonathan Gingo
Nice staff, my first time there, delicious food, I'm Italian I must say good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cyber A.
best pizza in long islnd. the vibe of this pizzeria gives family makes you feel so at home and cozy. omg wait heres the best part. they made me a vegan pizza with vegan substitute meat. it's so yummy. yesterday i had the vegan spaghetti with the vegan substitute meatballs. hopefully they'll add vegan to their menu i love it here
Psalm Eighty2Six
Dang that pizza is frigging good!
Food: 5
Service: 5
samantha wolfe
I used to be a big fan ordered on the slice app a lot but then I ordered in person when it was not available on the app and I will not be returning they are very unsanitary no one wears gloves ever the guy taking my order answered his cell phone from his pocket took a call while slicing up the pizza then proceeded to get the toppings for the pizza bare handed digging in the container and then assemble the slice no gloves never even washed his hands I had already paid and then when he handed me the pizza and I wanted to put my garlic and red pepper flakes on it the pizza was cold meatball slice was a joke he took a meatball cut it up and slapped it on the slice with a dash of extra cheese as a regular here I’m completely disgusted and turned off of the place won’t order here again
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Karen M.
These people are the nicest sweetest you can imagine. I have ordered from them for years. My favorite is the regular pizza with extra crispy crust. Delivered.
If your looking for a good pizza spot this is it. You definitely get your monies worth here I eat here every chance I get.
Lance Johnson
The pizza was very skimpy on tomato sauce and dripped with oil. I was very hungry and did not have much time so I went to the nearest pizza shop. I certainly would not plan to go to Central
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Phil Norton
I’m not impressed. After multiple delays in my order (took almost an hour to deliver) I got two soggy cold slices and a salad I couldn’t eat because the delivery didn’t come with utensils. I was at a hotel which was clearly stated by both address and my order request. Honestly, even if it were warm, I’ve had better “NY style” pizza. Too bad, this was my first time to NY, and was really looking forward to it.
Food is top grade. Customer service is top notch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza recipe was better under the prior management. The man in the picture no longer works there, and he had good conversation while waiting for my order. They need to bring back the prior recipe!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
This place was great in the early 90’s, not so good anymore. Food is decent at best and way overpriced. Much better options around.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Clean, relaxed pizzeria. I had CBR slice and took a POP hero home for later. I ordered pick-up via GH. I ate my slice inside.(They do offer dine-in) Delicious ?Parking: Safe. Very well lit. Inside a shopping plaza, so the lot is shared but has lots of spaceKid-friendliness: Booths. Tables w/ chairs attached.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Slice
Vegan pizza so good. Delivered within 30 mins. Love the customer service and how they always accommodate to my dietary restrictions
Nice staff, my first time there, delicious food, I'm Italian I must say good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
best pizza in long islnd. the vibe of this pizzeria gives family makes you feel so at home and cozy. omg wait heres the best part. they made me a vegan pizza with vegan substitute meat. it's so yummy. yesterday i had the vegan spaghetti with the vegan substitute meatballs. hopefully they'll add vegan to their menu i love it here
Dang that pizza is frigging good!
Food: 5
Service: 5
I used to be a big fan ordered on the slice app a lot but then I ordered in person when it was not available on the app and I will not be returning they are very unsanitary no one wears gloves ever the guy taking my order answered his cell phone from his pocket took a call while slicing up the pizza then proceeded to get the toppings for the pizza bare handed digging in the container and then assemble the slice no gloves never even washed his hands I had already paid and then when he handed me the pizza and I wanted to put my garlic and red pepper flakes on it the pizza was cold meatball slice was a joke he took a meatball cut it up and slapped it on the slice with a dash of extra cheese as a regular here I’m completely disgusted and turned off of the place won’t order here again
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
These people are the nicest sweetest you can imagine. I have ordered from them for years. My favorite is the regular pizza with extra crispy crust. Delivered.
Restaurantji Recommends
I called for pick up, they said they lost the ticket, we waited. The pizza is salty and can not be consumed. Disgusting ?
Been coming here since the 80's it's still going strong! #CentralIslipStrong
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Regular Slice
If your looking for a good pizza spot this is it. You definitely get your monies worth here I eat here every chance I get.
The pizza was very skimpy on tomato sauce and dripped with oil. I was very hungry and did not have much time so I went to the nearest pizza shop. I certainly would not plan to go to Central
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
I’m not impressed. After multiple delays in my order (took almost an hour to deliver) I got two soggy cold slices and a salad I couldn’t eat because the delivery didn’t come with utensils. I was at a hotel which was clearly stated by both address and my order request. Honestly, even if it were warm, I’ve had better “NY style” pizza. Too bad, this was my first time to NY, and was really looking forward to it.