Stuff A Bagel

166 Wheeler Rd, Central Islip
(631) 582-5222

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jamie Ganuzza

Don’t know what well done bacon is :(

Trish Hase

Just go somewhere else! Unpleasant staff, overpriced and stingy. Usually when you order a NY bagel with cream cheese it's LOADED, this one had pretty nothing on it. The OJ carton had mold on it when I opened it (had to throw it out) gross!

Tiffany Lee

I get it…times are rough but I just paid $8.50 for a Bacon Egg & Cheese on a Bagel. 🤯🤯🤯 unbelievable

Marlyn Duran

Not sure why this place doesn’t have more stars! Whenever I go, the service is quick and friendly. I never wait more than ten minutes, even when it’s multiple specialty sandwiches/ bagels.
The price is solid even with egg prices being out of control right now with the bird flu. I paid $15.13 for what I’ve paid $22 at other deli’s. Delicious, and would recommend!

Lesli Cruz

Today was my first time trying their French toast, and they were amazing!! I’ll definitely go again.

Michelle Shaw

I saw the lady the register grab everyone bagels with her bare hands AFTER handling money. Had she touched their food without charging them first I would’ve given her the benefit of the doubt and assumed her hands were just washed and still clean but she did it after touching money. I’m astonished no one else said anything to her. She also seemed offended by me asking her to either use gloves before handling my food or the parchment paper.

Larissa Reyes

I got a poopy seed bagel with strawberry cream cheese. the bagel was stale & they barely put any cream cheese. i wouldn’t go back here.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Review Ortiz

W eats good food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ada Wong

I've been coming here since I was in high school. The only complaint is they aren't open all day! I get cravings for their Bagels / sandwiches.The fact that their Asian owned is also a plus since they have offer some signature asian snacks and drinks as well as quick Ramen bowls. If your in the mood for some noodles instead.I normally get bacon egg and cheese on a roll. SPK.But today I was extra hungry and craving a lox bagel.I never ordered one before and the guy was very helpful.Got a lox on an everything bagel. I called it in ahead of time since I was worried they wouldn't have any left it was about 1pm.They close at 2PM! And sundays at 1pm. Same as most breakfast places that open at 6am . Remmeber they need to be there even eariler to prepare!Overall had a good dining experience the tables and floors were clean. Lots of cold drinks stocked. Coffee and tea available to make. Some pastries for Dessert and prepared foods as well.Always nostalgic coming back here!It's the only place I go!Brings be right back to 20 years ago walking from the high school to get breakfast/Lunch.Going strong!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagel

Efrain Hernandez

Worst bagel I have ever had. They claimed it was an everything bagel, was not. Barely toasted butter was margarine. No heat inside, avoid this place and stuff yourself elsewhere.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Mc1madayas

Pretty good food. Ordered sausage, egg and cheese on a roll. So good ? added the salt, pepper ketchup and mayonnaise. Love

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anthony Welch

Bagel tasted old ?? 10$ minimum should be a crime for this place

praxedes escuderochorres

The white woman is rude

David Damsky

Worst bagel I've had in a long time. Very hard to chew. So hard it wasn't even cut in half all the way. 2 stars cause the Lady makes the eggs really good she barely mixes the white/yellow and keeps some yolk still bleeding, that was nice. not like other places that just scramble them.

Sue Franco

Do not go here!! Absolutely ridiculous price gouging!! A western omelette, with peppers, onions, tomatoes and cheese. NO bacon, or ham or potatoes or toast or coffee of any kind. Just the omelette and they had the audacity to charge 10.88 This folks is price gouging and taking advantage of the public at its finest. Complete rip off. Avoid them at all costs!

Loading...