Sugar Shack Pub'n Eatery

1405 Old Rd, Clymer
(716) 355-4141

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Michelle Colyar

Family get together

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kristin Polz

Wait staff was very friendly. A little bit longer wait for the pizza- that that's to be expected with real wood fired pizza. Pizza was excellent. Meatball sub was delicious. Fries pretty good. Prices fairly reasonable- especially for a resort. The atmosphere was the coolest. Just perfect for a ski resort. Loved the decor and the vibe! Can't wait to come back! Needs a cuter name. Sugar Shack doesn't really fit this place.

Ted Spilka

I went there with 3 other bus drivers to eat while waiting for our group to finish skiing. The waiter was very freindly and thanked us for bring people to the ski resort. He took very good care of us the whole time we were there. Our food was great especially the potatoe soup. We are heading back there this weekend and we will definitely be eating there again.

Alex

Great spot to stop and eat as long as you take it for what it is.

J D

Well it's 1 star and better then no stars but have to give at least 1 star. Terrible experience. Walk in for a take out order and didn't just screw up the order once but twice. Unbelievable. Didn't even offer anything for the extra time waiting because of their screw up. Bad 1st experience and last time there for me. Simple pizza and a terrible experience. Enjoy...

Hank Tankerous

My wife and I went there yesterday on a new years eve outing. The food was good The place is very nice. However the bartender ruined the night for us. He was obnoxious, loud, and singing. The most annoying bartender I have ever seen. We waited for our food just so we could leave. Never again

Joshua Elmer

Nice place to eat and drink when at the mountain.

Jessica DemMc

We ate here after a day of tubing. Walking into the restaurant I thought it was beautiful and had high hopes for the food. Our waitress was great and handled our table of 9 well. Our check was well over $200 and when you’re spending that amount of money to eat somewhere, you’d expect good food. My husband and I decided to share a chicken Cesar salad and a meatza calzone. The calzone was hardly warm inside but edible. The salad was the worst salad I’ve ever had. The chicken was like the “microwaveable” chicken you can buy in a bag and the lettuce was legitimately out of one of those dole salad kits, it was wilted and tasted awful. The Cesar dressing had a terrible taste. For a $14 salad you should be served fresh Romain lettuce with good quality chicken, and should be edible. We didn’t even eat it. Next time we will go outside of peak n peak for food.

Caitlin Dobran

Amazing Calzones! My choice for dining whenever I'm skiing

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jessica Reviews

We ate here after a day of tubing. Walking into the restaurant I thought it was beautiful and had high hopes for the food. Our waitress was great and handled our table of 9 well. Our check was well over $200 and when you’re spending that amount of money to eat somewhere, you’d expect good food. My husband and I decided to share a chicken Cesar salad and a meatza calzone. The calzone was hardly warm inside but edible. The salad was the worst salad I’ve ever had. The chicken was like the “microwaveable” chicken you can buy in a bag and the lettuce was legitimately out of one of those dole salad kits, it was wilted and tasted awful. The Cesar dressing had a terrible taste. For a $14 salad you should be served fresh Romain lettuce with good quality chicken, and should be edible. We didn’t even eat it. Next time we will go outside of peak n peak for food.

Jessica Demetreu McQuay

We ate here after a day of tubing. Walking into the restaurant I thought it was beautiful and had high hopes for the food. Our waitress was great and handled our table of 9 well. Our check was well over $200 and when you’re spending that amount of money to eat somewhere, you’d expect good food. My husband and I decided to share a chicken Cesar salad and a meatza calzone. The calzone was hardly warm inside but edible. The salad was the worst salad I’ve ever had. The chicken was like the “microwaveable” chicken you can buy in a bag and the lettuce was legitimately out of one of those dole salad kits, it was wilted and tasted awful. The Cesar dressing had a terrible taste. For a $14 salad you should be served fresh Romain lettuce with good quality chicken, and should be edible. We didn’t even eat it. Next time we will go outside of peak n peak for food.

Brian Surtz

Very good food for a ski resort.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tom Giordano

Pizza is way overpriced, small, and not good whatsoever. I large pizza is a personal size and $18! Do not expect much if ordering take out for pizza

Allison Calhoun

Not open Mondays, Tuesdays or Wednesday

Rashaad Thomas

Mid, bad service

Loading...