Like walking into a resturant owned by your family. They tossed the pizza for my boy and let him watch them make it. So good!!
Jacqueline Williams
we went in to have a pizza. it was undercooked and tasted weird....the hot sauce is not hot sauce. the mild is even worse. really disappointed.
richard walpole
Always enjoy stopping by when visiting.
trica
Fantastic food and always quick service.
Pejy Kash
We were excited to try Pizza Shack after hearing good things, but unfortunately our first visit didn’t quite meet expectations. We didn’t order pizza (which we realize now might’ve been our first mistake), and maybe we just caught them on an off day but the rest of the food really missed the mark.
I ordered a grilled chicken sandwich and sadly had to toss most of it. The chicken was rubbery, oddly pink in the center, and had a strange plastic-like texture. We also tried the spaghetti and meatballs, which were overwhelmingly salty but still edible. The two orders of fries we got were cold, soggy, and felt like they had been sitting out for a while.
We’re giving them the benefit of the doubt and will try the pizza next time before we make any final judgments. Hoping for a much better experience on the next visit, if the pizza delivers, they’ll stay on our local rotation. But if not, we’ll likely move on.
Cory Westgate (Saint Baal-MAŠ)
By the slice, great price. Whole pie, price is high. The flavors are right, good crust, served by nice folks.
YEPPerino!!
Pulled off highway to get gas and a bite. Thought instead of commercial fast food would try a local spot. Nice pizza place in heart of Coblesville main street. Service was great, clerk was nice and friendly. We had ordered a few slices, meatball sub and buffalo chix with fries. Gotta say sub par. Fries were the best part and they were the freezer to fryer type. Sorry but just not good quality food.
Louie Radliff
Always got a good pizza there. Today ordered pickup,ready in 20 min,walked in 15 min. Already done,got home no hot cheese,or hot sauce dry crust.ricotti and sausage thrown on.real dry like crust premade gas station pie. Times have changed it was always good. Maybe somebody having a really bad day or didnt care.
Trinity Appell
My boyfriend and I have been wanting to try this place out for a while and we're happy we finally did. Everyone was super nice and the pizza tasted amazing and hot. I definitely recommend the bang bang chicken pizza and the white veggie pizza! Great place for college kids to sit and relax while getting something to eat or if you're just out and about in town!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, White Veggie Pizza, Boneless Chicken Wings
Pizza and pastas are always yummy here. It's our stop when we come home to visit.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Garden Salad, Wings Garlic Bread and Spaghetti with Meatballs, Calzone
Kalen Alaxanian
I'd give 10 stars if I could. Good lord the food is outstanding. Been going here since we moved to the area 7 years ago, never misses.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, White Veggie Pizza, Boneless Chicken Wings, Garden Salad, Wings Garlic Bread and Spaghetti with Meatballs, Calzone, Buffalo Chicken, Veg Pizza with Cheese and Charcuterie, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Wrap, Chicken Ceasars Salad, White Pizza
Josh Jung
Great food, even better service!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Fullford
Came in today and tried some taco pizza slices and they didn’t disappoint! I like when pizza places get creative, it had electric crust as Dave Portnoy would say and all their other varieties of slices looked great too. Met the owners son, really nice guy and I love the fact that this is a family owned and operated restaurant. The atmosphere? It just screams traditional Italian American, you won’t be disappointed! I’m told they even bake the bread for the subs fresh every day! I’ll be trying one of those next. Thanks for the good food guys, all the best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Parker Smith
Waitress was so friendly, she gave my kid crayons and coloring sheets and some stickers, the food was amazing, the dough is fresh and handmade! And the pizza was fairly priced for a large.
Kid-friendliness: Gave my kid some coloring sheets and she gave him some stickers!
Like walking into a resturant owned by your family. They tossed the pizza for my boy and let him watch them make it. So good!!
we went in to have a pizza. it was undercooked and tasted weird....the hot sauce is not hot sauce. the mild is even worse. really disappointed.
Always enjoy stopping by when visiting.
Fantastic food and always quick service.
We were excited to try Pizza Shack after hearing good things, but unfortunately our first visit didn’t quite meet expectations. We didn’t order pizza (which we realize now might’ve been our first mistake), and maybe we just caught them on an off day but the rest of the food really missed the mark.
I ordered a grilled chicken sandwich and sadly had to toss most of it. The chicken was rubbery, oddly pink in the center, and had a strange plastic-like texture. We also tried the spaghetti and meatballs, which were overwhelmingly salty but still edible. The two orders of fries we got were cold, soggy, and felt like they had been sitting out for a while.
We’re giving them the benefit of the doubt and will try the pizza next time before we make any final judgments. Hoping for a much better experience on the next visit, if the pizza delivers, they’ll stay on our local rotation. But if not, we’ll likely move on.
By the slice, great price. Whole pie, price is high. The flavors are right, good crust, served by nice folks.
Pulled off highway to get gas and a bite. Thought instead of commercial fast food would try a local spot. Nice pizza place in heart of Coblesville main street. Service was great, clerk was nice and friendly. We had ordered a few slices, meatball sub and buffalo chix with fries. Gotta say sub par. Fries were the best part and they were the freezer to fryer type. Sorry but just not good quality food.
Always got a good pizza there. Today ordered pickup,ready in 20 min,walked in 15 min. Already done,got home no hot cheese,or
hot sauce dry crust.ricotti and sausage thrown on.real dry like crust premade gas station pie. Times have changed it was always good. Maybe somebody having a really bad day or didnt care.
My boyfriend and I have been wanting to try this place out for a while and we're happy we finally did. Everyone was super nice and the pizza tasted amazing and hot. I definitely recommend the bang bang chicken pizza and the white veggie pizza! Great place for college kids to sit and relax while getting something to eat or if you're just out and about in town!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, White Veggie Pizza, Boneless Chicken Wings
Live 3.8 miles away, wouldn’t deliver.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza and pastas are always yummy here. It's our stop when we come home to visit.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Garden Salad, Wings Garlic Bread and Spaghetti with Meatballs, Calzone
I'd give 10 stars if I could. Good lord the food is outstanding. Been going here since we moved to the area 7 years ago, never misses.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, White Veggie Pizza, Boneless Chicken Wings, Garden Salad, Wings Garlic Bread and Spaghetti with Meatballs, Calzone, Buffalo Chicken, Veg Pizza with Cheese and Charcuterie, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Wrap, Chicken Ceasars Salad, White Pizza
Great food, even better service!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Came in today and tried some taco pizza slices and they didn’t disappoint! I like when pizza places get creative, it had electric crust as Dave Portnoy would say and all their other varieties of slices looked great too. Met the owners son, really nice guy and I love the fact that this is a family owned and operated restaurant. The atmosphere? It just screams traditional Italian American, you won’t be disappointed! I’m told they even bake the bread for the subs fresh every day! I’ll be trying one of those next. Thanks for the good food guys, all the best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Waitress was so friendly, she gave my kid crayons and coloring sheets and some stickers, the food was amazing, the dough is fresh and handmade! And the pizza was fairly priced for a large.
Kid-friendliness: Gave my kid some coloring sheets and she gave him some stickers!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Loading...